3 ms·
Why even pretend that admission is in some sense "fair"? I don't mean this as a "anti-woke" or "pro-woke" harangue, or as a middle school cynical pose. Admiss
by gumby 4y ago
Why even pretend that admission is in some sense "fair"?
I don't mean this as a "anti-woke" or "pro-woke" harangue, or as a middle school cynical pose.
Admission in the USA is a manual and largely arbitrary process. Just like judges' rulings, it's influenced by which person happened to read the application, what they had for breakfast and what time of day it is. Plus random factors like the orchestra's french horn player having just graduated.
We recognize this for hiring, why not school applications? Acknowledging it will reduce a lot of heartache.
(Another heartache reducer would be the elimination of the "common application")
- hawaiianbrah 4y agoWhy would removing the “common application” remove heartache? I’m not familiar with that idea.
- gumby 4y agoThe common application encourages people to apply for schools they aren't qualified for ("what the hell it's only another $30"), a phenomenon which has been exacerbated by the schools themselves. The USNWR ranking includes acceptance rate ("more selective" means a higher proportion of rejections), so schools send letters to kids who can't get in, encouraging them to apply. I saw these letters last year. In addition, the common app really restricts what you can say. For example two kids might have earned an Eagle Scout rank: one just did the minimum to get a check box; the other might have really used it to learn and develop. In the common app there isn't really room to differentiate unless you devote your essay to it. Back when each school had a unique application, the burden of applying makes you more judicious in your choices. However it also allowed you to adapt your application to what you wanted to emphasize to each school. For a quantifiable difference: back when I was applying to universities in the 1980s, MIT had quite a high acceptance rate compared to its peers, ~18% IIRC. Why? Turns out few people applied because they (probably correctly) assumed they wouldn't get in anyway.
- forinti 4y agoJust forget about trying to be fair: use some kind of test and pick out by lottery from the n best results.
- lupire 4y agoThis is what SAT provides: A way to find highly capable students based on a very low bar (relative to college education), with a low ceiling, avoiding peacocking.
- andrepd 4y ago>You care about fairness and justice? Well why don't you simply... not? Then your problem is gone. Well that's hardly an interesting solution is it? x) Yes things are not good, and they might never be perfect. But that can be better.
- WalterBright 4y agoA point is reached in that any improvement in fairness to one group will decrease fairness to another. For example, I'm bald. That's unfair. At some point, one has to just accept it and move on.
- andrepd 4y agoI fail to see how the educational system has reached the end of any possible or conceivable improvement. I find it very very unlikely that 2022 USA is the end of history (but Mr Fukuyama might like a word with you :p) Also, as a fellow man afflicted with male-pattern baldness, I wouldn't dream of comparing that with the injustices discussed in this thread.
- WalterBright 4y ago> I fail to see how the educational system has reached the end of any possible or conceivable improvement At least the public school has not made any objective improvement since around 1970 or so. That's pretty good evidence that that system cannot get any better.
- andrepd 4y agoCome on Walter, you're a very smart guy, you cannot possibly believe the nonsense you are saying x) In fact the very existence of several developed countries with much better educational systems (by almost any metric) than the US should clue you in on that.
- WalterBright 4y ago
- yzsh 4y ago
- gumby 4y agoAn implicit point in my comment, which replies suggested wasn't clear, is that it's completely unclear what "fair" would even mean. Is it fair that my parents went on an extended walkabout and so I happened to be in the US during high school and had the chance to go to amazing universities? Is it fair that some kid with a 160 IQ grew up on a reservation with parents who desperately wanted to help the kid succeed but had no idea how, while the kid had to go to crappy schools, learn only the basics, and worry about their next meal? They would be waay smarter than I, but I would be far better prepared and would get more out of an MIT education. Trying to diversify the student population sounds like a good thing for schools to be doing, something that in the medium term will hopefully ablate some of the second case. And if that excludes someone with high test scores, which is "fair"? Hell, if it excludes someone who diligently labored to worked the system, well, the there's a reasonable case to be made that such a person will do OK regardless while the student with less opportunity might end up with a greater benefit for society. And, as far as "fair" goes: private universities, at least, are going to accept a certain number whom they believe will provide future donations, helping the institution survive and grow, even if they are otherwise unqualified. Is that fair?