7 ms·
NATO is not a threat to the survival of Russia, only to Russia's imperial ambitions. If Russia's neighbors did not feel threatened by Russia, then perhaps they
by kibwen 4y ago
NATO is not a threat to the survival of Russia, only to Russia's imperial ambitions. If Russia's neighbors did not feel threatened by Russia, then perhaps they would not feel the urge to join NATO. I don't observe anybody joining a military alliance with the goal of protecting themselves from Panama or Luxembourg.
It is a tactic of bullies to reframe "defense" as "aggression". Is me locking my doors "aggression" against burglars?
- D_Alex 4y ago>NATO is not a threat to the survival of Russia NATO has become a threat to survival of NATO. And Russia. And everyone. Think very carefully and tell me how is expanding NATO to the Russian borders in the interests of original NATO members?
- paulryanrogers 4y ago> NATO has become a threat to survival of NATO. And Russia. And everyone. Can you elaborate how NATO is a threat to itself and everyone else? It would appear Putin is the greatest threat to Russia and everyone else. He is the one ignoring Russia's own territorial treaties. He is the aggressor invading sovereign states. NATO alliances are defense pacts that are entered into voluntarily by all parties.
- azangru 4y agoI think what the parent is suggesting is that NATO's tango with Russia (it always takes two, remember?) puts the world closer to the brink of annihilation. In a context when, as the title article suggests, 70% of the world population (or maybe more? they say "almost everyone", so perhaps 5,34 billion is a conservative estimate?) may die a violent death, words like territorial treaties or sovereign states start to lose their meaning.
- kibwen 4y agoIt is ludicrous to suggest that Putin threatening to nuke Ukraine is somehow the fault of NATO. If Putin launches nukes in aggression, it is Putin's fault. Stop wringing your hands in apologetic appeasement to madmen.
- azangru 4y agoWhen Putin announced that he was putting his nuclear forces on high alert back in February or March, it was not to threaten Ukraine, but to threaten NATO countries who might come to its assistance. I have not since then heard him threaten Ukraine with his nukes. Perhaps I missed his threats? Do you have a link to one? As for whose fault is what — honestly, would you care, if either Russia launches nukes or NATO does so preemptively, and then the other side inevitably retaliates, and our world dies in flames — would you really care whose fault it would have been? Would it really matter to you?
- choko 4y agoYeah you definitely missed it. See the link below. Kadyrov is also one of the likely successors to Putin. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/russia-says-its-troops-left-lyman-avoid-encirclement-2022-10-01/ https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/russia-says-its-troops-...
- azangru 4y agoI checked out the link. Didn't the parent comment say that it was Putin — italicized — who threatened to nuke Ukraine? Wouldn't the evidence for that need to point at specific Putin's words to that effect?
- choko 4y agoSo other high officials, and Putin's likely successor making threats means nothing? You're really splitting hairs here man.
- 4y ago
- paulryanrogers 4y agoWait, "it takes two" implies some consent of both parties. If someone is accosted we don't say they--as a victim--share half the fault. Does trying to hire a bodyguard because of your aggressive neighbor somehow make your neighbor's trespassing and destruction justified? Remember NATO is a defense alliance which must be invited in. And afterward doesn't grant the new inductee any power to threaten other sovereign states. Said another way, does Putin having nukes constitute a blank check to annex neighbors?
- azangru 4y ago> Wait, "it takes two" implies some consent of both parties. Yes. In this case, both parties consent to threatening each other with their nuclear arsenals. They consent to gradually raising the stakes in this poker game, and eventually calling each other's bluff. It may very well turn out that one of the two is bluffing. Or it may not. I really don't care all that much to find out which. > If someone is accosted we don't say they--as a victim--share half the fault. > ... trespassing and destruction justified? > ... a blank check to annex neighbors? We are speaking different languages here. You are talking the language of ethics and apportioning the blame. I am talking the language of survival, which I think the article in the title post talks as well. If - following your metaphor — you live next door to a neighbor who has hired a bodyguard, and in the moment of intrusion the bodyguard and the intruder start firing at each other from a rocket launcher, explode a cistern full of gas, and as a result the intruder dies, the bodyguard dies, your neighbor dies, and you die — would you particularly care in those last terrifying moments whether it was the intruder's fault, the bodyguard's fault, or your neighbor's fault? I know I wouldn't. > Said another way, does Putin having nukes constitute a blank check to annex neighbors? Both no and yes, depending on which way you turn the question. It doesn't give him the right to do so, but it sure gives him the means.
- paulryanrogers 4y ago> They consent to gradually raising the stakes in this poker game, and eventually calling each other's bluff. This is absurd. NATO is a defensive pact voluntarily entered into. Russia's neighbors want in not because of Western provocations but because of Putin. > If - following your metaphor — you live next door to a neighbor who has hired a bodyguard, and in the moment of intrusion... Framed this way I would be the intruder, the one deciding to escalate an already dangerous situation. And therefore I would be the foolish one, putting everyone's lives at risk for my own selfish goals. > would you particularly care in those last terrifying moments whether it was the intruder's fault, ... It's kind of irrelevant once the moment is reached. The world isn't there yet. And it's Putin with his foot on the gas accelerating toward destruction. > It doesn't give him the right to do so, but it sure gives him the means. Then every nation around Russia must have nukes or an alliance with a nuclear power. Putin is the one pushing them into doing so, and he's proven that any treaty with Russia is worthless. So there's no point trying to ally with them.
- foverzar 4y ago> It is a tactic of bullies to reframe "defense" as "aggression" Of course, that is why the most common pro-NATO shilling narrative is that it is merely "defensive". NATO is just another military organization, whose business is war. And just as any other military, it will be (and has been https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_NATO_Operations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_NATO_Operations ) used as a political tool. NATO and Russia aren't allies (at best), which makes NATO a threat for Russia, simply by definition. Pinky-promising that NATO won't be used as a threat or a political tool obviously doesn't count, since there are quite enough precedents of the contrary. These are just boringly objective risk-management calculations and conclusions that any manager would reach. > I don't observe anybody joining a military alliance with the goal of protecting themselves from Panama or Luxembourg. Do you really feel like Panama or Luxembourg are fair examples, instead of countries like the US, that actually has military capability? You wouldn't deny that there are quite a lot of instances of people trying to protect themselves from the US and NATO, would you? How come? Really, it all boils down to a dangerous supremacist idea that there is only one culture enlightened and wise enough to use its military capabilities, and it is widely accepted in the western bubble. This concept is just so desired, that it erases any kind of reflection on how one can pave the road to hell with good intentions. The conflict in Ukraine, for example, was born out of a public push (by the US, mostly) for it to join NATO, even before all the bad stuff started. Ironic, really, like a self-fulfilling prophecy.
- kibwen 4y agoThis is utter nonsense. Unlike Russia, NATO isn't invading members in order to force them to join. Countries are begging NATO to let them in so that they have some measure of protection against Russia. NATO is not some "supremacist idea" of who gets to use military force, it is a reaction to Russian aggression. Ukraine did not seek to join NATO due to the US asking it to, it sought to join NATO to defend against Russia after overthrowing Putin's puppet in 2014. Quit your bullshit.
- digikazi 4y agoNATO was quite happy to bomb Serbia and Libya, to name but two.