4 ms·
Even if it does violate copyright, I think there is a strong argument for adjusting copyright law to allow training ML algorithms with any data, no matter the s
by londons_explore 4y ago
Even if it does violate copyright, I think there is a strong argument for adjusting copyright law to allow training ML algorithms with any data, no matter the source.
In cases like this, the benefits of the technology are so huge, and the downsides to the original code author so tiny. Was he actually going to license that code to someone who said 'nah, I'll recreate it with copilot instead'?
Very few people successfully license anything less than 100,000 lines of code anyway.
- tokai 4y agoThere are many good arguments for reorganising copyright law. But giving tech companies an easier time stealing others work to make money is not one of them.
- arrosenberg 4y agoIt doesn’t honestly matter. If the big tech companies want to call off the IP war, thats fine, but until such a time they should be forced to play by the same stupid rules us mortals have to comply with.
- batch12 4y agoI should have some say in whether a company with a 1.76 trillion dollar market cap can further enrich itself with my work without compensation or attribution. If copilot was about the greater good, the entire product would be free at all tiers.
- trention 4y ago>the benefits of the technology are so huge, and the downsides to the original code author so tiny When this starts impacting emplyment opportunities for devs, get back to us with the "tiny" downsides.
- AlexandrB 4y ago> In cases like this, the benefits of the technology are so huge, and the downsides to the original code author so tiny. Benefits to whom? I don't recall Microsoft making this technology free for OSS development. Suppose you're right and 5 years from now everyone is using co-pilot. To remain competitive with proprietary software, OSS developers will have to use it also but they will still be paying Microsoft $10/month for the privilege. Meanwhile none of them were compensated for making this possible in the first place.
- londons_explore 4y ago> don't recall Microsoft making this technology free for OSS development. Actually, they did exactly that... Anyone with a decent number of commits to any opensource project gets a copilot license for free.