4 ms·
'permanently suspended' is weird in itself isn't it? Just avoiding the word 'banned' or similar.. but butchering other words into meaning the same thing?
by OJFord 4y ago
'permanently suspended' is weird in itself isn't it? Just avoiding the word 'banned' or similar.. but butchering other words into meaning the same thing?
- hairofadog 4y agoGood catch. “Suspended” by definition is temporary.
- true_religion 4y agoThat and it’s not permanent, it’s indefinite. All suspensions can be reversed manually.
- PopAlongKid 4y agoBack in high school, I think everyone understood the difference between a student being suspended and being expelled.
- jacobriis 4y agoIt's such a power move to dictate things that don't make sense or that are internally inconsistent. Suspended: Caused to stop for a while; interrupted or delayed. You are permanently stopped for a while. Unfortunately: Happening through bad luck Through bad luck (not an intentional decision we are making), our policy prohibits that. Unfortunately, your account has been permanently suspended.
- Izkata 4y agoAlso, > has been "we didn't do it, it just sort of happened"
- Karliss 4y agoThat actually somewhat correct description of situation. Computer heuristic randomly banning users, with "careful review" not involving any humans or at least humans who care about results. They did make the system but afterwards it just does stuff by itself.
- prepend 4y agoI think this is part of the super annoying to me trend of double speaking to avoid using overtly negative words. “Banned” is a negative word so we don’t want to use that. But we still want to ban you, thus “permanently suspended.” It’s not a new trend as “made redundant” (ie, fired) and “focusing on value” (ie, cancelled your project) are all over press releases and public communication. I think it makes me feel worse than just using plain language as it takes me more effort to figure out the meaning so I’m also frustrated by the fakery in addition to whatever the negative message is. Makes the speaker and organization seem stupid.
- themitigating 4y agoIsn't suspended a negative word too? Maybe banned is too vague in that it could mean you had access now you don't OR you were never allowed access in the first place. What I'm saying is "permanently suspended" isn't sugar coating what happened
- TheCapn 4y agoYou're right, they are the same, but they sound different, and kinda invoke different feelings when heard without a conscious effort to think about the meaning. This is entirely subjective, but to me saying "Banned" is terse, rough, and firm. It spits out like a slap. Being "suspended" is temporary. It sounds more gentle, less gruff. (Almost) all kids have been "suspended" from a sport or activity because of something that they did, but they were allowed to play again after a short period. The catch is the qualifier being "Permanently" changes it to being a Ban, but it doesn't sound that way at first. Language is silly. You can say the same thing in very different ways that come across more or less negative, and I think that's the same as what's happening in the corporate veiled speech.
- viridian 4y agoThere's something I find literally evil about describing firing people as reducing the workforce, or rendering a position redundant, but I can't quite put why to words. It downplays human suffering to a degree that's almost unbelievable.
- ipqk 4y agoI think there's a subtle difference. A person is banned, but the account is permanently suspended. Trump himself was banned, and one of his accounts @realDonaladTrump was permanently suspended.
- OJFord 4y agoFair point, but it's whether 'suspension' can be 'permanent' I was commenting on really, rather than that it ought to be 'banned' specifically. ('Disabled' perhaps when talking about the account, with the distinction you highlight.)