5 ms·
I've wondered about stuff like this when a post appears here that is critical of some well-known company.
by m463 4y ago
I've wondered about stuff like this when a post appears here that is critical of some well-known company.
- ggm 4y agoYes, but I hazard a guess it's 30/30/30 fanbois/trolls/real. I would love to be paid to be nasty about Musk, alas I have to decide to do it for love not money. What category does that put me in?
- poopnugget 4y ago
- wincy 4y agoIf only I could get paid to gush about how great Musk is, you and I would have great job security!
- ggm 4y agoI think both our paymasters would be people we didn't want to be associated with alas.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI'm pretty sure he or his PR firm actually does this, particularly on Reddit (where it seems to be cheap to manufacture consensus). A lot of other big business interests too. As far as people paid to bash him, I doubt anyone has the same incentives.
- bentcorner 4y agoPersonally that Brave Browser article a few days ago looked quite strange (to me, at least). A lot of top-level comments positive about the browser within a relatively short period of time after posting. Not a lot of commentary about the company itself and related controversies. That only happened after the post hit the front page.
- kbelder 4y agoI made a positive comment in maybe that thread, and I'm a human, and sadly enough nobody has ever even offered to pay me money in return for an internet post. Seriously, I found myself thinking that most of the criticism against Brave is done by... not an organized group, but a group that is predisposed to loudly criticize it regardless of any actual failing or problem. But that kind of thinking is unfair to the vast majority of posters, pro OR con, who are honestly expressing their opinions. It's probably best to assume good faith, as the good lord and HN guidelines dictate.
- qzx_pierri 4y agoBrave fans are relentless in their pursuit to shill the browser to others. It’s why the browser has such a stigma. The browser has a shady reputation due to the fact that every comment section attached to a Brave topic is filled with “Brave is perfect and if you disagree, then you’re wrong” level responses.
- bawolff 4y agoBy that metric, rust must be the worst programming language ever ;)
- lamontcg 4y ago
- 4y ago
- robswc 4y agoI honestly think its just easy to hate on well-known companies. Wouldn't be surprised to find out that most posts that go that way are legit. On the other hand... I'd be more suspect of posts about random companies that pop out of no where and get a ton of random engagement. * of course, not implying start ups don't go viral, etc.
- ekianjo 4y ago> I honestly think its just easy to hate on well-known companies. Wouldn't be surprised to find out that most posts that go that way are legit. What happens is that probably bots/alts do all the work at first to bad-mouth specific companies often enough, until it gets a critical mass and all simple-minded NPCs end up parroting the same narrative.
- robswc 4y agoehhhh maybe? I mean take google for example. Who is paying money to have bots come on here and claim "google starts 100 projects and never finishes them" ? Everyone knows that, because everyone is/was a user of those projects, lol. It's easy to meme on them for that.
- Barrin92 4y agoon a forum like this the most straight forward explanation is almost always organic pro-tech bias given the audience, or the opposite, extreme distaste for particular companies. I honestly doubt this mindset of smelling psyops everywhere, especially on a tiny forum that gets maybe a few hundred comments on every article is a good idea.
- version_five 4y agoMy guess is the closest thing to coordinated "psyops" that HN has ever seen is when an aspiring "founder" asks a group of his buddies to upvote his post and make accounts to give praise or ask softball questions (which I have seen). But it feels like in every controversial discussion there are accusations of being a shill or astroturfer or whatever in the pay of the enemy. I've been occasionally accused of this myself. I think it's just a lazy substitute for debate rather than an accusation that's actually been thought out or is even believed in any way. I have no insight into how psyops are run, but I find the idea of an agent springing into action because a HN article critical of or praising X has just come along. Who knows I guess...
- bombcar 4y agoYou can see benign psyops on any thread about cloudflare or stripe. The speed which high-levels appear means it’s being monitored for sure.
- gigel82 4y agoI personally encountered unexplained behavior like this whenever I make comments critical to Apple (I'm specifically concerned with their "privacy" PR hiding a nascent mega-ad empire so mostly comment about that) and Elon Musk being anything but perfect (particularly expressing doubt on his new initiatives based on his track record of over-promising and -severely- underdelivering). I'm convinced there are genuine people that believe Apple / Musk can do no wrong, but the veracity of flagging and downvoting is making me suspicious to something more going on.
- simondotau 4y agoI don't think I've ever heard people claim that Apple or Musk "can do no wrong". Not even their most enthusiastic proponents. What I do hear from their proponents (including myself) is push-back on provably false claims, conspiracy theories, and opinions-declared-as-fact. I don't think you'll find many devout fans who will defend Apple's intransigence with the butterfly keyboard debacle. Or how they're marketing ProRes RAW video codecs on a smartphone that doesn't have a USB-C port. As for Musk, he's just a person. I am impressed by what he has achieved and I greatly admire his work ethic. That doesn't mean I defend the entirety of his character. But his flaws aren't reason for me to avoid rebutting claims which are obviously false, such as claims that he's just a "cheerleader" with no particular skills. You mention a "track record of over-promising and severely underdelivering" but I wonder if that's just a matter of which parts of his track record you place emphasis on. Far from over-promising or under-delivering, Falcon 9 is an astounding success. Dragon is an astounding success. Starlink is providing a level of service previously unheard of and is now the largest fleet of satellites by an enormous margin. The Model S was described as vapourware before its release, then it won multiple car of the year awards. The Model 3 was described as vapourware before its release, then it won multiple car of the year awards. The Model Y is currently the top selling car in Germany. I don't recall any of them turning out to be flops or disappointments. The yoke steering wheel was described as dangerous and maybe illegal, and it won't make it to any production vehicles, then it was released and the howls of controversy vanished overnight. Right now the criticism is focused on claims that Full Self Driving (FSD) Beta is vapourware. For a long time it was described as impossible. And also that it's scandalous how it is taking some years longer to complete than initially estimated. And also it doesn't work. And it is killing people. And it's unimpressive and Tesla's technology is dead last among competitors. Just don't look at YouTube.