6 ms·
I think this is great, and though I agree that determining whether there is an "on-going cost to the manufacturer" will be a gray area that automakers will try
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I think this is great, and though I agree that determining whether there is an "on-going cost to the manufacturer" will be a gray area that automakers will try to game, I think that's a solvable problem.
The heated seats example is a great one. There is no reason for this not be a one-time charge.
On the other hand, I think it's fair to offer autopilot/"full self driving" on a subscription, or at least the upgrades as a subscription. Clearly there is a large ongoing cost to continually improve self-driving capabilities, and it seems reasonable to me to have a pricing model that reflects that.
- fintechjock 4y ago> On the other hand, I think it's fair to offer autopilot/"full self driving" on a subscription, or at least the upgrades as a subscription. Agree with your overall point. However, this probably isn’t feasible considering most companies will follow Tesla’s FSD upgrade model. Autopilot / FSD upgrades are often more safety than feature related. Allowing people to opt out of upgrades but keep their older FSD just means a bunch of vehicles on the road with depreciated safety features.
- userbinator 4y agoAllowing people to opt out of upgrades but keep their older FSD just means a bunch of vehicles on the road with depreciated safety features. ...which is perfectly fine and has been the status quo since the beginning of the automotive era --- vehicles only need to meet the safety requirements when they were manufactured.
- kyleee 4y agoNot perfectly fine in the context of “move fast and break things” software dev cycle used for safety critical things like auto pilot. Out of date auto pilot versions are going to have vulnerabilities and bugs (known and unknown) that will likely cause death, destruction, etc. on public roads
- userbinator 4y agoknown and unknown) that will likely cause death, destruction, etc. on public roads ...and so do human brains... As long as the driver is still liable, I don't see a problem.
- leetcrew 4y ago> The heated seats example is a great one. There is no reason for this not be a one-time charge. if you're referring to BMW, the heated seats are still available as a one time charge. they're just also available as a subscription if you didn't option then upfront. heated seats seem like a weird fit for the subscription model, but as long as the upfront purchase option is reasonably priced, I don't really see the issue with this.
- dahdum 4y agoThe issue is you already paid for the heating element in the seats when you bought the car, and you are driving it around as dead weight (however small). You own the heater outright, they are gatekeeping your ability to use it.
- paxys 4y agoThat has nothing to do with subscriptions. The manufacturer could still sell you the car with the heater disabled, make you drive around with the dead weight, and charge you a one-time fee to unlock it. That would be perfectly acceptable under this law.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoUnder this law that's fine sure. But how far do they go with this plan? Do they cost up each part of the car and allow you to use only that bit. And when you have bought enough of a car it can then serve as your transport? The desired rule is hard to pin down though isn't it? But subscriptions, DLC, DRM etc all grate on consumers as not quite right somehow.
- prvit 4y agoThat's been happening for ... decades? It's not unusual that the "heated seats" option just gets you a button, the heating elements are often installed regardless.
- diebeforei485 4y agoThis is also true of CPU's, GPU's, etc etc that have cores disabled. Sometimes they are are disabled because they failed tests, but other times they are disabled to fulfill demand in a different segment.
- m463 4y agoMaybe the wording should be ambiguous like "high crimes and misdemeanors" so manufacturers honor the intent of the law.