5 ms·
We have an access road that was sized for utility trucks. We had to widen it slightly because of obscure California regulations. Widening it didn’t cost $1.7M
by hedora 4y ago
We have an access road that was sized for utility trucks. We had to widen it slightly because of obscure California regulations.
Widening it didn’t cost $1.7M. However, the cost per linear foot was within a factor of two of buying a line of Tesla Model 3s. This is in an unincorporated (rural) area, on a farm.
The work lasted one rainstorm before needing extensive repairs.
I’m completely unsurprised that building a hut around existing plumbing and adding a toilet costs so much in the city. I wonder if the price includes a sink.
- jollyllama 4y agoToo many bureaucrats and construction profiteers, not enough good laborers.
- hotpotamus 4y ago
- melony 4y ago> The public toilet will be built by union workers who will “earn a living wage and benefits,” San Francisco doesn't owe anything to the tradespeople. When you share a border with Mexico, there is absolutely no reason not to outsource. Almost every city that can rapidly scale up infrastructure have access to some type of cheap labour. The rapid construction in the middle east and asia didn't happen by using union labor for everything. Nobody likes talking about the elephant in the room but that doesn't make it any less true. Most of the red tape and bureaucracy come from having too much local rights and democracy. If you can't build housing cheaply, then no amount of union rights and progressive policies would reduce the amount of homeless people.
- hotpotamus 4y agoDoes San Fransisco owe anything to anyone?
- BobbyJo 4y agoSan Francisco, the government, owes the constituents it's meant to serve, and whom pay its taxes, literally everything. San Francisco, the city and community, as a society, owes what anyone in the world owes everyone else: an ethical existence.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway0x7E6 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Arrath 4y ago
- colpabar 4y agoAgreed. They should honestly just use prison labor.
- ruined 4y agoi mean, the city has already hired police officers, who are armed. we know they're not solving murders or catching thieves, so i'm sure there's plenty of time to round up a work crew from the local population that will benefit from the toilet
- nopenopenopeno 4y ago>not enough laborers Not enough wages. If the free market is good enough for everything else, why not for labor?
- scifibestfi 4y agoIt's being absorbed by the bureaucrats who have made it cost $1.7M to build a single toilet.
- nopenopenopeno 4y agoAll government entities in the US are ultimately controlled by private corporations.
- pirate787 4y agoThere's a non-market, political outcome that's the dominant factor in the labor market -- the degree to which the federal and state governments enforce or incentivize undocumented workers.
- eweise 4y agoThe good laborers are union workers, which drives the cost up significantly.
- hexator 4y agoThe actual labor costs for the workers are not the issue, they already don't make a lot and wages have stagnated for decades while costs have soared. Also, there's plenty of non-union areas that STILL have incredible costs. Profiteering from subcontractors and suppliers is the issue. All of these bids are public, this isn't exactly forbidden knowledge.
- notch656a 4y agoSo underbid them. You just found a golden goose.
- eweise 4y ago"The actual labor costs for the workers are not the issue" How do you know? The article explicitly calls out union labor costs. By "profiteering" are you complaining that someone made a profit because there is nothing in the article to indicate excessive profit. Union labor is really expensive. It cost my neighbor who is part owner of the SF ferry building wine shop, over $8K to install a TV set because it had to be done with union labor. And get this, he was not allowed to install it himself because of union rules. I have another neighbor that works as a location scout for movies and commercials. He says all filming in SF has to be done by union workers and its much more expensive than filming outside SF.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- eweise 4y ago
- scottyah 4y agoThere’s plenty of good laborers, they just never get invited to the table
- hedora 4y agoActually, the construction workers found multiple issues with the plans, and were on the hook for some of the repairs. The profiteers were the engineers that designed the system. Each time they screwed up, they got to bill us more hours. Also, the contract with them stipulates zero liability for their incompetence. The state licensing board should be fired for allowing that. Also, we wanted to put in a more environmentally friendly, cheaper, and more reliable road technology (specifically, a permeable road), but the county blocked us, then made us pay to put in drainage to mitigate the effects of the obsolete thing they stipulated. Both the mandated obsolete road technology and the drain design immediately failed. The state regularly uses the disallowed permeable technology in this area. Since then, the county has approved similarly flawed designs at other sites, and the construction firm flat-out refuses to install them.
- jollyllama 4y agoI think we agree. I would consider the construction workers to be laborers. They're adding value. Profiteering would be collecting profit without adding value i.e. engineers and the licensing board in this case.
- nashashmi 4y ago> collecting profit without adding value i.e. engineers Civil Engineers DO NOT have the upper hand in any of their designs. They propose, and upper management comments, and they propose again, and upper management comments again, and back and forth it goes. At the end of the day, all they have done is manage a series of comments, and tried to please the client rep with something like a quick and dirty fix to whatever comments they are getting. Who has the creativity? The client rep, but he is so incompetent/overloaded/unelated that all he does is either manage from high above, or just look for ways to protect himself and the City, or ask the consultant to propose solutions and makes the smallest comments possible on these solutions, while leaving majority of the comments for other offices. This leads to designs that hardly get a fight history. And more of a sychophant-driven approach just to get nitpickers out of the way.
