3 ms·
Well you are still at the mercy of whoever's maintaining the network, aka some random-ass people all over the world. Aside from the few main ones, crypto networ
by moffkalast 4y ago
Well you are still at the mercy of whoever's maintaining the network, aka some random-ass people all over the world. Aside from the few main ones, crypto networks are infamously ever changing and you're more likely to register a domain on something that won't even exist in 2 years because it collapsed completely. Maybe Eth is to big to fail now, but maybe it isn't.
- yieldcrv 4y agoanti-fragility, permission to fail, rapid iteration basically risk isn't controversial, and it rapidly iterates to more and more resilient systems
- moffkalast 4y agoWell it certainly needs another decade or two of iterations before it can replace what we have now, I imagine.
- yieldcrv 4y agoI don't think it needs to replace anything, that's not a goal to me I think it needs to be permissionless and autonomous I think it needs to compete on overhead costs and payment style (pay to write once, store and read indefinitely for free. compared to a SaaS service)
- woodruffw 4y ago“Permission to fail” is a desirable property in a research setting, not a global name service. This justification is in tension with the one offered above, and there’s been no evidence so far that “web3” is becoming more resilient instead of less resilient.
- yieldcrv 4y agoNot all products are suited for all market participants. Figure out where you are on the gradient and act accordingly. Ethereum Name Service was launched in May 2017, there are many name service competitors. > and there’s been no evidence so far that “web3” is becoming more resilient instead of less resilient. based on? some frequency of a type of headline you saw? quantified against..... anything?
- woodruffw 4y agoThis is a cop-out: of course there are people with absurd risk or reliability profiles, for whom just about anything might be suitable. The entire point of systems like DNS are that they’re universal substrates that don’t require any exceptional selection. Economies and ecosystems are built on reliable and universal substrates. My perception of resiliency is based on this[1], which has reliably increased in volume and quantity by year. [1]: https://web3isgoinggreat.com/ https://web3isgoinggreat.com/
- yieldcrv 4y agoI think it isn't doing great at consumer confidence, I don't think it needs to exist for that https://web3isgoinggreat.com/?id=earningfarm-exploited-for-971000 https://web3isgoinggreat.com/?id=earningfarm-exploited-for-9... An exploiter's bug bounty on a still functioning yield farm that flash loaned itself, getting frontrun by a MEV searcher because the exploiter didn't hide their transaction directly with a block producer via bribery? That sentence wasn't possible a year ago. And now we all know not to design a smart contract powering a farm that way. I don't view that as failure. A regulatory sandbox would have deliberated for 5 years before allowing a launch and still never found that problem, resulting in a following multi year pause, committee report, and disbanding. I view this much faster higher iterative version as a win.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y ago"The problem is you can lose access to your emails at any time." "Use web3 - then when you lose access to all your emails it's the system working as intended!"
- rglullis 4y agoThat is the kind of tired, cheap, wrong argument that it so easily debunked, but "skeptics" still keep using. Let me see if you really interested in a healthy debate or just proud of your ignorance: do you know that when using web3 for domains, you'd still be running the email servers that use the traditional protocols? You won't be losing any of your messages. You'd still be authenticating against a traditional server. There is nothing about using web3 for domains that would lead you to lost access to your data.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoYou're right, you won't lose access to your emails, you'll lose access to your address, which really is the bit that I care more about - losing ability to log into sites and services is what really scares me about losing my email. But now the important question - how does a web3 domain name solve the domain problem any better than just buying a domain, especially considering that "Permission to fail" is being touted as a web3 feature?
- rglullis 4y ago> losing ability to log into sites and services is what really scares me about losing my email. That is also not a problem. Maybe current "login with web3" implementations rely only on your primary ENS record for authentication, but there is nothing stopping a MFA system where the ENS name is only one of the factors. E.g: you could build a system that uses ENS as the first factor and a regular PGP client cert as the second. There are also "social recovery" systems. Even if you lose your keys, you can have a secondary address that can vouch for you. IOW, stop arguing like you are the only one aware of the current limitations and that the thousands of people working on the space are just stupid. Before spewing ignorant arguments, you should learn a thing or two .