3 ms·
Regulation isn't always good. I'd say it's mostly bad. For example - in my country for more important contracts (like selling house, etc) there is a requirement
by ajuc 15y ago
Regulation isn't always good. I'd say it's mostly bad. For example - in my country for more important contracts (like selling house, etc) there is a requirement, that apart from both sides signs, that "notariusz" (dictionary says it's notary public) will sign this contract.
"Notariusz" is regulated job, there is constant amount of them (you have to pass very hard exam to become one, and mostly being a notariusz goes from father to son ,because others won't pass exams somehow). People are required to hire a notariusz to check important contracts, and notariusz gets percentage of contract worth for a work, that any intelligent people will do anyway (like checking ground register before buying a house, etc).
I do think they are sometimes usefull, but why regulate them? Why are they mandatory? People that want to risk should be able to risk, people that want to be safe can pay more to be safe. In IT various schools and certificates exists, so people can prove, that they are good enough to do some job. There are bad schools and better schools and certificates, why do you think state will be better at assesing people qualifications than private company (which sole buisness model will depend on being good at that). Why is state always trying to do others work?
I'd much prefer free market in such matters. The same goes for engineers, architects, etc. Just make sure people are responsible for their errors, and there would be cheap but risky architects, and expansive but safe ones. And insurance companies would require you to hire these with respectable certificates.
No need for state to mess with this.
- waitwhat 15y agoI'm curious how you stand on the regulation of insurance companies. Do you think this is something that the free market should also take care of? And what about (retail) banks?
- ajuc 15y agoRetail banks are special case, because they are given special government permission to multiply money, and if abused, this priviledge can make the whole economy crash. So banks that lend more money than they have should be controlled by someone. And banks are only a few in a market, big, and can easily ignore new companies wanting to certificate them, making these certificates worthless. So there is need to regulate banks. With workers it's not a problem, so there is no need for state to get involved. Regarding insurance companies - I don't think there is inherent need for regulation. A few broken insurance companies won't destroy economy. For their clients it will be a problem, but that's also true for other activities we currently don't regulate. At first, insurance companies wasn't regulated, and they somehow managed to work. Now people expects state to regulate them, so we trust unknown insurance companies too much, so if we were to stop with regulation, many people will lose. But if we did not started regulating them before - this would not be a problem.