4 ms·
ADHD is actually one of the things that’s actually rigorously and quickly testable (assuming you’re willing to take self-reported effects / observations, you c
by Spivak 4y ago
ADHD is actually one of the things that’s actually rigorously and quickly testable (assuming you’re willing to take self-reported effects / observations, you can’t read a number off a lab test) but it’s never done because it involves giving someone without any medical diagnosis a schedule 2 drug and we moralize that for some reason.
You just give the person a stimulant and see what happens. If they get really awake, hyperactive, excited, anxious, shaky, hyperfocused, etc. then nope, if they get calm, content, or sleepy then yes. And it’s not like this is crazy in general, we do “just treat it and see if they get better” as the test for plenty of things.
Nobody bats an eye when we do the same thing for depression, it’s super common for people who exhibit the symptoms to be asked to try a few antidepressants and see if they work.
I get that some people abuse stimulants but they suuuuuuck. Life changing because they allow you to function but you will also curse them for it. The side effects are awful. So much so that I tried a bunch of non-stimulant medications until I found one that worked. Nobody who doesn’t have ADHD is gonna wanna regularly take adderall or vyvanse just because it would be miserable and that’s before the fact that they aren’t cheap.
Edit: /rant Mental health is wild because smart and well meaning people designed a system that actively prevents people from being honest and getting help. Want to talk to your therapist about your suicidal thoughts, bulimia, or self-harm, nope. Not unless you want to take a mandatory grippy sock vacation away from your support network and get set back in school or lose your job all things famous for improving mental health. Wanna tell your psychologist that you think you might have ADHD because you were at a party, tried something and it made you felt way different than everyone else, haha drug seeker.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoMany people with depression don’t improve on antidepressants so this seems of questionable accuracy.
- Spivak 4y agoBoth things are true. If you improve on them you have it, if you don’t then it doesn’t mean you don’t.
- bitexploder 4y agoThey work great for me (adderall and friends). I don’t use them because of the side effects. When I can arrange my work life to be one or two things I like I can focus and work 10 hours productively and it feels easy. Make me manage a lot of trivia and distractions happen and I fall apart. So, I pick hard things and do them and just ignore the rest. It has worked out okay.
- wikibob 4y agoWARNING The above post is utterly false. This was always known to be false, but was a popular opinion in pop-psychology for a time. It is untrue. Stimulant medications DO NOT have this claimed opposite effect on people with ADHD. This is not a view that is supported by science and is not a valid diagnosis method.
- Spivak 4y agoIf true you should let me, someone who can be put to sleep by adderall and caffeine, the degenerates I know (and love but cannot understand) who take adderall specifically for those opposite effects, and my therapist and psychologist who both ranted to me about their frustrations diagnosing their ADHD patients because they can’t use this test. I’m not even saying you’re wrong, but it doesn’t match my personal experience at all (in both directions), and the belief is apparently widespread enough that real professional mental health providers believe it. It would be genuinely surprising to me if someone who works all day with people who take these medications and talk about their effects wouldn’t be armed with a million counterexamples if at minimum the observations didn’t line up. Like they’ve got to be seeing some real effect even if the explanation is wrong.
- ryeights 4y agoSuch a drastic change in effect—a drug inducing powerful stimulant effects in one group, and sedating effects in another—should be easily measurable by study, no? Is there any scientific literature documenting this?
- llamaLord 4y agoSo I’m not saying that I agree that it’s AS difinitive as this guy makes it out to be; but as someone with diagnosed ADHD, I can 100% validate the experience of stimulants having the opposite effect on me vs my neurotypical close-contacts. I can comfortably take a nap after popping 10mg of dexamphetamine, whereas most people would be atleast moderately buzzed. And this has been the case since day 1 (I was diagnosed at 26), so it’s not just a factor of tolerance. Another great example is the fact that the single biggest benefit to ADHD meds for me has been a complete reversal of my life-long anxiety. I’m now zen as f..k, whereas before being proscribed meds I was a very anxious, hyper-self critical person.
- pazimzadeh 4y agoOne related I've noticed is that people respond to certain drugs way differently to me. For example, cannabis acts like a stimulant for me (especially the first 1-2 hours) whereas it practically puts some to sleep.
- alasdair_ 4y ago>Want to talk to your therapist about your suicidal thoughts, bulimia, or self-harm, nope. Not unless you want to take a mandatory grippy sock vacation away from your support network and get set back in school or lose your job all things famous for improving mental health. It takes a hell of a lot more than this to be involuntarily taken into a psychiatric hospital. The stuff you are saying is flat out wrong. It's also extremely harmful. I say this as someone who volunteers on a suicide hotline and takes calls like this every night I'm on shift. No one is going to involuntarily take you to hospital unless you are in really, really imminent danger (as in, you have a loaded gun and insist you will use it in twenty minutes level of danger). Just having suicidal thoughts or even self-harming will not result in your autonomy being taken away. Please, if you are having harmful thoughts, the best thing you can do is talk to someone. Don't let the nonsense above scare you away - you CAN talk to your therapist about this stuff. It's why they exist.
- Spivak 4y ago> Don't let the nonsense above scare you away - you CAN talk to your therapist about this stuff. It's why they exist. I’ve had every therapist I’ve ever seen give me a rehearsed speech about what things they’re required by law to take action (i.e 5150 although technically a different number here) for and it’s always self-harm and suicidal-thoughts, but not ideation. Maybe it varies by state? The speech always came with a wink wink just don’t tell me explicitly and we can talk about it here so I think they agree with you.
- alasdair_ 4y ago“Action” is different from involuntary commitment. All I can say is that out of the many thousands of calls yearly to the Seattle-area hotlines, the number of direct involuntary interventions was on the order of a few dozen a year at most. Yes, if you are in imminent danger, people will come to you and try and talk you out of it, and there are lots of voluntary hospitalizations, but it’s honestly rare for someone to be taken against their will and usually only happens in cases of heavy psychosis. The thing with a therapist is that many are not set up to be crisis counsellors and so they will want you to talk to someone who can help in a crisis rather than once a week for an hour. But that’s all.
- MistahKoala 4y agoPutting aside other factors for a moment, a rigorous test surely depends on the dose. Stimulants like lisdexamfetamine can be titrated over a period of several weeks to determine effectiveness and tolerance of the dose, which are unknown until tested - that doesn't seem quick to me and indicates that clinicians can't expect a binary response from a one-off dose.