3 ms·
I don't have a link handy, but there was a huge FBI scandle where their experts were essentially calling things a match to a specific person, etc. But yes, the
by giantg2 4y ago
I don't have a link handy, but there was a huge FBI scandle where their experts were essentially calling things a match to a specific person, etc.
But yes, the science is fine if interpreted correctly. The correct phrasing would be exclude or not exclude a suspect. Or for your example, it could be consistent with someone having been in a vehicle. The problem is when the experts say they must have been in a vehicle, or especially a specific individual vehicle.
- Ekaros 4y agoThat seems something that should be criminal. And realistically always asked how many vehicles with this type of material is there around?
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoThe judge should have thrown it out. Second thing they teach in forensics is that unless I witness the actual event, it is really hard to tie it to a specific person. I can present dozens and dozens of circumstantial evidence which has sufficient weight for a reasonable person to make that inference, but I cannot attest to that.
- giantg2 4y agoJudges should do a lot of things. In reality, their quality and knowledge varies greatly.
- wahern 4y agoAny judge worth their salt would prohibit or censor witness testimony making conclusory statements, especially based on circumstantial evidence. This is Evidence 101. Everybody knows the so-called "hearsay" rule, but almost every rule in evidence revolves around one core precept--no evidence is per se conclusive, and the function of testimony of any sort isn't to submit conclusions to the question at issue. But implying conclusions is exactly what both the defense and prosecutor are working at; they're constantly playing word games, and some judges would certainly be better than others at seeing through the B.S.
- paulmd 4y agoJudges are elected in many areas of the US so they're potentially literally some rando in a robe who wants to put "bad guys" in jail, not some master of critical thinking.
- giantg2 4y agoYeah, and the other way you get judges is via appointment. So there's a chance you have a hack that put in because the executive leader likes their politics.