3 ms·
My partner had a clinician review her paperwork and say "why are you here" explaining the enhanced imaging was leading to tentative concerns being raised about
by ggm 4y ago
My partner had a clinician review her paperwork and say "why are you here" explaining the enhanced imaging was leading to tentative concerns being raised about structural change so small it was below the threshold for safe surgical treatment.
Moral of the story: the imaging has got so good that diagnostics is now on the fringe of over diagnosing and the stats need to catch up
- lostlogin 4y agoThis has been a thing for a long time, with MRI in particular. It gets quite philosophical. To diagnose something you need some pattern on the images. As resolution and tissue contrast improves you see more things, and the radiologist gets to decide if the appearance is something. When a clinician says there is a problem in some area of anatomy and there is something on the scan, the radiologist has to make a call. The great thing about being a tech is that making the call isn’t my job. I have noticed that keeping the field of view small tends to make me more friends. A half imaged liver haemangioma, a thyroid nodule or a white matter brain lesion as an incidental finding are a daily occurrence at least.
- steveBK123 4y agoI think it cuts both ways though, over-testing vs under-testing, as the question is when do people actually get access to imaging, and is there more pro-active imaging screening we should have done. A good friend recently had an unrelated routine surgical procedure go awry, that lead to a CT scan to check on the damage. The CT scan ended up finding stage 2 cancer, larger than a billiard ball, in an organ that is going to be surgically removed. Our friend had absolutely no symptoms of any kind related to the cancer. There is no reason he would have gotten a CT scan other than the unrelated surgical accident. Imagine in 5 years he finally had had some symptoms, they do the scan & and find its stage 4, sorry. The fact that we only have routine screening regiments for a handful of cancers (breast, colon, prostate, skin) is something that I've been thinking about a lot lately.
- ggm 4y agoYes. And the balance between under testing and some loss of early treatable detection and over testing with some incurring unneeded operations is a hard one. Everyone tends to the over test side. For some things like knee operations the evidence appears strong that surgery is the worst path to take in most cases. Surgery stems from improving imaging of knee joint tissue. Treatment regimes need to catch up to return to a sweet spot of detection and remediation. My partner feels her breast tissue calcification detected in improving imaging of annual checks should have been left alone and incurred discomfort and scarring she didn't need, but we both know breast cancer survivors who owe their life to detection and intervention
- hef19898 4y agoOne of the first things AI will be really good at will be image post processing. Even then I, in case of medical diagnosis, I'd prefer to have an actual person compare the "RAW" image to whatever the AI came up with. Simply because post processing can create artifacts that can throw you of quite a bit. Regarding tue quality of imaging: I tend to agree, and the better imaging gets the more we will have to relly on humans to judge whether or not treatment is necessary or recommended. That judgement alone is, IMHO, in the same league as full self driving and requires general AI.
- lostlogin 4y agoThe raw image is not good and isn’t usable. AI denoises and this is what makes it usable. Then it doubles the resolution. There is no point in reviewing the raw image as it doesn’t add anything. A study is generally 300-1000 images. If you’re going to review the raw and therefore look at 600-2000 images you’ve just wasted everything AI gained and you might as well not use it. I acquire the images and I look at what I get and re-run anything that’s got artifact. This is not unusual and generally happens due to movement, excessive image noise or incorrect parameter selection. I don’t review the raw, but I do review the output. Keep in mind that MR images have always been very heavily processed at every stage of image formation as any way of squeezing more out the the acquisition will have time benefits. There are a ton of ways a tech can create a misleading or faulty image with parameter selection which leads to an incorrect diagnosis. This could happen quite easily and AI being part of any error m is not something that keeps me awake at night, unlike other other parameters with which I have seen mistakes and have made them myself.
- hef19898 4y agoThanks for the explanation! Shows that some knowledge in digital photography doesn't translate into other domains taking pictures. Comments like yours are what I love about HN!