3 ms·
> The measurement apparatus as a separate thing from the quantum system was actually partially explained by decoherence I disagree that the decoherence at all
by whimsicalism 4y ago
> The measurement apparatus as a separate thing from the quantum system was actually partially explained by decoherence
I disagree that the decoherence at all partially explains a different measurement apparatus separate from the system. After observation, we still have the the system is in a superposition of multiple states. How this system "collapses" to one state in the measurement apparatus is unexplained.
Decoherence explains why each state of the observer can't tell that the other states also exist.
> This is the most direct way of interpreting our experimental results.
Sure, except we have to invent an entirely new non-unitary transformation of "collapse" despite all observations and predictions of quantum mechanics showing that unitary evolution of the wavefunction continues even for large macro-scale objects.
- tsimionescu 4y ago> Decoherence explains why each state of the observer can't tell that the other states also exist. Sure, but, again, decoherence doesn't explain (1) why the wave function is split in the classical states (position, momentum etc.) and not other states (linear combinations of position and momentum and spin etc.); and (2) doesn't explain why different states have the precise probabilities of being observed that they do. You still need to postulate these features. > Sure, except we have to invent an entirely new non-unitary transformation of "collapse" despite all observations and predictions of quantum mechanics showing that unitary evolution of the wavefunction continues even for large macro-scale objects. You're confusing the map for the territory. What we can see, plain as day, is that unitary evolution of the wavefunction does not continue for macro-scale objects. MWI explains this through the framework of the universal wavefunction and its mutually un-interacting "branches", CI explains it through wavefunction collapse. No one has ever successfully put a macroscopic object in superposition, so the idea that the universe itself could be in superposition remains highly theoretical at best. Note also that movement in the classical world (and in GR) is often highly non-linear/non-unitary (such as the movement of a free pendulum, or many kinds of orbits). While far from perfect for this, the Born rule at least allows us to "sneak in" non-unitary evolution through this collapse; but, in the MWI, we predict that the movement of a free pendulum should in fact be non-chaotic. This is rarely discussed, but is an interesting observation that could be experimentally tested as we get better at creating larger and larger systems that remain coherent for longer and longer periods of time.
- whimsicalism 4y ago> Sure, but, again, decoherence doesn't explain (1) why the wave function is split in the classical states (position, momentum etc.) and not other states (linear combinations of position and momentum and spin etc.); and (2) doesn't explain why different states have the precise probabilities of being observed that they do. You still need to postulate these features. I agree that (1) is a strong objection that I do not have an easy solution to. (2) I think is addressable in the same way that it is in CI - our theory has to explain our observed experience and the born rule (whether CI-flavored or MWI-flavored) is how we do so. > No one has ever successfully put a macroscopic object in superposition But getting larger and larger. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41567-019-0663-9 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41567-019-0663-9 Thanks for an informative discussion!
- tsimionescu 4y ago> (2) I think is addressable in the same way that it is in CI - our theory has to explain our observed experience and the born rule (whether CI-flavored or MWI-flavored) is how we do so. Absolutely, but I would still say that it means we are adding an extra postulate that can't be derived directly from the Schrodinger equation even in MWI. I'm not trying to claim that the MWI is wrong: just that it is not simpler than the CI (nor it is more complex though - I'm arguing it has the same number of postulates). > But getting larger and larger. Sure, and I'm really hoping we'll advance closer to macroscopic objects in my lifetime, so maybe some of these questions may be elucidated. > Thanks for an informative discussion! Thank you as well!