6 ms·
I've been wondering something. So corals evolved 535 million years ago. During this time the earth went through large fluctuations in temperature (ocean tempera
by andai 4y ago
I've been wondering something. So corals evolved 535 million years ago. During this time the earth went through large fluctuations in temperature (ocean temperatures of 35 degrees, Antarctica being tropical), and CO2 concentrations over twice as high as we have now. But supposedly they can't handle the current conditions? That makes no sense to me.
Are the causes of coral bleaching actually understood? Wikipedia lists a dozen potential factors. It seems more likely to me that it's something other than CO2/temperature considering the species' history.
On the other hand it could well be that during the times when the temperature was changing rapidly, most of the corals died off, leaving behind only the most resistant ones.
- dtgriscom 4y agoExcepting mass extinction events (impacts, supervolcanoes), have the conditions ever changed as quickly as are now?
- Retric 4y agoEvolution doesn’t have a great memory, we used to live in the ocean and now drowning is a real threat. Plenty of land mammals have gone back to aquatic living but they don’t regain gills so they still go back to the surface. The transition from feet to fins also took a very long time. So yea massive changes over 50 years means mass die offs and even extinctions. Assuming we eventually stop introducing massive changes and in 5 million years aquatic ecosystems will be fine, but we care about the short term.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> Plenty of land mammals have gone back to aquatic living but they don’t regain gills so they still go back to the surface. Breathing air is probably a superior system anyway, since mammalian fish utterly dominate gilled fish in nearly every respect. What gilled fish can dive like a sperm whale, acquire the bulk of a blue whale, or the agility of a dolphin?
- Retric 4y agoWhat’s the point of diving like a sperm whale if you can just stay at the bottom of the ocean? As to overall performance the fastest swimmer is the Indo-Pacific Sailfish clocked at 68 mph. The blue whale is more bulky and faster than a whale shark, but young whale sharks can simply dive too low to be at significant threat from Okra. So breathing has real disadvantages.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoWhat's the point of having gills to stay at the bottom of the ocean if you're going to get dominated by sperm whales anyway? I don't know if sperm whales eat young whale sharks, but they certainly could if they wanted to. They can dive deeper than any whale shark.
- Retric 4y agoWe don’t have any evidence that sperm whales attack them. Okra packs have been observed attacking juvenile baleen whales on the other hand.
- oneoff786 4y agoAre you the superior system if you’re at the top of the food chain but your species’ continued existence is more tenuous than the lower prey animals?
- MichaelCollins 4y agoI think the greatest threat to marine mammals is the decline of all the other fish they eat.
- rileyphone 4y agoMarine species like coral and starfish are supported by a symbiotic holobiont of bacteria and dinoflagellates that provide it with protection and nutrition. Raising ocean temperatures contribute to the disruption of this biome, but there is something else at play IMO. The bacteria consisting of the holobiont, especially the Rhodobacterales, can quickly transfer genes and plasmids, to devastating effect [0]. There’s evidence that the ultimate genetic source of these destabilizing bacteria is in wastewater treatment plants - I don’t have the sources on hand ATM but there are cases both in Miami and China. 0. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35254236/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35254236/
- Tagbert 4y agoJust because there have been changes in the past does not mean that this is like all of the others. This is happening at an accelerated rate that is much higher speed than the evolution rate of plants and animals. The result will be a mass extinction of species. That has happened in the past and overall life does recover but many species are gone and things are very different afterward. No one wants to be alive during a mass extinction but they all would hope to survive. There is no guarantee that humans would survive this extinction. Even if the climate changes do not directly kill us off, it will stress our societies to a possible breaking point, with the risk of famine, war, and general societal breakdown.