2 ms·
I think you make a strong case for ops who can dev, but a fairly weak one for devs who can ops so I think you and the parent are actually agreeing. And this mir
by Spivak 4y ago
I think you make a strong case for ops who can dev, but a fairly weak one for devs who can ops so I think you and the parent are actually agreeing. And this mirrors my experience pretty well, I need to know the code to be able to ops effectively but it's much rarer that devs need to know how to ops to dev effectively.
And in some ways this is by design, I want to have some distance between dev and ops because it gives me the freedom to rearrange infrastructure transparently. I can move workloads between Lambda, ECS, and EC2 based on the observed performance characteristics without anyone being the wiser.
- mikkergp 4y agoThis is going to depend on a lot of things. Size of company, cloud native or not, org structure. I mean everyone would love to live in the google world where a team of SRE's run everything. But even in the world where a Devops engineer is embedded on a team there's bus factor to consider. I think most modern AWS services are more the equivalent of an API or a microservice than they are a server, and you need to understand the limitations of the services you integrate with. If you're a cloud native company and don't have a mature platform engineering team, devs are going to have to know alot about AWS. If the developer has all the information necessary to create an S3 bucket, lambda function, kinesis stream, etc does it make sense for them to offload 10 pieces of information to me, or for them to learn HCL and interact with it themselves, especially if it is something they do often. Especially if there's a central dev/ops team and they're the limiting factor. Devops taking over every infrastructure change for a broad team of devs is inefficient and expensive. It's also probably frustrating for devs that are aware of the above factors. Lots of devs I know would prefer to do it themselves. And all of this is to mention that infrastructure and integrations with infrastructure are not static. Should I be reviewing all PR's to a system that touch the client code for an AWS service, because the dev team doesn't want to learn how that service works? Maybe, but in the end I don't know if this makes anyone happy. Platform engineering is certainly the goal. Where ops creates a platform and dev just consumes that platform. But I don't know if it is realistic. Every system on rails is great until you try to take the rails off, and most devs I know hate rails :-) Fundamentally "devops" is all meant to solve human problems, not tech problems so it will have to be dynamic.