11 ms·
Not trying to be condescending but doesn't it surprise anyone here that this is _not_ obvious? At least on this site, there are still people doubting or debatin
by rdtsc 15y ago
Not trying to be condescending but doesn't it surprise anyone here that this is _not_ obvious? At least on this site, there are still people doubting or debating this.
So I am wondering why don't stores do this already. And I believe it is because of perceptions. They understand that time will be saved, however, they realize that most people will be scared by a long line.
One long line that moves fast will still appear terrible compared to a bunch of small lines that crawl. Because people don't look long enough to estimate the rate of movement. They see both lines as static (not moving).
- tomkarlo 15y agoStores are moving towards this, but very slowly. The retail industry doesn't tend to innovate quickly. Generally, you see the more innovative / aggressive stores doing this now (Whole foods, some drug chains, Apple stores, Best Buy) but it could take a decade or more to spread widely, in particular because in many stores it requires a significant layout change to accomodate one long line - generally you need additional space between the front of the line and the registers so that customers can go to the open checkout, and some stores don't have that much space.
- philwelch 15y agoIt's another instance of "people are stupid". Yes, for any educated person it's obvious that one line is faster, that's the first thing about queueing theory, but most people don't know the first thing about queueing theory. Other instances of "people are stupid" leading to poor design: * Some cars come with a CVT (continuously variable transmission) rather than having to shift gears. The audible pitch of the engine just gradually goes up as the accelerator is depressed, rather than revving up and then shifting back down again. Since people were used to the gear-shifting behavior, they thought CVT's were underpowered, so they were actually redesigned to simulate the shifting behavior even though it was suboptimal. * Coinstar machines are actually much, much faster than they appear. But people don't trust them if they don't take three times as long and make jangly coin sounds, so it just silently sorts the coins as fast as it can and plays a recording of jangly coin sounds, all the while delaying when it displays the final count onscreen.
- wisty 15y agoA university lecturer of mine actually interviewed people in a bank, and asked them how long they thought they had stood in line. She found it was proportional to the line length, not the time they actually stood in line. Note, the bank didn't believe her, so she used some modelling package to animate it ... then they believed her.
- nik_0_0 15y agoDo you have a source for that Coinstar playing jangly coin sounds?? I would love to read more about that.
- philwelch 15y agoWell, this is embarrassing: I remembered that story from somewhere, and it turns out somewhere was another Hacker News thread: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2007818 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2007818
- JamesAn 15y ago"Counting 600 coins per minute, Coinstar machines detect the metal content of the coin, as well as the size to accurately identify the coin denomination - and efficiently sort out all kinds of debris typically found in consumer coin. The company has found paper clips, key chains, wedding bands, gum wrappers, even teeth, all of which are identified quickly as non-coin." http://web.archive.org/web/20100324183932/http://www.coinstar.com/US/WebDocs/A3-2-2 http://web.archive.org/web/20100324183932/http://www.coinsta...
- lywald 15y agoIt's obvious that one line is faster? Well it's not. Considering all cashiers are busy all the time, if it could be faster that would mean they have to manage multiple customers at the same time... If you're in the top 50% skilled at finding a line, then you're penalized because it just averages the queuing time.
- cynicalkane 15y agoMost Nissans have a CVT now, and the ones I've driven seem to shift continuously. BMW tried implementing a discrete-shifting CVT like the one you describe for one of their semihybrids, and though I've never driven it, it got slammed in reviews. Do you have a citation for your claim?
- cheald 15y agoFry's Electronics does the single line thing, and any time there is a line, I feel like I end up standing in it longer than I would at a grocery story. I suspect this is probably psychological, but letting me, as the shopper, pick the line I want to stand in puts me in charge of how long I wait. If I pick a bad line, it's my fault for picking the bad line. When there's just one line available, I don't get that choice. Single-queue might be faster, the the psychology of customer satisfaction is much more complex than that.
- prodigal_erik 15y agoWhen I have to choose a line I find myself harshly judging the people around me, because every difference can impose a cost in boredom and lost leisure time. "This guy's old and worn out. They seem kind of foreign, won't understand the cashier. That one looks poor, probably uses a lot of coupons and argues about what's discounted. They're paying all their attention to their kid instead of getting out of everyone's way." It may be the most socially corrosive thing I routinely do. Edit: and I think I just convinced myself to get a smartphone (I'm reluctant to bring a paperback, it might look like shoplifting because they sell those).
- hn_reader 15y agoIndeed, since I got a smartphone I no longer dread long lines in supermarkets, etc. Just more time to read HN.
- AndyNemmity 15y agoI go to Fry's a ton, and it always seems to go much quicker, but I agree, psychologically standing in a tremendously huge line feels worse.
- mc32 15y ago--which is why Delis‡ traditionally give you a numbered tag. It's a single line, but you can go about and not feel "constricted" to the queue (tail). Don't forget, Frys also has a "semaphore" who cues people to the next register. ‡among many places like hospitals, information centers (DMVs), etc.
- mahyarm 15y agoAt a walmart in Canada, they had an express line which had 6 cashiers and one line. A LCD screen chimed with the number of the next cashier when they were ready.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Semiapies 15y agoThe layout of the store may make switching to a single line tricky. You need enough area for people to line up, and stores I've seen with this layout usually had a larger area between the aisles and registers than most grocery stores. Also the largest big-box stores would have to go with multiple multi-register lines due to the sheer number of registers.
- clord 15y agoStores are focused on individual wait times, not on total throughput.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- malvim 15y agoI used to be very afraid of long single lines, until I studied a bit of queue theory in college. I now feel angry whenever I see lots of small lines, and relieved when I'm in a store that has a larger single line with a bunch of "servers" at the end. Unfortunately that is the ONLY thing I got from that subject: "single line with lots of servers better than lots of lines with one server each". I can't really remember anything else, like WHY this is the case or how queues work. :/