3 ms·
As a general rule in the lab, when you find a nice signal you first check that it's not 50Hz (or 60Hz), because if the signal is too nice you are probably measu
by gus_massa 4y ago
As a general rule in the lab, when you find a nice signal you first check that it's not 50Hz (or 60Hz), because if the signal is too nice you are probably measuring the electric grid.
They found a nice signal (Figure 1 in the paper) that correlates with the oxygen level in blood that is essentially the heartbeats. So my first assumption is that they are measuring noise instead of some deep consciousness property.
Quantum effects are very important inside molecules, you can't calculate anything about them without QM (or an effective model).
There are some quantum effects in slightly larger system, like photosynthesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthesis#Efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthesis#Efficiency but it's not a global effect or something that can solve complicated problems. It's just a very local, very short lived improvement, not something that can solve the TSP or think about the meaning of life. It's something in between of the intelligence of an electric switch for a lamp and a very cheap calculator.
To get a global long lived quantum effect on a big system, you need very cold and very isolated systems. Otherwise, the noise breaks all the quantum correlation and you get a global classical system.
Being very optimistic, perhaps they measured some very local and very short lived quantum effect. My biology is not strong enough, but perhaps some of the pores of the neurons use some quantum effect to open and close, for example to let sodium get in and out, or oxygen, or whatever.
It's perfectly possible that cells use some short lived local quantum mechanics effect to improve some the efficiency of some living function, but it would be surprising that a neuron in the visual are in the back of your brain has an entangled electron with a neuron in the front of your brain that is thinking about the meaning of life.
My proposal is to repeat the experiment with other organs, like the liver, the toes or whatever organ is the most stupid organ in your popular culture. If they are only measuring noise caused by some uninteresting quantum effect correlated with blood flow, I expect it to be also visible in other organs.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoDon't ruin the puff piece by asking scientists to actually do science! They are biologists, though, who do not generally have a good track record on replication.
- gus_massa 4y agoMy guess is that the basic science part is right and they are measuring a real signal. I guess it will be reproduced, even in other animals and in other parts of the body. The part I really disbelieve is the implication that this new measurement method is getting a signal that is related to consciousness or other high level stuff. For example, quoting a quote in the press article: > "Quantum brain processes could explain why we can still outperform supercomputers when it comes to unforeseen circumstances, decision making, or learning something new." Nah.
- lostmsu 4y ago> They are biologists, though, who do not generally have a good track record on replication. What, now biologists too? o-O I thought the list consisted of economists and social scientists.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoSome fields of biology too, particularly the fields related to medical science and live organism research.
- colordrops 4y ago> There are some quantum effects in slightly larger system, like photosynthesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthesis#Efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthesis#Efficiency but it's not a global effect or something that can solve complicated problems. It's just a very local, very short lived improvement, not something that can solve the TSP or think about the meaning of life. It's something in between of the intelligence of an electric switch for a lamp and a very cheap calculator. This is far too confident a statement. I totally get that there may not be strong, or really any, evidence for quantum effects being a component of consciousness. But the converse is true as well. There is not definitive or even strong evidence that quantum effects do not contribute to consciousness. These sorts of religious statements belay a misunderstanding of nature of science - science is a process, which builds models that best fit the data found through experimentation, and the models get updated or even completely refactored as new data arrives. Science does not state anything as a definitive truth. We've seen countless times throughout history and "fundamental truths" get upended as a new hypothesis much better fits the data.