3 ms·
I’m skeptical how good anyone is at identifying any of this. The amount of “you’re one of them” or “you’re just a troll” out there on the internet when someone
by duxup 4y ago
I’m skeptical how good anyone is at identifying any of this.
The amount of “you’re one of them” or “you’re just a troll” out there on the internet when someone simply doesn’t agree or even understand is seemingly infinite.
It’s a nearly weekly accusation thrown at me on Reddit.
People’s willingness to believe someone else is a troll or similar seems to just mean they never have to consider any ideas they don’t like.
- EarlKing 4y agoIt's always easier to believe your opposition is ontologically evil -- that way you never have to address your own epistemological emptiness. Of course, the fact that it's blatantly obvious that far too many "people" on the net are behaving indistinguishably from chatbots doesn't help matters.
- adolph 4y ago> ontologically evil Like they come up with really terrible classification categories? > epistemological emptiness Does this mean one does not have a theory of knowledge or that one thinks that knowledge does not exist? https://www.reddit.com/r/PhilosophyMemes/comments/u1675o/hey_philosophymemes_please_explain_what/ https://www.reddit.com/r/PhilosophyMemes/comments/u1675o/hey... https://www.quora.com/Are-emptiness-and-nothing-better-as-ontological-or-epistemological-constructs https://www.quora.com/Are-emptiness-and-nothing-better-as-on...
- EarlKing 4y ago> Like they come up with really terrible classification categories? Rather they just declare their opposition evil by nature so they don't have to analyze their behavior any further, and anything done to them is, in their eyes, morally justified. It is, in other words, dehumanizing. > Does this mean one does not have a theory of knowledge or that one thinks that knowledge does not exist? It means that they have no formal theory of knowledge and simply accept whatever is conventionally wise to them (or, more specifically, whatever fits their unacknowledged class interest).
- cocoricamo 4y agoIncredibly bad. People seem to be too comfortable in their safe bubbles that when confronted when dissenting opinions they tend to see it as an attack that must be the orchestrated by an enemy real or imaginary. When I started participating in some random forum a very long time ago as a kid, some guy I was arguing with told me to never assume bad intent unless you see clear evidence of it. I didn't get it at first but eventually made my interactions way more manageable.
- mancerayder 4y ago>Incredibly bad. People seem to be too comfortable in their safe bubbles that when confronted when dissenting opinions they tend to see it as an attack that must be the orchestrated by an enemy real or imaginary. It's more; you must belong to the Other Team. It's an astroturf account. It's a troll. For how could anyone possibly disagree with me and do so in good faith?
- Genghis_9000 4y agoSo much this, it's not even funny. Anyone who is concerned about "enemy posters" is either a nazi or SJW (or some other category) in my opinion. There are exceptions but in general it's true. They have some specific cause they're trying to put forth and naturally people say things that conflict with it and so they get upset at random innocent bystanders. I've never had this feeling where a """psyop""" is under way in my entire life, so I have zero empathy for it. My internet experience since the 90s on public servers has been miserable due to these insufferable people with undue power (moderation capabilities). I cannot name a single internet service that has ever been controlled by level headed people. I expect to go on there and just casually talk about whatever I want but within 5 minutes they post a giant wall of rules and my immediate first thought is, "jesus christ, what the fuck happened???". Of course a big part of the problem is that the moderation position attracts a certain type of brain dead, melodramatic, moral obsessed person whereas in reality it only exists to delete spam posts.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cr4nberry 4y ago> It’s a nearly weekly accusation thrown at me on Reddit. I think it's just because redditors tend to be younger (and the site is advertising to young people specifically). There's no point in arguing with literal children
- Eisenstein 4y ago> There's no point in arguing with literal children Isn't there? How do we expect them to learn? There is no point in getting frustrated or angry with literal children, but I believe that arguing with them, in the educational and not rhetorical sense, is helpful. Children learn from example, and if the only examples are their peers, then how do you expect them to grow up differently than them?
- RalfWausE 4y agoThe last time i tried to argue with redditors got me a ban on r/de...
- pclmulqdq 4y agoRedditors are getting younger and dumber every day. If you don't toe the party line (which is usually an absurd or extreme position), they accuse you of being a bot or a troll. They literally can't fathom that people who don't agree with them exist. They are not worth the arguing.
- throwaway292939 4y agoI feel that this is kinda the point. It's not easy, so here's a guide to help you train yourself into noticing these patterns. More for this audience than on other internet forums. For those, good luck.
- anigbrowl 4y agoThere are pretty good (albeit probabilistic) methods for adversarial* analysis - mainly focusing on posting metrics and interaction behavior, with content/semantic analysis as a second tier (although many exceptions apply). * much of the literature about reducing trolling etc. is focused on platform operators, which isn't that useful to participants since platform operators are not incentivized to provide transparency or accountability.
- soheil 4y agoIn online discussions it seems like the threshold to accept an idea as true is much lower if one is to reach that conclusion themselves than if it has been reached by another regardless of one's awareness of the other party's threshold for accepting something as true.
- cyberge99 4y agoKarl Rove literally uses this as a playbook. I’ll see if I can find a link with the details of his campaign tactics.
- TwoNineFive 4y ago> It’s a nearly weekly accusation thrown at me on Reddit. If this is happening so often, then you are clearly doing something wrong and people are picking up on it. Also, like everyone else said, reddit is basically idiots arguing with other idiots. There's almost no value there anymore.