3 ms·
TikTok is no different to Facebook (Meta) and as Facebook has already been fined in the billions by the FTC over this, the same should also happen to TikTok and
by rvz 4y ago
TikTok is no different to Facebook (Meta) and as Facebook has already been fined in the billions by the FTC over this, the same should also happen to TikTok and repeat offenders should also be fined in the tens of billions of dollars.
- dontbenebby 4y ago>TikTok is no different to Facebook (Meta) Tik Tok exists as a corporation for people to "do business in China" AKA be paid vast sums of money for knowledge and skills that would be treason or whatever to otherwise transfer. At least Facebook people keep up appearances -- pretend to be a capitalist, then shun any regulations or taxes that differentiate capitalism from oligarchy. (And Federal Trade Commission is a joke, it's a known thing they can often do one test case when a behavior is being done in parallel across industry by many actors.)
- mgraczyk 4y agoWhen was Meta fined for secretly building a system to track the whereabouts of specific individuals? You may be thinking of Lundy et al v. Meta Platforms, in which they were not fined but agreed to a civil settlement and denied they were doing what was claimed. In that cases, it wasn't even alleged that they were trying to make the locations of specific individuals available for human analysis.
- rvz 4y ago> When was Meta fined for secretly building a system to track the whereabouts of specific individuals? Meta was fined for violating consumer privacy for years, which TikTok has already been doing themselves; but as you can already see they have become even worse than Facebook. > You may be thinking of Lundy et al v. Meta Platforms, You see, even when Meta didn't get fined for that, perhaps it's about time for TikTok to get fined in the billions for violating consumer's privacy in the US and repeated offences should be in the tens of billions of dollars to discourage such activity in the US?
- friedman23 4y ago[flagged]
- rvz 4y ago> You are being purposefully obtuse or dishonest. You did not answer his question, and you know you did not answer his question. ??? I really hope you have read what I said before commenting. > Stop being a shill for authoritarian governments. If you really cared about privacy you would advocate banning tiktok and banning facebook. Not this whataboutism nonsense. Who's shilling what? I already said I want BOTH of them to be fined in the billions? Since I already disagreed with the spying and privacy violations from what both Facebook and TikTok has done for years. I'd also be in favour of banning all of them if possible. But in the US and given the FTC has given a multi billion dollar fine to Facebook, I'm sure you would want TikTok to have the exact same treatment of a giant fine since they are operating in the US? No? It's not 'whataboutsism' as I've already agreed with the parent comment.
- friedman23 4y ago> I really hope you have read what I said before commenting. The comment was about specific individuals being targeted. Are there any reports of Facebook targeting specific individuals?
- mgraczyk 4y agoOk but you said "Facebook has been fined over this". You admit that's a false claim? Tiktok and Facebook both should be fined for violating the law when there is sufficient evidence that the violation happened. We don't need to make up stories about Facebook to justify investigations into either.
- Nextgrid 4y agoAnd yet Facebook is still going (just like their competitors), so clearly the fines weren’t enough.
- eloff 4y agoTikTok is very different because the CPP has leverage over them and can force them to do things we in the West would find abhorent. That's not to find Western companies or governments innocent, because they are not, but the magnitude of the problem matters.
- thelittleone 4y agoPerhaps true that CCP would use this in a more abhorrent way, but let's not forget PRISM [1] and also the eliptic curve / NSA / RSA fiasco [2]. One could argue these target state level targets or terrorists, but who really knows. [1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM [2]https://blog.cloudflare.com/how-the-nsa-may-have-put-a-backdoor-in-rsas-cryptography-a-technical-primer/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/how-the-nsa-may-have-put-a-backd...
- eloff 4y agoI'm not forgetting, just noting there's a difference between CCP and the US government which matters here. If the US government gets caught using that info to persecute dissidents and their families, I'll be sure to retract my statement.
- tonetheman 4y agoThis just in: Google/Apple/Facebook and every other company on the internet is doing the same thing.
- jamiequint 4y agoSounds like you (also) have a fundamental misunderstanding of the goals of advertisers versus the goals of state governments.
- palata 4y agoBecause you think that the US government does not benefit from all that data going through US companies like Facebook/Apple/Google? More privacy w.r.t. those wouldn't hurt non-US countries, I would say.
- jasmer 4y agoI'm a bit dismayed at the attempts at moral equivalence here. An imperial, totalitarian regime which currently imprisons people for being of a specific ethnicity (or any arbitrary reason), and has no measure of a proper judicial system, tracking citizens of other nations for purposes of pursuing their power - is not the same thing as - Facebook making it possible for advertisers to target groups of people with 'interests'. Meta can be fined for shenanigans (which FYI mostly do not cause direct harm), and of course - we need better regulations. But the issue of TikTok is one of national (frankly international) security, and it's on an entirely different level.