4 ms·
> Edit-> please, think about this: can the "result" of any thought experiment be surprising, not what you expected? The thought experiment is not to produce a
by lelanthran 4y ago
> Edit-> please, think about this: can the "result" of any thought experiment be surprising, not what you expected?
The thought experiment is not to produce a new artefact that you would traditionally call "a result", like a table of subjects responses, or a histogram of responses, etc.
It's to make the researcher consider stuff that cannot be tested, but might be feasible.
> how the setup makes no sense at all because, for starters, there's no way to make a real experiment that's truly equivalent.
That's the whole point. If you can make a real experiment, then it's not a real thought-experiment, is it? The article actually addresses this:
> But this issue need not concern us, because philosophical thought experiments depend on logical coherence rather than practical feasibility.
IOW, it depends on the argument being logically sound, not practically proven.
- narag 4y agoI do know what a thought experiment is. What I'm trying to point is that they never are really useful because the very reason that makes them unpractical is the reason that make them invalid. That reason is often shadowed by other reasons, but it's the fundamental flaw. You can turn that around: the differences between the reality and the alternate reality in which the "experiment" is possible are the key to the question.
- lelanthran 4y ago> I do know what a thought experiment is. What I'm trying to point is that they never are really useful because the very reason that makes them unpractical is the reason that make them invalid. That reason is often shadowed by other reasons, but it's the fundamental flaw. I understand, but ... you don't judge whether something is useful (or not) according to some arbitrary goal, you judge based on the specific goal intended. In this case, the goal is "Does the process result in further lines of thought to exhaust, or further discussion?". I mean, you wouldn't call a brain-storming session useless if it resulted in a conclusion of "no practical implementation is feasible at this time", would you?