3 ms·
If you don't start by pushing the cars out of the neighbourhoods and making them more human-friendly then transit is DoA - no-one will choose transit over drivi
by lmm 4y ago
If you don't start by pushing the cars out of the neighbourhoods and making them more human-friendly then transit is DoA - no-one will choose transit over driving door-to-door when they don't have to pay for the externalities of the latter. Yes, you probably do have to include some amount of parking at the edges of the superblock initially, and you probably have to build up your transit network in tandem with making your city more walkable. But small walkable neighbourhoods that you gradually expand are the only way to bootstrap it.
Note that you don't have to replace car commuting to reduce car use on the margins. Most car journeys are short, e.g. going to the nearest shop, or taking children to/from school, and a superblock with parking on the edge can mean people don't drive for those journeys even if they still commute by car. Getting a household to go from 2 cars to 1 is just as much of a win as getting a 1-car household to eliminate it completely.
> And then if you have the transit, do you need the superblocks - lots of walkable cities with streets open to cars.
Such as? Where I live (Tokyo) most streets are "open" to cars in that a car can drive down them, but they're narrow with low speed limits and cars are expected to give way to pedestrians, which is much the same as on the inside of a superblock. You can't make a walkable city without putting walkers first.