4 ms·
It’s strange to see this structure of argument: it effectively admits that we ought to do anything that a less scrupulous person or country would do, because (t
by woodruffw 4y ago
It’s strange to see this structure of argument: it effectively admits that we ought to do anything that a less scrupulous person or country would do, because (tacitly) we have more scruples. That’s never made any sense to me.
More seriously, it suggests that we ought to pursue any unethical domain so long as our perceived competitors will. Should the US have sunk billions into Lysenkoism[1] because the Soviets did, or phlogiston[2] research because there’s an off chance we’ve actually been wrong for the last 200 years?
In other words: this requires us to add a perverted normative glance to science, the kind you seem keen to avoid in the first place. Is it ideal that Americans get squeamish whenever intelligence is brought up? No. But doing something that’s largely failed to meet scientific standards just because another big country might do it doesn’t pass the smell test either.
[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lysenkoism
[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phlogiston_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phlogiston_theory
- yieldcrv 4y agoOkay, you can have that argument with a corporation. I'm having the argument with a taxpayer funded resource under the US Federal Government and it doesn't seem like a limitation it can create or sustain, legally. It should sell it off so you can have your argument.
- woodruffw 4y agoThis is a perfectly reasonable argument for any scientific funding, public or private. It’s arguably even more pressing in the public setting, given the civic interest in public institutions not funding junk science (or distributing private generic data). I don’t see why this situation would be unsustainable for the USG. It’s not a particularly unusual one.
- soco 4y agoIn WW2 you had all this "research" conducted by Dr Mengele and funded by the state. Should the US have done the same, just with taxpayer money? I know retroactively it's easy to say "no" but were you at that time presented with this dilemma?
- gambiting 4y agoHow is this even remotely comparable? Mengele "experimented" on living people, inflicting truly horrendous amounts of pain and suffering on his patients, it doesn't compare even slightly to what we're talking about here.
- woodruffw 4y agoThe context is matching the eugenics research that China is known to have done, which includes human subject research. There was a pretty infamous example of embryo modification, IIRC, a couple of years ago.
- inglor_cz 4y agoIn my view, this stuff is similar to firearms. Not unethical per se; only concrete use can be unethical. But if the West collectively and unilaterally decided to reject firearms as such back then, it would likely have been gone by the 17th century.
- woodruffw 4y agoWell, a firearm is a practical thing: it’s a weapon you hold in your arms and potentially use to kill people. I think the Lesenkoism analogy is more appropriate here: our best science demonstrates, at the most, that our strongest attempts to genetically influence general intelligence have weak effects, if any. So it’s not so much latent danger (the way rejecting firearms would have stopped much of Western history) as it is poor science that produces limited value relative to its financial and civic costs.
- inglor_cz 4y agoFirst firearms were rather primitive as well. The English famously kept on to bow and arrow until the 16th century or so. I am sure that complexity of genome and epigenome is huge and that we are just at the beginning of the journey. But unlike Lysenkoism, I believe that the underlying principles are sound. But I disagree with the idea that you can easily measure value of science by its costs, especially short term. Look no further than Katalin Kariko, one of the most important people in mRNA. They demoted her at UPenn in 1997 because they considered her research not valuable... and yes, it actually took 20 years for it to bear fruit.
- woodruffw 4y ago> But unlike Lysenkoism, I believe that the underlying principles are sound. Is this an expert opinion, or a lay opinion? Eugenics is one of those fields where there’s a split distribution: experts are generally less confident in the scientific value of eugenics research than the public is. No domain is infallible, and science is by its nature unsettleable. But the fact that a particular academic department was unfair to a particular academic is not especially strong evidence that the scientific community is wrong, as a whole, about eugenics.
- philwelch 4y agoLysenkoism was the denial of evidence-based genetic science motivated by political concerns. It elevates what powerful people will allow you to believe over an investigation into the truth free of any ulterior motives. I’m not sure that example demonstrates what you think it demonstrates. If anything, Lysenkoism held back the Soviets in competition with the West.
- woodruffw 4y agoYou just drew the connection: like Lysenkoism, eugenics is not good science. It’s reactionary sociology and political ideology wrapped in the language of genetics. Because it isn’t good science, it isn’t clear what the Chinese have to benefit from it. That’s their mistake to make, not unlike the Soviets with Lysenkoism. But that doesn’t suggest that we should blindly copy their mistake.
