3 ms·
> All you need is the wrong captain at helm Even if you don't buy the argument of turnkey tyranny (the above concept), it is also important to remember that no
by godelski 4y ago
> All you need is the wrong captain at helm
Even if you don't buy the argument of turnkey tyranny (the above concept), it is also important to remember that nothing is unhackable. So if you're the "well I trust X" or "what is X going to do with it, sell me ads?" type, you should also question "What ,,could'' my enemies do with this data?" (Foreign or domestic. State sponsored or run of the mill hacker)
While governments can be the most egregious abusers of this data, they aren't the only ones that can abuse the data. We have hundreds of reports about cops stalking their (current and former) partners, hackers blackmailing high profile people (including politicians), and plenty of reports about how nation states use this data to influence your countrymen. You may be immune (you aren't) but is everyone else?
I think pigeon holing this conversation to governments is wrong. There's a whole laundry list of potential problems with data collection like this and checking off any item on the list is generally enough to be against this type of policy. For example, I don't think anyone wants a national repository of children's IP addresses. That's not only valuable to nation state actors (who want to influence the next generation), but also pedophiles.
With intentions to protect children you end up actually putting them in more danger. We should HIDE children's personal data rather than gather it. But the only way to do that is to hide everyone's data.
Edit: I do believe in turnkey tyranny. I'm just saying that the argument isn't effective to everyone (as time has shown). I'm saying that when you run into these people don't keep talking about turnkey tyranny, shift your argument to one of the other many issues to choose from. One of them will (likely) be something they care about and use that as the baseline for your argument. If you keep arguing something that someone doesn't care about then I'm not sure how you all expect to convince anyone. Our exclusively turnkey arguments have been ineffective, let's adopt a better strategy.
- soulofmischief 4y agoI don't know. To me, it's like arguing that cannabis is relatively safe to consume and has health benefits. Completely sails past (and loses by default) the argument of personal autonomy. By shifting the discussion away from turnkey tyranny, we're admitting, at least for the moment, a defeat in that argument.
- godelski 4y agoI think you've really missed my entire point. My point is that we should include several arguments. Pigeon holing means having a strict focus. I'm arguing that ONLY talking about turnkey tyranny is not a good argument. Let's be real, we've been having this discussion since long before Snowden. Clearly it, alone, is not effective. So I'm not arguing to abandon the turnkey tyranny discussion, but expand our discussion to include issues beyond it.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoturnkey tyrrany, as you call it, should be enough.
- godelski 4y agoShould, but isn't.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoshould in this case means is, even if you disagree.
- godelski 4y agoTurnkey tyranny is a good enough argument for you, me, and many others. It isn't for a lot of others though. This is indisputable. We have decades of history of making this argument and have garnered little support through the argument. Ipso facto, it is not good enough. I understand what you meant, the problem is that you're wrong.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoYou have many people trying to explain it to you, figure it out or don't, not my concern.
- 4y ago
- sterlind 4y agothe recent abortion laws have made the turnkey tyranny argument more convincing and practical, lately. states have subpoenaed tech companies for surveillance data, attempting to catch women who seek abortions out of state. even my non-techie friends are wary now about period tracking apps. regardless of your stance on abortion, and the extent to which law enforcement seeks this data, it's woken up a large chunk of the population to the risks of their personal data.
- gleenn 4y agoApple and PlannedParentHood both have apps to track cycles and store data encrypted on the device only, tell your friends https://lifehacker.com/why-apples-period-tracker-data-is-more-private-than-oth-1835248220 https://lifehacker.com/why-apples-period-tracker-data-is-mor...
- godelski 4y agoI do agree with this point and have adapted my arguments to point this out when I'm discussing with people who care about abortion rights. But when talking to more conservative types these arguments are often less effective. So a different strategy is needed for them. Though there are definitely turnkey arguments for them. They tend to be easy to convince since despite voting in authoritarians they are also highly concerned with authoritarians. Just the left kind. So s/Trump/{Obama,Hillary,Pelosi}/g and s/abortion/guns.
- __turbobrew__ 4y ago> states have subpoenaed tech companies for surveillance data, attempting to catch women who seek abortions out of state Do you have a source on that? I’m not American so this is astounding to me.
- sterlind 4y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/aug/10/facebook-user-data-abortion-nebraska-police https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/aug/10/facebook-use...