2 ms·
Just playing devil's advocate, but you say the one side ignore women's autonomy in favor "murder" can also be flipped in saying that focusing on autonomy is ign
by dylan604 4y ago
Just playing devil's advocate, but you say the one side ignore women's autonomy in favor "murder" can also be flipped in saying that focusing on autonomy is ignoring the murder aspect.
In this day and age, everyone talks past each other, but nobody hears the other regardless of the topic.
- soulofmischief 4y agoYou're absolutely correct. In my case, I was forced against my will to attend a March for Life event in Washington, DC 12 years ago. I refused to hold any signs or chant anything, but I got intimate experience with the rhetoric used in these protests. I also have had an abortion so I have seen the protests from the other side as well. Almost got in a fist fight with a grown man who spit on my girlfriend, but opted to get a security guard to call the police instead. My experience led to me oversimplifying the argument to make a point, but it's definitely more nuanced.
- godelski 4y ago> My experience led to me oversimplifying the argument to make a point, but it's definitely more nuanced. I'm finding that as information is becoming increasingly accessible that this seems to be becoming more common: oversimplification. Maybe this is through attempts to understand more about our world but not having enough time to learn the nuance. Maybe willful ignorance. Maybe the disseminators of knowledge are bad (quality) or bad actors. Probably all the above and more. But I do know that there are plenty who use these concepts to deceive us. It is easy to see that authoritarian powers love to overly simplify concepts and create hard boundaries: defining good and evil. I do think the cure to this is encouraging nuanced discussions. But the cure is much harder to take than the poison. So I'm not sure if there's a better solution.
- godelski 4y agoYou're right, but I would avoid the phrase "devil's advocate" because it often indicates something armchair "I want to argue just to argue" is coming next, not something more nuanced. I just mention this because at the root of what you're talking about is psychological priming and we should be aware of it when learning how to communicate better. I think people are ignoring the arguments of the other sides and frequently talking past one another because of this priming effect. Since communication has a substantial amount of implicit information being passed (a lot more than we give it credit for) this priming can make us make faulty assumptions about another's positions. To bring up another very clear example of people talking past one another is whenever anyone discusses "capitalism" or "socialism", as the two main groups are typically using different definitions for each word. While one may recognize this, neither is willing to discuss with a more unified definition or listen to the other's arguments under the definition that they are using. Which breaks down communication. After all, communication is in 3 parts: 1) what you intend to say (the idea in your head), 2) what you actually say (the thought embedded/encoded into language), 3) what is head (the language decoded into the listener's brain). The system is highly noisy at each step and assumptions are made by our minds in attempts to extract the signal from the noise. But this is probably just fancier language to explain the concept of good faith.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoHow about we just continue using well-known idioms? I think you should avoid the phrase "avoid the phrase" because that indicates that you just don't want to talk about the phrase due to childhood issues. But does it really?