6 ms·
There's another unintended effect I haven't seen talked about anywhere: when cars no longer require human drivers, the cost of driving in human terms (time, fru
by modeless 15y ago
There's another unintended effect I haven't seen talked about anywhere: when cars no longer require human drivers, the cost of driving in human terms (time, frustration, danger) will be drastically reduced, but the energy cost will only be reduced by a small amount. The logical consequence of this is that cars will be doing a lot more driving and as a society we will spend a lot more energy on transportation overall.
- jacques_chester 15y agoThis sounds to me like the Jevons Paradox. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- brianbreslin 15y agointeresting link, do you think this increased use could go hand in hand with increased efficiency? think about it. if every car drove optimally, they would meet their planned MPG. Now no one gets the listed MPG as they all drive like, well humans.
- jacques_chester 15y agoThe point here is that very efficient driverless cars may encourage more travel than driver cars do. The increase in total miles travelled may more than offset the savings for any given passenger mile. The key to the Jevons paradox is that first order estimates of the effects of efficiency are misleading. You must also give regard to how the increased efficiency will change buyer preferences.
- artsrc 15y agoComputers that communicate could draft really well at highway speeds, and get awesome MPG. They also would rarely need to brake.
- invalidOrTaken 15y agoWhile I suspect you're right in that the # of miles driven would increase, I suspect that automated hypermiling would more than compensate for it, leading to a net decrease in energy usage.
- modeless 15y agoI doubt it. How much more efficient do you think automated cars would be? Now think about all the people who will decide to live farther from work because they can work (or play!) on their commute, all the people who will take long overnight road trips while sleeping in the car, all the cars that will drive empty from place to place for various reasons, and most of all the businesses that will all have free automated delivery. I could easily see all that resulting in a 5-10x increase in car-miles driven.
- rsheridan6 15y agoThis. A 3 hour commute would not be a big deal if you could sleep/get online/watch tv/do most of the stuff you would do at home. Commutes would also be shorter, all else being equal, since near-optimal automated driving would mean fewer traffic jams. You'd find automated commuters living way out of town in areas that are currently nearly uninhabited. There probably aren't many places in the lower 48 that are too far from a medium-to-large city to commute with automated driving. Road trips would also be easier - you'd have to be in a pretty big hurry to pay for an airline ticket when you can go 1500 miles or so in 24 hours with no effort, and without the need to pay for a hotel.
- learc83 15y ago>you'd have to be in a pretty big hurry to pay for an airline ticket That probably wouldn't result in a large net increase in total fuel consumption. According to wikipedia the average commercial jet gets 49 passenger miles per gallon. It wouldn't be to hard to get that out of a driverless vehicle, add a second passenger and you're twice as fuel efficient as an airplane.
- nextparadigms 15y agoThis is why I hope Google will license their technology only to all-electric cars. Both technologies are disruptive, and they might as well hit 2 birds with one stone.
- melling 15y agoElectric cars might not become the norm for another decade. The technology is still nascent and it will improve significantly over the next decade. Also, why would you want to restrict an improvement that could benefit gas powered cars too? A self-driving car would probably be more efficient than a human driver. Fewer traffic jams would be less wasted fuel.
- loboman 15y agoBut if less people have cars (say every 10 people share a single car), then the energy used to build cars diminishes.
- modeless 15y agoThe energy used to make a car is dwarfed by the energy it uses on the road over its lifetime.
- loboman 15y agoThat's one car. What about the 10 cars this car is representing, if it's right that 10 people share the same car? (a la zipcar). It would be good to get the data about energy consumption for car building, to answer this.
- kkowalczyk 15y agoMy assumption here is that when we have driverless cars, they wont be purchased by individuals but a few global providers will emerge that will provide those cars as a service (similar to how we only have few rental car companies, or how ZipCar is a leader in its field or how Uber is becoming a single provider of taxi-like service). In that scenario, both the cost of cars and cost of energy (gas or electric) will have direct negative impact on their revenues so they will have a very strong economic incentive to drive down that cost. A single buyer isn't well informed and isn't very rational, so a nice shape of the car might be more important than mpg mileage. Our hypothetical provider would, however, consider it one of the most important characteristics. Combine that with a great purchasing power of such provider. If they buy 10000 cars and they want high mpg, you can be sure that car companies will spend most of their effort on increasing mpg.
