14 ms·
A selection process based on academic achievement alone yields a graduate more highly valued by corporate America [1]. Private universities should be able to u
by petilon 4y ago
A selection process based on academic achievement alone yields a graduate more highly valued by corporate America [1].
Private universities should be able to use whatever criteria they want (as long as there is no illegal discrimination) including "building communities" and "shaping the student body". (It's a free country after all!) But public universities must use objective criteria. Students need to be able to control their own destiny through hard work. That's a basic principle of fairness that should apply in this land of opportunity. No "shaping" of the student body by universities that receive funding from taxpayers, because that is unfair to students. Imagine being denied admission by the only good public university in your state, not because your grades or test scores are not good enough, but because you didn't fit in whatever "shape" the university decided is appropriate for that year! For more on this see [2].
[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/college-selection-method-can-boost-graduates-value-11575058720 https://www.wsj.com/articles/college-selection-method-can-bo...
[2] https://circles.page/5680a56b5c28af0998656e09/College-Admissions-in-the-US https://circles.page/5680a56b5c28af0998656e09/College-Admiss...
- cuteboy19 4y agoI very much agree on the shaping your own destiny part. How can anyone subject themselves to a committee of random bureaucrats deciding their future? Even if they were 100% fair and impartial, does it not take away your agency in choosing your own fate? And let's not pretend that they are 100% fair and impartial. We know for a fact that they are racially biased against different races depending on the time period. And maybe the one who rejected you didn't like how you name sounded. It's not as though the process is transparent, and they're only making it a 100 times more opaque as people catch on to them. This Holistic Admissions nonsense has always been a scam just like Holistic Medicine