4 ms·
What kind of data can the app collect? I don't use TikTok, but it seems to be video entertainment. It gets access to your location, and it knows a ton about wh
by jfengel 4y ago
What kind of data can the app collect?
I don't use TikTok, but it seems to be video entertainment. It gets access to your location, and it knows a ton about what videos you like, but is that really all that useful? TFA cites "phone numbers, birthdays and draft videos" -- the first two are hardly secret, and the latter is specifically stuff that you were planning to make not-secret.
Sure, it's not great that they're following you, but TikTok is hardly alone in that. Your location is also a terrible secret.
I can see objecting to TikTok as a propaganda machine (even if the US is hardly in any position to be complaining about others' propaganda machines). But I'm unclear on just what kind of surveillance they think is going on here, or why the Chinese government would find it especially useful.
- Nextgrid 4y agoIt also infers social graphs. I'm sure it has the option to collect contacts, but even without it, even the links you share are unique and embed your profile information (there is no easy way to share a canonical link to a video that doesn't link back to your own profile). It also no doubt does a lot of tracking based on IP addresses to find out which users are in close proximity or even share the same internet connection.
- cwkoss 4y agoAt least the way I use tiktok, it would be terrible at this. 90% of my tiktok 'friends' are people I have never met IRL nor ever expect to interact with outside of the app. The UX encourages you to follow back strangers, so they are intentionally poisoning their own data.
- sva_ 4y agoI wouldn't be surprised if they use the video data provided by their users to build said social graph (face recognition), even including people who never used the app and just appear somewhere in the background.
- walrus01 4y agoYou can do a lot with residential IP addresses and home wifi/router connections, since very often a typical DHCP residential internet customer does not change IPs very much. Or at all. DHCP renewal request often comes back for the same IP. Or only changes IPs to another address in a very small /24 to /26 sized block that's assigned to a router in one very specific geographic area. Or you have a case like a bunch of customers all behind one cgnat exit point to the internet that also does not change in geographic scope/scale of how many cgnatted customers are behind it. As commonly seen on LTE networks. Even if you have not granted GPS location permission to an app there is a very high likelihood that other people in the same small netblock have, which greatly improves a third party's correlation of netblock-to-lat/long.
- walrus01 4y ago> Location > Location of residence and work, correlating different IP addresses such as if your client device often appears from a certain 'home' IP address during non work hours, and another set of IP addresses during work hours. > Location of where you go on vacation, and for how long (based on entirely new IP address in some other geographical location) > Facial recognition data, likely good enough over long term use with enough angles of your face to develop a high confidence model of your uniqueness as a human in the world. Getting even better all the time as front-facing cameras on phones improve in video quality. > Facial recognition data of any other persons who appear in your videos and where they are in your social graph of contacts. > Object recognition and categorization of what things appear in the background of your videos, consumer electronics, art, religious symbols, furniture, vehicles, electrical outlet shape (can be used to distinguish geographical location). > Time of day use/usage patterns > Social graph of who you're friends with, whose other tiktok clients login from the same netblocks (likely to be in the same residence, etc). Who do you like/follow and who follows you > Telemetry data from device itself for unique ios or android device fingerprinting > What content you watch that might be even slightly politically, economically or religiously related and how that content is perceived by Beijing. > Who and how many and which other people in your social graph watch anything political/business/religious related and all the other data gathered about them. > How many and which one of your friends have client devices that appear from known VPN exit endpoints or IP addresses that look "suspicious" to data sets used in the back end of the domestic China great firewall. I'd be shocked if they don't collect data when a large % of somebody's friends and social media graph are apparent VPN users. I could go on.
