3 ms·
The GDPR is not "the source of the now-near-ubiquitous cookie-consent noise". Rather, those banners arose from malicious compliance by companies protesting the
by mindslight 4y ago
The GDPR is not "the source of the now-near-ubiquitous cookie-consent noise". Rather, those banners arose from malicious compliance by companies protesting the earlier EU cookie law, and you've seemingly fallen for the ruse. Furthermore, the GDPR fixed the loophole that made this malicious compliance technically legal. So the only take away from your point is that enforcing regulations on large companies suffers from incompleteness, which is obvious.
Your assertion that the GDPR affects "personal ownership of other people's perception of you" is blatantly false. From the GDPR: "2. This Regulation does not apply to the processing of personal data: ... (c) by a natural person in the course of a purely personal or household activity". It explicitly excepts regulating personal activity, and instead focuses on commercial activity - ie companies. Companies do not have some inherent right to keep surveillance records on individuals. And this often referenced idea that company behavior is
merely individual behavior scaled up is utterly fallacious, starting with the fact that companies are formed precisely to shield liability by diffusing responsibility.
And sure, the corporate lobby is extremely powerful in the US, so I agree I'm dreaming to think that any law would ever hamper the credit surveillance bureaus - they already bought their regulatory capture with the indemnifying "Fair" Credit Reporting Act. But still if we're talking about what ought to be, then a law that would allow me to opt out of their keeping surveillance records on me is sorely needed. I for one would be happy to live without them.
- shadowgovt 4y ago> those banners arose from malicious compliance The consequences of malicious compliance must be considered for every law passed. That's fundamental to the process of law, because humans react to incentives and are often selfish (or at least, self-focused). There was very little carrot attached to the law and plenty of stick, so people pushing right up to the edge of what the law allows was completely anticipated. Can't blame people with goals opposed to the law for legally bending the law to reach those goals. I like thinking about what ought to be, but I sure get burned too often by people passing laws in that direction who haven't paid sufficient thought to what is.
- mindslight 4y agoI agree that the cookie law was a terrible law, written by tech-ignorant politicians who reached for a naive solution - one that already existed as a configuration option in web browsers. Malicious compliance within the letter of the law should be anticipated, yes. But malicious noncompliance is still illegal, like these GDPR-inspired faux-consent popups. The framing of consent in the GDPR is precisely because of how the cookie law played out. I find it curious that your nick is "shadowgovt", yet you're arguing against attempting to regulate a shadow government. Are you like a shadow government enthusiast or something?
- shadowgovt 4y agoCheck my profile, it's a reference to a song. The crux of the song is shadow governments do not exist. It's just people doing their best with the incentives before them.
- mindslight 4y agoAh, the irony of music lyrics explains the inversion. (TMBG has always been in sort of a blind spot for me.) FWIW you can hand wave away the existence of overt governments with the same rationale. Identifying and naming emergent structures is how we make sense of the chaos.