3 ms·
> You're making an extremely narrow definition of "work" that your employer is delighted by. You're paying for the privilege of getting a paycheck. I'm saying t
by kelnos 4y ago
> You're making an extremely narrow definition of "work" that your employer is delighted by. You're paying for the privilege of getting a paycheck. I'm saying that you aren't being paid for your time.
I think you still aren't really understanding the person you're replying to.
They're not saying that's the "definition of work"; they're merely -- correctly -- acknowledging that's the definition of work that nearly every employer imposes on employees. They're not saying that's a good thing, just accepting reality and trying to plan for it.
Sure, some people may work as a contractor and have compensated commute time as a part of their contract. I think that's great, but it's also probably vanishingly rare, at least in the context of office work (I've never personally heard of this actually happening, but sure, it's possible, and probably exists).
Not really sure how your "scenarios" are relevant to this. Yes, companies pay for employees to go to conferences, paying for their travel and lodging expenses, though often many companies can be pretty stingy and inflexible about this sort of thing too, setting cost limits that can make trip logistics challenging. And if a trip goes over the weekend, an employee isn't usually compensated for "overtime". And of course an employer would pay to ship needed equipment somewhere; what does that have to do with anything?
But that really has nothing to do with employee commute time. The fact of the matter is that commute time is generally accepted to be something the employee has to bear, uncompensated. I don't think anyone is saying that's a good or fair thing, just that's how it is.
> There are zero bona-fide reasons that I cannot work at home.
If you find a company that's cool with that, awesome. Fortunately there are many more companies that are cool with that than there were in 2019. But many people still do not have that option; many employers are forcing employees back to an office, and still consider time-in-office to be the only valid "work time". That's sucks and isn't fair, but that's reality. Ignore it at your peril.
- klyrs 4y ago> They're not saying that's the "definition of work"; they're merely -- correctly -- acknowledging that's the definition of work that nearly every employer imposes on employees. No, I get it. If you accept a definition of "work" that has you eating hours of overhead per day, you'll never negotiate a better deal. Don't accept it, at least not without a fight. I don't accept it.
- tharkun__ 4y agoTell us about that wonderous employer that pays you for your commute time, so that we may work there as well. And no cheating. If your employer has a "perk" that pays for an amount of public transport, that does not count. It's a perk. It can be taken away at any time and isn't part of the actual contract. It usually also doesn't pay for the entire amount regardless of where you live. It has a maximum or maximum "range". It usually doesn't pay for driving on your own if you choose to use your car. It is often money you can also use to pay your cell phone bill or somesuch, which means people that live closer can use more of it for other stuff rather than public transport. As the parent mentioned, short term contractors don't count. I'm talking employee, which is the relationship to work that most of us have. And I mean actual contractual negotiation of: OK you want to pay be $150k but I live in the sticks, it takes me 1.5 hours by car+train one way to work, we'll put into the contract that you pay X amount for car maintenance, Y for gas and Z for the train ticket indexed to inflation or I work 5 hours instead of the 8 otherwise agreed. If you find that employer, let me know.