3 ms·
The claims made in the article are developed into very exaggerated forms and thus make it really difficult to take seriously. It would have been better if the
by MichaelZuo 4y ago
The claims made in the article are developed into very exaggerated forms and thus make it really difficult to take seriously.
It would have been better if the author stuck strictly to tenable claims, since veering into amateur political agitation is usually the last resort of writers without substantial prospects elsewhere.
e.g.
>" The problem is when you can't choose someone else – when leaving a platform involves high switching costs, whether that's having to replace hardware, buy new media, or say goodbye to your friends, customers, community or family."
Here the author tries to turns a mundane observation, that switching costs are high when you put your entire life on a single platform, into an emotive and attention grabbing claim.
> "That's why plans to impose interoperability on tech giants are so exciting – because the problem with Facebook isn't "the people I want to speak to are all gathered in one convenient place," no more than the problem with app stores is "these companies generally have good judgment about which apps I want to use. The problem is that when those companies don't have your back, you have to pay a blisteringly high price to leave their walled gardens. That's where interop comes in. Think of how an interoperable Facebook could let you leave behind Zuckerberg's dominion without forswearing access to the people who matter to you"
Here the author alleges Zuck to be ruling a vast dominion of billions of Facebook users. And the fabled 'interop' shall grant users the magic key for passage through the most expedient gates into the land of unbounded freedom outside.
In reality Facebook usage is already declining in North America, and no magic keys are necessary for people to just leave and delete their accounts.
The idea of interop may be valuable yet this phrasing and casting of the folks at Facebook as arch-demons and feudal lords will more likely retard rather than promote the prospects of its integration.
- kmeisthax 4y agoThe feudal lord metaphor is entirely accurate, but for the wrong reasons. While FAANG companies do talk a good game about "stickiness" and "switching costs", the reality is that most of the time, they aren't the ones holding users in. It's actually fairly difficult to do that. Users piled into FAANG because they had things the users wanted and were able to keep out the deluge of spam and malware that is the heat death of any global communications network. i.e. anti-spam is difficult, but if we move our business over to Google Workspace, we get that for very cheap. Gmail now has a moat around it because the bar for proving you aren't a spammer gets worse every year - but everyone trusts Google's MX. Likewise, Apple's App Store lockout was so they could brag to users that "iPhones don't get viruses", because users would rather wear a straitjacket if it keeps them from getting stabbed. The underlying problem is that governments rarely actually fight cybercrime, so tech companies protected users by appointing themselves as judge, jury, and executioner. Ending the era of digital warlords is more than just repealing DMCA 1201[0] or incorporating EU DMA into local law. We need an actual government to take their place - because nobody actually wants to live in the wild west. [0] Including the equivalent laws that the US forced into a large number of other countries
- nullc 4y ago> deluge of spam and malware and DDOS attacks, to bring up a recent subject indirectly... But I think it's both are true: Explicit anti-competitive lock-in behavior exists (including embrace-extent-extinguish, closed ecosystems/networks, data lockup, dumping (e.g. giving away expensive to provide services to on-board people)), patent intimidation as well as centralizing external forces (spam, malware, DDOS, and criminal user conduct getting treated as crimes by the operator for non-megacorp operators). Which forces have a greater effect on your experience differs a lot from person to person.
- gernb 4y agoThe value of interop is that every company will ask "Click here to allow us to access all your FB data". Agree that the article is full of hyperbole that makes it hard to take serious > Then there was the law: how could you impose license terms on a gift? Sounds like most open source software. Seems like a gift but you hve to obey the license terms. I'm not saying anyone was obligated to follow Cuecat's terms. I'm only saying the sentence above is nonsense. Plenty of "gifts" require you to obey license terms. > Anger turns attention into a narrow tunnel of brittle movements and thinking. Um, Ok, so I guess there are zero effective activists? The large portion of them seem to be angry about something and channel that anger into action > With Emotional Design, Norman argued that aesthetics were functional, because aesthetics primed users to fix the oversights and errors and blind spots of designers. It was a manifesto for competence and humility. WAT? I'm not even sure what that paragraph is trying to say. The last sentence does not seem to follow from the first 2. That's about the point I decided the entire thing had too much nonsense and stopped reading, even if I tend to be worried about some of the issue raised.
- _whiteCaps_ 4y ago> veering into amateur political agitation is usually the last resort of writers without substantial prospects elsewhere. Have you read any of Cory Doctorow's other work? I don't think he's worried about his prospects, looking at his kickstarter account.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoHe has two Kickstarter projects, the first: 'Chokepoint Capitalism: an audiobook Amazon won't sell' where we are advised: 'an absolute must-read for anyone who senses that the predominant economic mythology is a lie' He further touts: 'Chokepoint Capitalism is a book about the tricks Big Tech and Big Content use to capture creative labor markets, and how we can take them back and get artists paid.' Interestingly, the second level of 'reward' offers the option of: 'Pledge US$ 10 or more Pin An enamel "Chokepoint Capitalism" pin - wear it in on your lapel, start a conversation, dismantle systems of unaccountable power.' ... The second project being a second sequel to one of his speculative fiction books: 'ATTACK SURFACE: the long-awaited third Little Brother book In 2008, I published Little Brother, a New York Times bestselling YA novel of resistance to authoritarianism. it's been published in dozens of languages and, translated and distributed to underground resistance movements in Myanmar and Iran. It's been repeatedly adapted for the stage and optioned for film. In 2013, I published Homeland, the New York Times bestselling sequel, a book that Edward Snowden took with him when he went into exile when he fled Hong Kong.' Since the book series apparently is already widely translated and published, why is a Kickstarter needed? Even in the worst case that no English language publisher will take on his works anymore, it's odd that he doesn't have the means to self-publish this one. .... In short, it seems like selling easily digestible rebellion fantasies, and I'm saying this as someone raised in Toronto like him who also likes sci-fi and is informed about the tech industry.
- Apocryphon 4y ago> Since the book series apparently is already widely translated and published, why is a Kickstarter needed? Have you not heard of Brandon Sanderson edit: seriously, your entire analysis of his current status as a professional writer, and your dismissal of this article, is because he's using Kickstarter? > selling easily digestible rebellion fantasies, That's been his entire shtick, he was a big Creative Commons-boosting, FSF-friendly, WIRED contributor type of blog pundit since the early 2000s. What you call "amateur political agitation" is Doctorow's bread and butter. It might not be for you (it certainly isn't for me), but it shows that you clearly don't know anything about the public figure you're attacking.