3 ms·
That article is overstating the findings. Killing off 50% of the population can only double the prevalence of a given mutation. Aka if 20million of 100 millio
by Retric 4y ago
That article is overstating the findings. Killing off 50% of the population can only double the prevalence of a given mutation.
Aka if 20million of 100 million have X, and you kill off 50 million people then at most 20 million people of 50 million people have X. Sure jumping from 20% of the population to 40% of the population is a major change but 20% is already a large percentage of the population.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoSort of. It's not black-and-white. If the gene provides a reproductive benefit then going on from there the gene prevalence only increases. Also genes can be complex, with partial sequences providing partial benefit etc.
- devmor 4y agoGenetics is rarely that simple. Take the scenario where Gene X has a mutation that causes a chance to get a disease. Gene Y also increases the likelihood of developing this disease, but Gene Z mitigates the effect of Gene Y. Maybe you also have Gene A, B and C which don't directly effect the disease, but lead to less bioavailability of nutrients that prevent the disease. Now multiply this by tens of thousands, and maybe you also need to include RNA for some diseases/disorders and it's suddenly not very simple.
- Retric 4y agoNone of which matters unless those mutations are common in the population. Remember they didn’t DNA test a significant percentage of the population’s remains they only found things that where already common. As to your point, suppose you have 100 mutations that are impacted by the Black Death but none are president in more than 0.001% of the population. Does it actually change much if some of those go to 0.002%? No A 99% die off or similar bottlenecks can make huge changes at the population level, but a single 50% die off simply isn’t that impactful.
- outworlder 4y agoBut then, subsequent breeding will skew these results far more than the initial event. You just need a mutated Genghis Khan.
- Retric 4y agoIf they had some long term evolutionary advantage then without or without the Black Death they become prevalent either way. Genghis Khan, is known for having a great number of dependents but many of those people have zero DNA that actually traces back to him. Something like 30% of everyone living 1000+ years have decedents making up a noticeable fraction of the world’s population today. However, without some evolutionary advantage any given bit of their DNA only has a ~50% chance of being passed on to their kids.
- yakak 4y ago> In subsequent bubonic plague outbreaks over the next 400 years, mortality rates decreased. This could have been the result of changing cultural practices, pathogen evolution, or human genetic resistance. Multiple rounds.
- Retric 4y agoNone of which where anywhere near deadly enough to change European genetics. In theory it’s possible a 50% bottleneck to push a trait from 45% of a population to at most 90% at the extreme end. However, 45% of a population having some trait(s) without earlier evolutionary pressure is extremely unlikely. Thus, the prevalence of those traits would trace back to that earlier genetic pressure.
- yakak 4y agoGenes that already provide a protective function alone but cause problems in combinations like 2 copies or with other similarly protective genes are naturally going to stay around but not become prevalent. A serious event or events creates a situation where these genes become common enough to hit the bad combinations much more often. Naturally not everyone has type I diabetes and MS.
- Retric 4y agoSure, but again all that changed was a slight change in the frequency of this interaction not the existence of it. It’s simply not enough change at the population level to turn extremely rare genetic disorders into common problems.