- cycrutchfield 4y ago
- BitwiseFool 4y agoI sincerely wonder if we have 'democratized' infrastructure and construction too much. >"First, an architect needs to draw plans for the toilet, which will then be presented to the public for feedback. The Arts Commission’s Civic Design Review committee will be responsible for conducting a “multi-phase review” of the project, like it does for all projects on public lands. According to the Arts Commission’s website, “the committee evaluates each project’s design, scale and massing for accessibility, safety and aesthetic merit.” The review process “ensures that each project’s design is appropriate to its context in the urban environment, and that structures of the highest design quality reflect their civic stature.”" I recognize that the verbiage of this quote is probably standard for construction projects in the city, and it sounds absurdly out of place for a project of this scale. That being said, at some point our elected officials just need to delegate authority and let them act mostly autonomously.
- skeeter2020 4y ago>> just need to delegate authority and let them act mostly autonomously. Sounds a lot like the representative democracy that created this mess in the first place.
- nashashmi 4y agoThis arts commission is a thorn. A roadblock. And an energy drainer.
- toss1 4y agoOr, how about spend the money ONCE and create a set or two of architectural design standards for use in city projects? These would include aesthetic design, massing, scale, accessibility, safety, etc. This is really what the whole review is doing, attempting to make the design consistent with the surroundings, which is a worthy consideration. But literally re-inventing this wheel for every project id both wasteful and guaranteed to fail, as every committee will be different. Simply pick one or two, and maybe have a standing process to update it every decade. Then, it's just specify function, dimensions, etc., and maybe "in SF-City Style A", and put it out to bid, and passe it through maybe one or two approval processes to verify compliance before digging, or even include that in the bidding process - submit your design & costs, meeting these standards. IFF the process is good and fair, they should get many good bidders (ya, big IFF).
- collegeburner 4y agosimilarly, NYC decided to pay McKinsey $4mm to answer the question of whether large, stinky festering piles of trashbags would be better in containers.
- jesuscript 4y agoSource, my dear friend. The world is just too weird for me delineate between real and unreal at this point.
- collegeburner 4y agoi know its hard to believe but https://gothamist.com/news/nyc-orders-4-million-mckinsey-study-on-whether-trash-piles-would-be-better-inside-containers https://gothamist.com/news/nyc-orders-4-million-mckinsey-stu...
- hedora 4y agoTangentially related, Folsom, CA still knows how to build stuff in a hurry: https://www.theonion.com/preemptive-memorial-honors-future-victims-of-imminent-d-1819594660 https://www.theonion.com/preemptive-memorial-honors-future-v... Separately, they completed the spillway upgrades about 10 years after that video was produced, so 1 for 2?: https://ascecapitalbranch.org/geotechnical-aspects-of-the-folsom-dam-auxiliary-spillway/ https://ascecapitalbranch.org/geotechnical-aspects-of-the-fo...
- bombcar 4y agoCalifornia can move mountains when they really need to - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ekUROM87vTA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ekUROM87vTA covers the Oroville dam disaster and recovery (the disaster was averted, and the recovery was fast). In things that are NOT obviously life and death is where it gets bogged down by people "trying to help".
- eachro 4y agoI mean the answer to this is not as simple as "yes trash belongs in trash bins". How do you organize trash pickup? Where do these receptacles get placed? How large should they be? Is this for business and residential? Do trash routes need to change as well? NYC is massive and what will probably work in a neighborhood in Manhattan may not work for one in Staten Island. It's not at all a simple exercise.
- borkt 4y agoLitigation is the enemy here. I’ve been in this from top to bottom and it’s always legal precedents that fuck everything up. Governing bodies, be they local or regulatory, are forced to broadly interpret legal precedent established in high profile situations, or small, specific legal settlements which have occurred at a local level. Lawyers then take this case law and work with bureaucrats to craft regulations and ordinances which have zero possibility of running afoul the case law, and these can become so odd and counterintuitive when broadly applied that they have wildly negative effects on the whole. A high dollar project can spend the money the develop legal justifications for getting a code variance and ignoring the precedent set by case law, but the 95% of the rest of us are forced to design, construct, and accept the baked in laws to gain the privledge from the city to operate under their purview (which ultimately puts them on the hook for any lawsuit in their jurisdiction - as they always come after cities before individuals, and the cost of fighting these always exceeds the cost of settling them). So contractors are left constructing shit they know won’t work, engineers are signing off on shit they know won’t work, and cities are authorizing construction on shit they know won’t work, all to avoid taking on the responsibility doing your job right, and to avoid the horrendous consequences that would result from the people willing to go along with this system being in the position of making actual design decisions themselves, with no legal safety nets when they fuck up. It is the very definition of a broken, unsustainable system, and there are even more levels of red tape around environmental reviews I didn’t come close to getting into. It’s a lawyers dream, the most profitable contractor in your local jurisdiction is so solely because they are the best at exploiting loopholes in the system to overbill clients, it drives away anyone who has the skill or desire to fix it, and its and civilizations worst enemy. Edit: Pardon the typos, I’ve got gig to go do as I was stupid enough to try to address a small part of this on behalf of a city’s residents, and boy have I suffered.
- testfoobar 4y agoMaybe Shakespeare was right.