6 ms·
TikTok accused of covert plot to track specific US citizens' every move
- about_that 4y ago[flagged]
- leoszliard 4y ago
- rvz 4y agoTikTok is no different to Facebook (Meta) and as Facebook has already been fined in the billions by the FTC over this, the same should also happen to TikTok and repeat offenders should also be fined in the tens of billions of dollars.
- dontbenebby 4y ago>TikTok is no different to Facebook (Meta) Tik Tok exists as a corporation for people to "do business in China" AKA be paid vast sums of money for knowledge and skills that would be treason or whatever to otherwise transfer. At least Facebook people keep up appearances -- pretend to be a capitalist, then shun any regulations or taxes that differentiate capitalism from oligarchy. (And Federal Trade Commission is a joke, it's a known thing they can often do one test case when a behavior is being done in parallel across industry by many actors.)
- mgraczyk 4y agoWhen was Meta fined for secretly building a system to track the whereabouts of specific individuals? You may be thinking of Lundy et al v. Meta Platforms, in which they were not fined but agreed to a civil settlement and denied they were doing what was claimed. In that cases, it wasn't even alleged that they were trying to make the locations of specific individuals available for human analysis.
- rvz 4y ago> When was Meta fined for secretly building a system to track the whereabouts of specific individuals? Meta was fined for violating consumer privacy for years, which TikTok has already been doing themselves; but as you can already see they have become even worse than Facebook. > You may be thinking of Lundy et al v. Meta Platforms, You see, even when Meta didn't get fined for that, perhaps it's about time for TikTok to get fined in the billions for violating consumer's privacy in the US and repeated offences should be in the tens of billions of dollars to discourage such activity in the US?
- friedman23 4y ago[flagged]
- rvz 4y ago> You are being purposefully obtuse or dishonest. You did not answer his question, and you know you did not answer his question. ??? I really hope you have read what I said before commenting. > Stop being a shill for authoritarian governments. If you really cared about privacy you would advocate banning tiktok and banning facebook. Not this whataboutism nonsense. Who's shilling what? I already said I want BOTH of them to be fined in the billions? Since I already disagreed with the spying and privacy violations from what both Facebook and TikTok has done for years. I'd also be in favour of banning all of them if possible. But in the US and given the FTC has given a multi billion dollar fine to Facebook, I'm sure you would want TikTok to have the exact same treatment of a giant fine since they are operating in the US? No? It's not 'whataboutsism' as I've already agreed with the parent comment.
- friedman23 4y ago> I really hope you have read what I said before commenting. The comment was about specific individuals being targeted. Are there any reports of Facebook targeting specific individuals?
- mgraczyk 4y ago
- Nextgrid 4y agoAnd yet Facebook is still going (just like their competitors), so clearly the fines weren’t enough.
- eloff 4y agoTikTok is very different because the CPP has leverage over them and can force them to do things we in the West would find abhorent. That's not to find Western companies or governments innocent, because they are not, but the magnitude of the problem matters.
- thelittleone 4y agoPerhaps true that CCP would use this in a more abhorrent way, but let's not forget PRISM [1] and also the eliptic curve / NSA / RSA fiasco [2]. One could argue these target state level targets or terrorists, but who really knows. [1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM [2]https://blog.cloudflare.com/how-the-nsa-may-have-put-a-backdoor-in-rsas-cryptography-a-technical-primer/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/how-the-nsa-may-have-put-a-backd...
- eloff 4y agoI'm not forgetting, just noting there's a difference between CCP and the US government which matters here. If the US government gets caught using that info to persecute dissidents and their families, I'll be sure to retract my statement.
- tonetheman 4y agoThis just in: Google/Apple/Facebook and every other company on the internet is doing the same thing.
- jamiequint 4y agoSounds like you (also) have a fundamental misunderstanding of the goals of advertisers versus the goals of state governments.
- palata 4y agoBecause you think that the US government does not benefit from all that data going through US companies like Facebook/Apple/Google? More privacy w.r.t. those wouldn't hurt non-US countries, I would say.
- jasmer 4y agoI'm a bit dismayed at the attempts at moral equivalence here. An imperial, totalitarian regime which currently imprisons people for being of a specific ethnicity (or any arbitrary reason), and has no measure of a proper judicial system, tracking citizens of other nations for purposes of pursuing their power - is not the same thing as - Facebook making it possible for advertisers to target groups of people with 'interests'. Meta can be fined for shenanigans (which FYI mostly do not cause direct harm), and of course - we need better regulations. But the issue of TikTok is one of national (frankly international) security, and it's on an entirely different level.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 4y ago
- micromacrofoot 4y ago> They prioritize profit and censorship over engaging grass roots content. you seriously think tiktok is prioritizing grass roots content and not siphoning off massive amounts of data for profit?
