3 ms·
Land most often does not wear down, but the built structure obviously does. And even for a condo in a desirable neighbourhood in Manhattan, >50% the value of t
by MichaelZuo 4y ago
Land most often does not wear down, but the built structure obviously does.
And even for a condo in a desirable neighbourhood in Manhattan, >50% the value of the property is likely in the value of the structure. i.e. the land value portion would be <50%
So the parent is accurate.
- kennend3 4y agohttps://spearswms.com/10-oldest-houses-in-the-world/ https://spearswms.com/10-oldest-houses-in-the-world/ Yep, some of these homes from 1700's are just so worn out.. They must be worth absolutely nothing. Suggest you head over and offer $1 for them?
- MichaelZuo 4y agoThis seems like a non-sequitur?
- kennend3 4y agoHardly, it simply follows your logic. These houses are very old, and must be worn out. Therefor they would have depreciated to zero...
- MichaelZuo 4y agoWhere does my logic imply that the value of that exact house's structure has depreciated to zero or $1? It's very likely the land is worth more than the structure, but that doesn't mean the value of said structure is literally nothing.
- kennend3 4y agoIt would seem you struggle with the definition of depreciation. "noun a reduction in the value of an asset with the passage of time, due in particular to wear and tear." Given enough time, depreciation leads to zero, or some "scrap value".. this is literally part of its definition. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depreciation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Depreciation When house values "fall" this is NOT depreciation, but market forces (supply/demand, interest rates, mortgage rates, government policy...). The point of "depreciation" is normally to allow things to be written off at a reduced value over the assets lifetime. Cars do "depreciate" because over time, they face wear and tear and at the end of their lifespan they are traded in for "scrap value". Homes do not depreciate because there is no logical reason why this asset's value would reduce over time/wear/tear when it can be properly maintained, as is the case of the houses from the 1700's i sent you.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoIf your not being purposefully obtuse, do you understand the concept of differing timespans? Given enough, time, such as millions of years, yes any human made structure will likely depreciate to zero value. Because even solid granite can be eroded down into dust from simple weathering, let alone normal building materials. That doesn't guarantee any specific structure, such as the one you linked, will depreciate to zero within human timescales. And obviously if structures are maintained they will probably not. That doesn't invalidate the concept of wear and tear or depreciation. If you maintain a structure you are by definition putting resources such as energy, materials, labor, etc., into it, so maintenance isn't free. Those resources represent a real cost that someone has to pay for.
- kennend3 4y agoSo, moving the goalposts your new position is that houses depreciate over geological timescales? Got it. Instead of posting here, why not take your fantastic housing model (they depereciate) and go buy homes. you can show up at their house with your spreadsheeet and show them how you applied an appropriate depreciation factor and now they should sell the house because this is the fair market value. You can also explain to everyone how over longer times scales houses almost always appreciate. If you look at the SP500 for a week it may go down, but over a decade it is almost always positive. Houses are the same, so where exactly is the depreciation you speak of? Again, using your theory of depreciation and long time scales. From the linnk i sent you: "W. B. Yeats so much that he purchased it for £35 around 1917. From then on it became known as the Yeats’ Tower." What is the current value of this house, after factoring in your depreciation factors?
- worik 4y ago> Instead of posting here, why not take your fantastic housing model (they depereciate) and go buy homes. It is often true that the old house on a piece of valuable land would cost more to repair than it would cost to build a new house on that land. Often enough the added cost of removing the old house (the use of asbestos in the past often vastly increases that cost) added on top of everything means that the land itself can loose its value. We see this a lot with old industrial sites, but it happens to residential buildings too. As for "timescales", do not be mean. The time-scale for depreciation of a car that is in use is measured in seconds New cars loose a third (? I know more about property than cars?) of their value when driven off the lot. Houses take a bit longer, but not "geological time-scales"
- worik 4y ago> These houses are very old, and must be worn out. Therefor they would have depreciated to zero... That is quite obtuse. Depreciation can be countered with maintenance. It is literally a physics concept: Entropy. It is a natural process but not unavoidable. A house that is thirty years old that has not been maintained can be a complete wreck. The roof has leaked all over the interior finish, the windows have broken and let in local animals to make their nests. Etcetera. The house next door that is thirty years old and had the roof maintained and windows fixed etcetera might be pristine. I think it is fun to see people on Hacker News forgetting about, even denying, entropy!
- stdbrouw 4y agoLet's say the price in your desirable NYC neighborhood is between $1,000 and $2,000 per square foot. New construction is between $100 and $200 per square foot, so $900 to $1,800 has to be for the land it's built on, no? (And if that's a 10 floor condo, the underlying land value is actually 10x that number.) Even in not-so-fancy neighborhoods, you're paying a lot for the land itself these days. I live in a <1M provincial city in Belgium in a semi-detached house, and a property assessor calculated that our house represents 30-35% of the total value of our property.
- kennend3 4y ago> and a property assessor calculated that our house represents 30-35% of the total value of our property. THIS! I live in Ontario (Canada) and my property assessment shows something similar, the value of the home is ~40% of the assessed value. There are plots of land in Toronto where the house is not livable selling for north of a million dollars. Given they have no house, it is purely land value.
- kennend3 4y agoUsing Toronto as an example because it is closer to home and i am more familair with it. Given your choice of spelling, it would appear Manhattan is not your core knowledge as well? https://www.blogto.com/real-estate-toronto/2022/10/toronto-condos-smaller-1990s/#:~:text=The%20average%20condo%20built%20in,a%2035%20per%20cent%20decrease https://www.blogto.com/real-estate-toronto/2022/10/toronto-c.... "As land values increase, we see more units on a single property, which means many of those individual units are smaller," said Greg Martino, MPAC Vice President and Chief Valuation and Standards Officer. MPAC is responsible for determining property values in Ontario, so do they know a thing or two about this topic. (https://www.mpac.ca/en https://www.mpac.ca/en) If structures wear down, how long until they reach zero value? Have you seen many houses for sale in the zero dollar range because of depreciation? it is not obvious that structures wear down. As i posted below, many of these houses are from the 1700's https://spearswms.com/10-oldest-houses-in-the-world/ https://spearswms.com/10-oldest-houses-in-the-world/ Which one do you feel has depreciated to zero?
- worik 4y ago> ? Have you seen many houses for sale in the zero dollar range because of depreciation? Yes. Plenty. It is not unknown. Not common but it definitely happens