- philwelch 4y agoYou keep using the word "eugenics". I do not think it means what you think it means. Eugenics was the attempt to genetically improve human populations by either encouraging or forcing sterilization, abortion, and birth control among the poor and disabled. This was neither good science nor bad science, because it wasn't science at all, but rather a social and political movement as well as a set of governmental policies. (And, just as an aside, "reactionary" isn't quite the best characterization of the political ideology that motivated eugenics; eugenics was pioneered largely by American progressives roughly a century ago.) Analyzing genetic data that NIH is gatekeeping is not eugenics in any way, shape, or form. While I don't know what you're talking about when you use the word "eugenics", I don't really need to because your argument has the same flaw regardless. Whatever "eugenic" hypotheses you're worried about, if they really are "bad science", the data will bear that out and the best solution is to disseminate that data as freely as possible rather than withholding it. Conversely, the only way bad science can be protected is by prohibiting inquiry and establishing dogma by fiat, which is exactly what happened in the case of Lysenkoism.
- belorn 4y agoIt is a known issue with social science that culture will bias research focus and conclusions that align with where the researcher lives. A typical finding is that US researcher tend to find research data that demonstrate individualistic virtues, while places like China and Russia tend to find research data that demonstrate collectivism virtues. In general there are a few conclusion that should be drawn from that. One is that researchers tend to focus on research subjects that align with their own cultural biases, so while the data might be unbiased the choice of research subject is not. It is that naturally those researcher will have a harder time considering alternative explanation for a given set of data, even if that data itself is unbiased. The key is always to consider culture into context of research and understanding how it limits the ability of the researcher, especially when politicians take such conclusions and runs with it.
- woodruffw 4y agoThis is a very vague response. I’m not really sure what it’s supposed to say — of course scientists are affected by the cultures they live in. But eugenics is not even good science, much less a popular social opinion. I believe that’s true just about everywhere.
- belorn 4y agoEugenics is politicians taking science of genetics and running with it in the context of certain cultural and political ideologies. The science of genetics is good and has significant contributed to medical science, historical research and our understanding of human, animals and plants. It has contributed to research of plants and animals, and the worlds ability to both feed people and to conserve the environment. Eugenics is not science. It is a set of political beliefs and practices.
- pannSun 4y ago> Is it ideal that Americans get squeamish whenever intelligence is brought up? But they don't get squeamish. They confidently claim there is no basis for intelligence (or personality in general) in genetics [1,2], then use any differences in behavior or outcomes as evidence of racism. [1] I am, somehow, less interested in the weight and convolutions of Einstein's brain than in the near certainty that people of equal talent have lived and died in cotton fields and sweatshops. ― Stephen Jay Gould [2] In fact, you did so in your very post, comparing the link between genes and intelligence to Lysenkoism or Phlogiston.
- mindslight 4y agoI don't know if you could have picked a worse quote to back up your point than footnote #1. While it is likely true [0,1] that the mean/median of one group is more genetically intelligent-capable than the mean/median of a different group, the variance is going to make it so that there are extremely intelligent outliers in both groups. And if we're focused on intelligence and its products, the potential of those outliers being wasted due to slavery/poverty/racism/etc is the travesty being pointed out by the quote. [0] Intelligence capability obviously relies on genetics. In the most obvious way, the genes of ursa americana result in a much less capable brain than the genes of homo sapiens. So, unless maximum "intelligence-capability" is the thing most strongly selected for (doubtful), genes that cause higher intelligence capability are going to be correlated with other genes that developed at the same time. But actually measuring that, in some objective way? I'd say you're better off focusing on the other end of trying to define what "intelligence" even is, at the computational level, and then the organizational level, before you can even think about judging the contributions of the biological substrate level. [1] The reason this is generally ignored or even rejected is that it's an utter red herring. At most you can say it influences individual outcomes by a tiny bit, while being overwhelmingly swamped by the larger issues of culture, nurture, environment, access to resources, and overarching personality. Meanwhile, less intelligent people love to reference their race as evidence of their own intelligence/virtue/etc, because happenstance attributes of their existence are their primary "accomplishments". So it's best to not add fuel to that fire.
- 4y ago