- ldjkfkdsjnv 4y agoTikTok exploded precisely because they let regular people create content, and then showed it to other regular people. Ofcourse they are making cash. FB basically stopped showing regular people's content, and constrained it to accounts/topics that were attractive to advertisers. There's a huge difference. They got caught with their pants down.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoRight but this is just the same pattern over and over again. Facebook started off showing regular people regular content; so did Twitter and Instagram. The only reason it wouldn't happen to TikTok is if it's propped up as a CCP data mining operation. There's literally nothing good about any of this.
- jamiequint 4y agoThis is the most confused comment I've ever read. What are you even talking about? What metric did you think that a company whose goal is to make money was going to optimize on? What metric do you think TikTok is optimizing on (hint: it's not "grassroots content" whatever that means)
- ldjkfkdsjnv 4y agoTikTok lets regular people create content, and then shows it to other regular people. As basic as that sounds, FB/Google have all sorts of manipulation behind the scenes that stops that from occurring at the same scale. And so TikTok exploded because people could actually communicate in an organic way through video media.
- passion__desire 4y agoInstagram is waiting for the opportunity if and when US bans TikTok like India did.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zeofig 4y agoI'm sure they will use our data more responsible than a semi-hostile foreign government...
- pupppet 4y agoBan TikTok. It’s ridiculous that everyone seems to be okay with China banning US apps but we allow their apps here.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mkl95 4y agoThere has been enough evidence to ban TikTok for years. I can't think of any reason it hasn't happened yet other than politics.
- chrisseaton 4y ago“An eye for an eye makes the whole world go blind” We’re trying to do better than them, not follow their example!
- cocacola1 4y agoSeven Psychopaths on an Eye for an Eye: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxaTb4GdX18 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HxaTb4GdX18
- azinman2 4y agoNot a game to play when it comes to asymmetric business and trade relationships. You’re “better” until you’re irrelevant and have no industry left.
- soheil 4y agoI think the point being made is that this is not just about business and trade relations, it's also about freedom of ideas, expression and censorship.
- chrisseaton 4y ago"China is doing well as an oppressive regime - why aren't we trying that?!"
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI am also accusing Facebook, Apple, and Google of the same thing. Can we add them to this inquiry please?
- azinman2 4y agoWhataboutism is always strong on HN whenever there’s any critique of anything Chinese.
- izacus 4y agoIt's because we prefer actual privacy applying to everyone instead of xenophobic hypocrisy. Put a stop to this - for everyone.
- friedman23 4y agoNo, it's because there are a bunch of Chinese nationalists working in tech. Your comment reminds me of critiques of Russophobia. Turns out in hindsight Russophobia was completely warranted.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI, the original commenter here, am as white as the driven snow, with no connections at all to Russia or China. The hypocrisy and the invasion of privacy is what upsets me, not which government has jurisdiction. The Chinese government almost certainly has access to Facebook and Google's data, too. I don't want ANYONE building a profile on me. Even if it is "just" for ad targeting. It won't be just for ads in the future.
- _trampeltier 4y agoWhat do you think how I feel as european guy with the US spy industry.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Nextgrid 4y agoI’m glad that the Western spyware industry is finally seeing some competition. Hopefully this will raise concerns that will end up outlawing all spyware, regardless of origin.
- jamiequint 4y agoSounds like you have a fundamental misunderstanding of the goals of advertisers versus the goals of state governments.
- wongarsu 4y agoThe Snowden leaks were nearly a decade ago, but I have serious doubts that it has gotten any better since then. The data hoarding for advertisements is just the cherry on top that makes this data more widely available.
- soheil 4y agoAdditionally that was what we did to our citizens imagine what we do to others.
- Nextgrid 4y agoThe problem is that advertisers are ultimately vulnerable to governments, not to mention not really incentivised to resist them. In the end, governments just outsource their spying to advertisers (without even having to pay for the service) and can “ask nicely” for any data they need.
- jamiequint 4y agoThat's an absurdly stupid claim, which you have no evidence to support.
