3 ms·
Natural systems are massively complex. We know a lot, but it is still a small fraction. It's right to question things that seem too good to be true. Sometimes t
by giantg2 4y ago
Natural systems are massively complex. We know a lot, but it is still a small fraction. It's right to question things that seem too good to be true. Sometimes that may lead to further discovery about the underlying mechanisms. Although there are plenty of drugs out there that we don't know why they work, we just know that they do.
And on that note, most doctors (that you know personally anyways) will be skeptical of new treatments as they've seen the unintended consequences of previous miracle treatments. Things that have stood the test of time at least give you a better understanding of the potential outcomes.
Edit: why disagree?
- themitigating 4y agoYou're assuming that the default is harmless. If you are seeing a doctor to seek treatment for a condition and you do nothing you still have the condition and whatever it brings. If you are deciding whether to get a vaccine for a deadly disease but 10% of the people who get it die you need to weigh that against probability you could get the disease and die. It's not 10% death vs nothing Doing nothing is still an action.
- giantg2 4y agoI'm not saying to do nothing. I'm saying new isn't necessarily better. If there's a long standing treatment with good outcomes and low side effects, then maybe it's best to use the old treatment. Take traditional joint replacement verses the cobalt replacements as an example.
- breck 4y agoI agree. I would frame though as even if you are 99.9% certain of something, you can never be so certain as to how important that thing is relative to other things. Often you are certain about something but it turns out to be a minor detail in a bigger game.