4 ms·
A mental trick that helped me understand the concept of “an observer” in particle physics is to imagine it like playing billiards in a pitch black room. In nor
by snowwrestler 4y ago
A mental trick that helped me understand the concept of “an observer” in particle physics is to imagine it like playing billiards in a pitch black room.
In normal human-scale billiards, there are immense numbers of photons flying around bouncing off everything. The photon interactions are far too small to affect the path of a moving billiard ball, but we can detect them easily with our eyes. So we can use photons to passively observe the balls rolling around.
But when you’re trying to observe a photon itself… there are no tiny photon-equivalents flying around. It’s like playing billiards in pitch black: the only way to know which direction a ball is rolling is to touch it. And you can’t touch a rolling billiard ball without changing its path somehow. Likewise, you can’t “observe” a single photon without interacting with it in some way.
- JackFr 4y agoI know all analogies are imperfect, but that is a really great one. It really captures the problem of observing so elegantly.
- Dx5IQ 4y agoObserver effect while applicable is distinct from Quantum Weirdness aka Heisenberg Uncertainty
- Comevius 4y agoThis is a great analogy, but also in experiments the presence or absence of the measuring device like a beamsplitter determines the outcome. The measuring device, the which-way detector is the observer, and it can be regarded as a quantum mechanical system. It's correlations with the rest of the system causes the particle behavior.