- Nextgrid 4y agoWouldn't the evidence be US law? As far as I know nobody can lawfully resist (nor even disclose) a national security letter. The only workaround is to not hold any data of interest to the government so they would have no reason to send one in the first place. However, besides national security letters, I'm not even sure one would be needed when there's a healthy industry of data brokers happy to sell the data.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoFor those going, "well, what is the Chinese government going to do, compared to Facebook?" Or saying, well, Facebook does the same thing right? Well... potentially kidnap you and bring you to China, if you don't comply. They supposedly "convinced" 230,000 Chinese nationals from April 2021 to July 2022 to "voluntarily" return to China to face criminal charges, complete with over 54 "international police stations" and a new law, going into effect this December, claiming extraterritorial authority over their "citizens" for certain crimes. This, along with other incidents, show that China is more than willing to harass people outside their country, at a minimum. https://safeguarddefenders.com/en/blog/230000-policing-expands https://safeguarddefenders.com/en/blog/230000-policing-expan...
- waffleiron 4y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraordinary_rendition https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraordinary_rendition It’s not China doing this I am afraid of, as a citizen of a third party country.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoExtraordinary rendition is still a legal procedure, done in courts from both countries. China's alleged activities do not even talk or rely on authority from their own courts, let alone another country's.
- waffleiron 4y agoThats not true, read the Abu Omar case. This was not done legally using the courts of both countries.
- stormbrew 4y agoYou seem to be confusing extradition and extraordinary rendition? The former is a legal process built on treaties. The latter is a euphamism for a kind of government kidnapping to circumvent legal restrictions, hence the "extraordinary."
- 4y ago
- nimbius 4y agos/tiktok/uber/g we literally have american companies that have been caught doing this with impunity.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sebazzz 4y agoThe enemy you know...
- maxbond 4y agoOriginal source: https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilybaker-white/2022/10/20/tiktok-bytedance-surveillance-american-user-data/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/emilybaker-white/2022/10/20/tik... Personally I'm reserving judgement until this is confirmed by other news sources, because the details seem sparse, the motives unclear, and I don't hold Forbes in a high regard journalistically (though this is at least a staff writer, and not a contributor, so presumably there's more editorial oversight). My intuition is that there's a 55% chance this story is true, and a 45% chance it's incorrect or overstated.
- twtw99 4y agoCan we all please stick to the topic of the post here? That Tiktok is a threat to the society especially when a foreign company with questionable ethical and moral practices is in charge of American teen data. If you want to discuss how western companies also collect the data, then go make a different post and discuss there? The false equivalence by comparing Tiktok to other tech companies ruins any discussions we could have here.
- aresant 4y agoWhat the “TikTok is just doing what other social media companies are doing” response misses is that US platforms are under the purview of US law and US government. The US govt’s extensive monitoring and archiving of its own citizens + foreign citizens information is widely known at this point. This is a source of wide consternation for other foreign governments because the monitoring is a tremendous asset for US domestic and foreign intelligence, defense, and cyber warfare which is of course why China has banned many of these US services. Meanwhile TikTok has grown like a weed in the US and several times the so called “firewall” supposed to keep the US version of TikTok separate had been demonstrably proven to be effectively non existent. And considering the scale of election meddling, astroturfing, and psy ops that take place on US platforms - that both private industry and govt have failed to contain - the US intelligence community and govt likely well understands the threat of their unofficial, global arch rival owning the fastest growing new social media platform. I would love to know what the intelligence community is doing behind closed doors at this point but they must have balanced TikTok as an asset vs liability given the obvious threat it poses to the US’ near ubiquitous control of global social media.
- toss1 4y agoConsidering that Stratva has revealed classified information merely by its ordinary function of publishing users' workouts when (foolishly) used ny soldiers in-country, the threat of an app tracking everyone's location to an enemy is terrifying - target any particular leaders, soldiers,pilots, etc., &/or their families, or just the command posts or barracks where they are located. Just connect missile guidance to the live coordinates. At this point, letting in any software or hardware from China or Russia is beyond idiotic. We can all live just fine without Kaspersky spyware and TikTok videos sending home our locations.
- maxbond 4y agoI dunno that isolationism is going to produce better outcomes. I think we should demand transparency and control over our data, and offer the same in return. Refusing to exchange software seems liable to chill economic and diplomatic relations, and result in us all creating our own Great Firewalls. We were able to negotiate the reduction of nuclear capabilities during the height of the cold war. I don't see why we couldn't negotiate the reduction of cyber capabilities now, were we to make it a priority. Certainly seems worth a try, if the alternative is destroying the internet as an international commons.
- javajosh 4y agoThe rugged digital individual needs Little Snitch for Android quite urgently. In fact, I think that's something Google can and should include in the very next Android revision. It would be a loud and clear statement in favor of security and privacy in a distinctly Android (vs Apple) way - it's more open, more information, and more on you to do the right thing (but I do support Apple-esque default rules). While I think the best reason to care is because of privacy and security, there's also a more concrete argument in favor of preventing theft. Every network call that is not in service to the user is theft of precious battery and bandwidth resources. Right now it's not a free market because people just don't know the price they are paying. It would be great to surface that price and give alternative apps and services a chance to win based on substantive differences, and not just on superficial things. (The only app that has succeeded on this basis is, to my knowledge, Signal. But Google would immediately alter the entire marketplace for the better by building Android Snitch into the next version of Android).