- gyardley 15y agoWhy wouldn't driverless cars be purchased by individuals? I want one and I have money - when they're available, why wouldn't I be able to buy one? Are you suggesting that I won't want to? I'm skeptical - the convenience of being able to use something whenever I want trumps cost. Or are you suggesting that I won't be able to?
- learc83 15y agoHe's suggesting that when you can open an app on your phone and (for the vast majority of the population in non rural areas) get a car to your door within 5 minutes, there won't be a connivence gap.
- wcarss 15y agoI believe the idea is that with time, it won't make fiscal sense. The first wave of these will be bought in small part by early adopting owners but more likely by small-time transit / freight companies looking to save a buck. Once it's a proven small-scale model, larger transit and freight systems will start using them; I'd expect ZipCar and Uber and similar services to jump on it. At this time, more and more people would be buying their own driverless car. Now picture 20 years down the road. You're a young person who can't afford a car. Do you get a job to pay to buy a car, or do you use a service like ZipCar? Fast forward 5 years, you've got a job and you could afford a car. Do you buy one to give you "added convenience"? That's what ZipCar will have to beat. If they can get a car to you by the time you're outside your house, they are actually beating personally owned vehicles, and the closer to that they get, the less likely it is people will purchase vehicles.
- artsrc 15y agoAccording to the wikipedia article, if we decide that the decide that increased energy (or road space etc.) use is a bad thing we can fix Jevon's paradox with taxation on car use.
- learc83 15y agoRoad space shouldn't be a problem, from studies I've read with increased speed and traffic density that come from driverless cars you could fit several times more traffic on the current roads.
- ajmurmann 15y agoIf every car is driven sutomatically, cars can be driven much more efficiently, since there won't be any need for stop signs or traffic lights in the current form. Cars can just coordinate that one car slows down a little and one car speeds up a little. The only reasonfor card to stop will be pedestrians. Of course I assume that there will be only driverless cars. I am fairly sure that human driven cars will be illegal in less than 20 years. Most accidents will be caused by human driven cats which will lead to a ban. I also predict that the US will be one of the last western countries to ban human driven cars
- cbr 15y agohuman driven cars will be illegal in less than 20 years I think this is very unlikely. Maybe 20 years from the commercial introduction of driverless cars, or 10 years from when they are the default?
- mbell 15y agoWhile this concept sounds amazing to me, lets not forget that we are not the majority. I just got off the phone with a relative who hates taking a plane, they would rather drive 24 hours to their destination. I consider this concept to be pure insanity, but i don't think this is limited to a small portion of the populous. There is much more at play in the mind of the 'average American(in this case)' than efficiency and 'the car will drive for me'. The lack of a feeling of person control is not among the lesser of these issues.
- bdunbar 15y agoi don't think this is limited to a small portion of the populous. I do that. But it's not because I hate planes but I've got three kids. Airfare for five to visit grandma in Virginia is prohibitive compared to the cost of driving. I'm not a nut about it: if it's just my wife and I, we fly. But on those long drives especially, I'd love a car to do the driving.
- brc 15y agoI like driving and make no apology for it. I love to set off and drive for a 1000 miles or more. I enjoy driving to no particular destination in particular. It's no more or less rational than liking golf or playing computer games.
- buff-a 15y agoActually the energy used would be reduced by quite a bit. They can drive in formation. This reduces energy expended by reducing drag. It also reduces congestion. It is estimated that congestion wastes 2.4B gallons of gasoline in the US [1]. They can take alternate routes. And if we get smart traffic signals, then they wont have to stop as often by coordinating speed with the flow system. Not to mention eliminating people flooring it out of frustration. [1] http://dsc.discovery.com/cars-bikes/do-driverless-cars-offer-safer-and-more-efficient-transportation.html http://dsc.discovery.com/cars-bikes/do-driverless-cars-offer...
- wazoox 15y agoGiven the current (and undoubtedly soon aggravating) energy crisis, on the contrary energy cost will probably be the limiting factor in most human activities in the coming decades, therefore shared cars will be making even more sense.