3 ms·
The claim that solar produces more CO2 than nuclear is quite dishonest. It may produce more right now, with the existing supply chain for materials. But in a
by pfdietz 4y ago
The claim that solar produces more CO2 than nuclear is quite dishonest.
It may produce more right now, with the existing supply chain for materials. But in a fossil-fuel free economy, there is no CO2 from fossil fuel combustion. Where are the CO2 emissions coming from? They could only be from manufacture of cement for concrete (calcination of limestone to calcium oxide and CO2.) PV doesn't have to use any concrete -- it can be mounted to the ground with steel earth anchors. Nuclear uses a lot of concrete.
The near term emissions of CO2 in construction of solar or nuclear are irrelevant, since they are swamped by the CO2 emission avoided as fossil fuels are displaced. Here, what matters is how rapidly the non-fossil alternatives can be rolled out, not what dribble of CO2 they produce directly.
As for levelized cost, the table lists the min/median/max cost of installed utility scale PV as 1700/3200/4300 $/kW. But the cost of utility scale PV in the US is already well below that minimum number. The footnotes give their sources as no later than 2013. PV prices have fallen greatly since that time (module prices per W down by about a factor of 4 in constant dollars.)
The min value for nuclear given is also absurd vs. actual experience with recent nuclear builds. The footnote says the data was from no later than 2013, before the EPR and APR1400 efforts went so disastrously wrong, when the "nuclear renaissance" had not fallen so flatly on its face. It also says (about nuclear):
"Limited recent data and/or original data are available in the published literature. More recent, (grey literature) sources provide investment cost and LCOE estimates
that are considerably higher than the ones shown here (Brandão et al., 2012)."
- Schroedingersat 4y ago> It may produce more right now, with the existing supply chain for materials. This hasn't been true for some time. There's simply not enough money. The solar module in a good location costs 0.7 cents per kWh installed. Although that can buy you a couple hundred grams of coal, doing literally anything with it uses up all the money. A 450W monocrystalline panel is under a kg of silicon, 50g of copper an a gram or so of silver. The neat thing about solar panel factories is they have a bunch of solar panels, and so tend to produce 30-90% of their own electricity, so the carbon footprint is almost entirely racking, shipping 20kg, and the 11kg or so per panel from the raw silicon (which uses 70% of the money). Meanwhile Uranium ore concentration is decreasing slightly faster than mining is getting more efficient.
- pfdietz 4y agoGood to know. I think the CO2 emission will be mostly from making the glass and aluminum, not the cells themselves. BTW, last I checked, reduction of silica to silicon is done with charcoal as the carbon source. Something about the porous nature of charcoal leading to better reaction with silicon monoxide vapor.