- friedman23 4y agoEveryone that is trying to justify this by whataboutism, you are defending a regime that is know for going into foreign countries to kidnap and arrest individuals extrajudicially. The people that will suffer are Chinese citizens trying to escape the grip of authoritarianism. The term for people that defend authoritarians this way is "useful idiot".
- DiogenesKynikos 4y agoExtraordinary rendition: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraordinary_rendition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraordinary_rendition Reminder: the US ran a global kidnapping and torture program for years. Innocent people were even kidnapped off the streets in Europe by American agents, and flown to third countries to be tortured.
- diimdeep 4y agoUnderstandable. The State of Democracy in the United States 2021-12-05 - Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the People's Republic of China https://www.fmprc.gov.cn/mfa_eng/zxxx_662805/202112/t20211205_10462535.html https://www.fmprc.gov.cn/mfa_eng/zxxx_662805/202112/t2021120...
- dantetheinferno 4y agoI'm pretty anti-TikTok - but shouldn't we have some evidence - or any knowledge of who this material came from - before trusting a reporter from Forbes? I read through the article - but I couldn't find any details on the source this reporter is citing. Worryingly - the author "held policy positions at Facebook and Spotify." Instagram is a major competitor to TikTok - so conflict of interest is pretty strong. As other posters pointed out - every major company tracks people. We've known about this type of behaviour for decades from big tech.
- fsckboy 4y ago> As other posters pointed out - every major company tracks people the headline says plot to track specific people, so that is alleging something different than "everybody does it"
- dang 4y agoByteDance planned to use TikTok to surveil specific American citizens - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33280176 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33280176 - Oct 2022 (204 comments)
- mrbombastic 4y agoDid this just disappear off the front page? I refreshed and it is totally gone after being the top story.
- soheil 4y agoLooks like a very similar story posted recently, so maybe dang is trying to keep the convo in one place https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33302960 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33302960
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoThere is a phrase of set of phrases I am looking for when it comes to astroturfing / election manipulation/ fake news. The first is that there are many stories, interpretations or perhaps coherent models. Obviously some stories are inconsistent or falsifiable on their own terms. Then we walk up the pyramid - and stories exist like "stories for children". these are things like "love will always triumph, hospitals are where sick people go and doctors make them better again". These stories are true in some directional sense, and they are true in that there are many facts that will support them, but there are facts that falsify the stories. And so we travel up the pyramid, and the stories become more complex and nuanced - failed prime ministers should not get 100K pa pensions, but if we don't give officials fat payouts they are at risk of bribery on the job which is more expensive. There are facts that support that argument but it seems less cut and dry - you need a model of bribery and human nature and revolving doors to match up. As we go further up the pyramid more and more falsifiable stories don't just need the same facts as me to agree with me, but they need other mental models to agree with me. Deserving poor, mentally ill people need to buck up a bit, believe in yourself, etc I think that surfacing mental models matters as much as surfacing facts. Debunking can only go so far and facts that might help cannot be used if the mental model is the wrong shape.
- fsckboy 4y agoyou're using falsifiability only as a negative, whereas most people will be familiar with Karl Popper and falsifiability as a necessary element of scientific discourse and progress.
- peteradio 4y agoThey say that falsifiability is a best case scenario and base of the pyramid, as you move up you have to construct dynamic models of measurement to deduce even a probability of being true.
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoI see falsifiability as very much a positive and love me a bit of Karl Popper. I just think that for a empirical outcome to falsify a theory we both need to agree on the same theory. If your theory is there is a shadowy cabal of pedophiles secretly controlling wokeness to hold down good old boys from decent jobs and my theory is that factory production in China is cheaper so why keep the factory in Detroit, exactly which facts are going to help us? It took a lot to prove the Earth even spins, and orbits the sun. And yet if you had polled everyone in Europe or America from 1600 onwards, I am not sure when 50% of people would have said heliocentric, and do wonder when if ever the figure got above 95%. Somehow the figure that Brexit and Trump votes split not on age but on further education seems relevant here - that university teaches new mental models. But somehow I am dubious that has explanatory power.
- sys_64738 4y agoAll because it's out of reach of being bought by Facebook and can't be controlled via conventional means. TikTok is no more a threat to Americans than any other webpage is.