3 ms·

I am trying to understand what point you are trying to express that is not already very well expressed in the article. Or are you repeating one of the several c

by distcs 4y ago

I am trying to understand what point you are trying to express that is not already very well expressed in the article. Or are you repeating one of the several counterpoints mentioned in the article? If so why is this one counterpoint more important than the other counterpoints made in the article?

PixyMisa 4y ago
The point here is that the argument is not internally consistent. If Mary knows everything there is to know about colour vision, that includes knowing the experience of seeing the colour red. If she doesn't know that, it simply contradicts the premise.
- distcs 4y ago
  Once again, all of this, including what you just said in this comment is already discussed in the article!
  - the_af 4y ago
    I find your comment puzzling. So your objection is that we cannot restate or emphasize the opinion that this thought experiment is flawed? If so, duly noted.