4 ms·
> As long as we replace nuclear with coal plants, which is what we are largely doing in Europe In Germany, coal use declined as nuclear declined. Is there som
by pfdietz 4y ago
> As long as we replace nuclear with coal plants, which is what we are largely doing in Europe
In Germany, coal use declined as nuclear declined. Is there some other country that counterbalanced this trend?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_Germany#/media/File:Energiemix_Deutschland.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_Germany#...
Admittedly, coal use could have declined even faster if nuclear had not been phased out, but that's not what you were arguing.
- franciscop 4y agoLooking at numbers it seems I was wrong! I must've mixed Japan where I live now and has had a steep coal increase in the last 2 decades[1] with EU and the non-renewable (not coal) increase. In EU it's coal+gas+oil+etc as a "non-renewable" group that has been increasing (specially gas), while coal itself seems to have decreased slightly as well. As a combination, the non-renewable is less dangerous than coal itself, but still a lot worse than nuclear. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Japan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_Japan
- the_third_wave 4y agoWhat did Germany replace the base load generation with? Natural gas and imports. They had been warned about their reliance on Russian natural gas and they could have figured out for themselves that imports would get unreliable in case of crisis. Also, where does that imported power come from? France: nuclear power Sweden: nuclear power and some hydro, limited by the transfer capacity between the middle and north (where the hydro plants are) and south (where the interconnects are) Poland: coal Russia: coal, natural gas and nuclear The Netherlands: natural gas and coal In other words Germany did not "get rid" of nuclear and coal, they just moved it outside of their borders. The "green" politicos slept well in their dreams of a virtuous future, dreams which they were rudely awaken from when the gas stopped following.
- pfdietz 4y ago> What did Germany replace the base load generation with? Natural gas and imports. If you had looked at the link I provided, you would have seen that the largest replacement of energy to the grid was by wind, not by natural gas.
- franciscop 4y agoI didn't mentioned because I was still wrong, but the numbers you provided are relative which might not mean much; a decrease of 5% "relative" might mean the actual MW didn't change at all if overall the energy consumption grew.
- the_third_wave 4y agoAnd what does Germany use when there is no wind? Wind can not provide the base load in absence of large-scale storage which Germany does not have. The answer to my question is in the one you replied to: nuclear, natural gas and coal plus some hydro limited by transfer capacity.
- pfdietz 4y agoRight now, they back it up with gas. They could at this point profitably add even more renewables, to cut down on gas consumption, as they are burning more gas than needed for that backup. Ultimately, they add batteries (or other short term storage) as well as hydrogen for ultimate backup. With recent natural gas prices there, green hydrogen would be cheaper to burn.
- the_third_wave 4y agoWe are talking about what is happening at this moment, not about a possible future direction. Germany needs power now, this winter. Batteries can be used as peak buffers, their capacity is measured in hours. So-called "green" hydrogen has not really made it off the drawing boards yet so it remains to be seen whether this can be a real solution. Most natural gas infrastructure - storage as well as transport - is not directly useable for hydrogen but parts of it can be adapted. As of now this is mostly a pipe dream so Germany has to rely on the mentioned sources for their base load: coal, natural gas and nuclear - imported as well as generated locally.