A lot of these thought experiments are just semantic arguments in disguise. We think we disagree about physicality of consciousness, but we're actually disagre

A lot of these thought experiments are just semantic arguments in disguise. We think we disagree about physicality of consciousness, but we're actually disagreeing about meaning of the word "all". She knows all there is to know about colors. This might be a good linguistic discussion, but it's unlikely to move us anywhere on physicality of consciousness.