- gruez 4y ago> Location Who's going to grant permission location for a video app? > Facial recognition data seems plausible, but only if you're producing content, in which case everything you record is already public and tiktok gathering data is the least of your problems. also, at least on ios surreptitiously capturing facial data with front camera is risky because there's a recording indicator displayed by the OS. > Facial recognition data of any other persons who appear in your videos and where they are in your social graph of contacts. > Object recognition and categorization of what things appear in the background of your videos, consumer electronics, art, religious symbols, furniture, vehicles, electrical outlet shape (can be used to distinguish geographical location). Again, only applicable if you're posting content, and if you're posting it, it's presumably public and tiktok is the least of your problems. > Telemetry data from device itself for unique ios or android device fingerprinting Given that iphones are basically identical, the only thing you'll be able to extract is "this guy is using an iphone 14 pro", which isn't exactly revealing > Location of where you go on vacation, and for how long (based on entirely new IP address in some other geographical location) > Time of day use/usage patterns > Social graph of who you're friends with, whose other tiktok clients login from the same netblocks (likely to be in the same residence, etc). Who do you like/follow and who follows you I'm having trouble imagining how these can be used in a nefarious way, or can't otherwise be acquired through other sources. > Social graph of who you're friends with, whose other tiktok clients login from the same netblocks (likely to be in the same residence, etc). Who do you like/follow and who follows you > How many and which one of your friends have client devices that appear from known VPN exit endpoints or IP addresses that look "suspicious" to data sets used in the back end of the domestic China great firewall. I'd be shocked if they don't collect data when a large % of somebody's friends and social media graph are apparent VPN users. okay, and then what? so the next time you visit china they throw you in an reeducation camp? At best this information can be used for determining how much support/opposition the CCP has abroad, but you can just use opinion polls for that. It's not like americans are shy about expressing their hate for the CCP.
- SrslyJosh 4y ago> It gets access to your location, and it knows a ton about what videos you like, but is that really all that useful? The app was regularly accessing the iOS clipboard (multiple times per minute), at least until iOS started telling users every time an app did that. > But I'm unclear on just what kind of surveillance they think is going on here, or why the Chinese government would find it especially useful. It doesn't have to be useful or make sense to be objectionable. If the government wanted to know what color socks I'm wearing and designed a surveillance apparatus to collect that information without my consent, I would still object to it when I found out, even though that information seems utterly useless.
- angryasian 4y agonothing any different than any other social media app collect. this is all just FUD
- imron 4y ago> or why the Chinese government would find it especially useful. Let’s say you’re an individual that the Chinese government doesn’t like too much - perhaps you protest too loudly about things like Hong Kong, Taiwan, Xinjiang, or Tibet. Perhaps you’re also originally from China but are now a naturalized citizen (or perhaps your spouse is). Perhaps the Chinese would like a word with you and want you to come down to the local police station [0] for a friendly chat [1] It sure would be nice for the government to be able to locate you easily. Perhaps though you’re aware of the privacy issues with TikTok and you avoid it. Problem solved - except for your kid who has it installed on her phone so now they know where you live. So Just ban your kid from using TikTok - problem solved (hah), except they’re also monitoring social graphs so now you need to make sure none of your kids friends use it either. It’s not difficult to see how such a system could present a problem to certain individuals. For most people this kind of surveillance isn’t going to mean anything. But for those certain people of interest it could be a real problem. Maybe you’ll never cross the line between random individual vs person of interest, but do you know where the line is and how it changes and expands as all systems like this do? inb4 “but US-based social media companies track you like this too”. Yes they do, and it will become a growing problem depending on how much you trust the government of the day. 0: https://www.newsweek.com/china-overseas-police-service-center-new-york-city-crime-1753242 https://www.newsweek.com/china-overseas-police-service-cente... 1: https://www.smh.com.au/world/europe/chinese-diplomat-admits-ripping-hair-from-scalp-of-hong-konger-in-manchester-20221020-p5bra1.html https://www.smh.com.au/world/europe/chinese-diplomat-admits-...
- snehk 4y ago> inb4 “but US-based social media companies track you like this too”. Yes they do, and it will become a growing problem depending on how much you trust the government of the day. The US has literally assassinated people based on exactly that siphoned data you describe. https://www.techdirt.com/2013/10/16/latest-snowden-leak-shows-nsas-involvement-us-drone-based-assassination-program/ https://www.techdirt.com/2013/10/16/latest-snowden-leak-show...