6 ms·
AntiX-22 Released
- miffe 4y agoWhat is the point of a systemd-free distro? Personally, I will never go back to writing startup scripts again.
- ofrzeta 4y agoOr what's the point of having another systemd-free Debian distro when there's already Devuan?
- danten 4y agoWhat's the point in having another systemd distro when there's already Red Hat Inc? /s
- ofrzeta 4y agoThe point is these are companies like Red Hat and Suse that "naturally" compete. Free software communities working on Linux distributions would be better off to join their forces. Just my opinion, though, of course they are free to do what they want as I am free to express my opinion on the matter.
- spookie 4y agoAntiX already works together with MX Linux. But to answer your point, cooperation is independent of distros.
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y agoThe point is less mess & hassle freeness. And the ability to load it into RAM, and have it running from there, without effort, because it was made with that use-case in mind, among others. $ uptime 07:21:39 up 128 days, 21:23, 3 users, load average: 0.38, 0.54, 0.60 The above is MX-Linux actually, but doesn't really matter, because they use the same framework, and the default image contains more stuff, while Antix is more 'spartan'.
- ofrzeta 4y agoWhat's with the uptime stats? Recently I had a systemd based server with two years of uptime. Nothing to be proud of, though, because obviously I missed to install a lot of kernel updates.
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y agoYeah, got a point there. I just posted that to confirm the 'messlessness' :-) As in having booted the image into ram, chosen a few menu-items via function keys, and having worked from there. Without having to edit any 'scripts', btw. As desktop. While not having updated the kernel, it got updates for the layers above, though. Anyways, it just works for me. (Shrug)
- prmoustache 4y agoHow many times a day/week/month do you have to setup services on your computers? I tried artix (not antix) archlinux systemdless based distro mostly out of curiosity a few weeks ago as I wanted to repurpose an old computer. I was also curious of systemd's memory overhead as I've seen report of people running a base kde with little memory usage on slackware compared to other distros. Turns out that writing a service definition for runit is even less complicated than for systemd. It might not be as flexible though but I didn't reach the point when I needed those options yet. So for now I am living happily without systemd in at least one computer at my home and my quality of life hasn't changed at all, it just remembers me it is different the few times I type systemctl or journalctl out of habit.
- colordrops 4y agoBeen using NixOS for a while now. It's heavily systemd oriented, and it also makes adding and configuring systemd-based services and jobs a breeze. I find myself doing it multiple times a week.
- breakds 4y agoSame here. I do not have any opinion towards systemd, but using it together with NixOS is really simple and hassle-free.
- prmoustache 4y agoWhat I meant is that in most case, the service you need are already configure and come with the packages of the distro and the only thing you do is enabling and starting them. Which is not more difficult with runit than systemd and it is probably the same for dinit or openrc. I mean systemd is still great, it allow a regular unprivileged user to create services and timers without having admin access, which is really nice to launch automatically some podman containers for example. But this is a niche use case and mostly limited to dev/sysadmins.
- heavyset_go 4y agoHow did the memory usage comparison pan out?
- arghwhat 4y agoThe alternative to systemd is not startup scripts. There are smart service managers that do not try to take over your entire system. s6 is a good example.
- forgotmypw17 4y agoI think the point is one less giant blob of technically open, but extremely obfuscated chunk of questionable usefulness on your system. I'm not sure about you, but I've used many distros, with and without systemd, and never had to write a startup script. The package manager takes care of it (or I switch to a different distro.)
- rahen 4y agoHealthy competition between modern init systems: runit, openrc, s6, systemd... This choice should be yours when you install a system. Just like you wouldn't want to have no choice for your desktop environment (why would anyone not want GNOME?), widgets, toolkits and libraries. Choice, modularity and competition between subsystems and libraries is what makes Linux an open, innovative environment.
- lakomen 4y agoRight and every package will need to have init configs for all the systems. Are you high?
- rahen 4y agoThis is how it's already done on Devuan. https://www.devuan.org/os/init-freedom https://www.devuan.org/os/init-freedom https://www.devuan.org/os/documentation/install-guides/chimaera/img/025initchoice.png https://www.devuan.org/os/documentation/install-guides/chima... (older screenshot)
- addajones 4y agoDo most of you posting here code in Linux? Or is it just your desktop of choice. I’ve been on macOS for many years. Probably 30+ and I’ve dabbled in so many Linux distros. I do want to set up a system again that is minimal and quick. Any recommendations? Cheers!
- nicoty 4y agoVoid Linux is both minimal and quick. The base live image is <700MB. I've been using the same installation I've had for >5 years with no hiccups so it seem pretty stable for my use case too, although I only really use it for basic stuff like programming, browsing, reading books so ymmv.
- addajones 4y agoThanks for the recommendation, I’ll take a look at it. 5 years that’s great!
- stjohnswarts 4y agoRun linux in a VM like VirtualBox first and find a linux distribution that you like. I would say try Endeavor OS (arch-related), Ubuntu, and Fedora linux and see if you like on of those to start. Warning, they will run a lot faster on real hardware but VirtualBox is a good place to start.
- alfiedotwtf 4y agoArch is as minimal as you'd probably want a user system.
- heavyset_go 4y agoDebian if you care about stability and running it on anything, or a rolling release if you care about using latest releases of software. Arch is nice, access to the AUR is nice, too. You can also use Debian unstable or testing. A lot is happening on desktop Linux right now, and I've found rolling release distros to be nice for that reason. Debian or Arch with KDE Plasma Desktop is a nice combination. Regarding minimal installations, if you're new to Linux, I think you should try to use a popular Linux desktop distribution, Debian has several, there's Ubuntu, EndeavorOS for Arch, and others. You can also boot live Linux instances from a flash drive and try things out before you install. To answer your first question, I went from Linux to macOS back to Linux again. Check this if you want to use macOS keybindings on Linux: https://github.com/rbreaves/kinto https://github.com/rbreaves/kinto
- oytis 4y agoBoth radical left and radical right hating systemd is an unexpected manifestation of horseshoe theory
- spyremeown 4y agoWho even is "the radical left and right" hating systemd? It's two or three people screaming on the internet.
- sdflhasjd 4y agoWhat exactly is "AntiX"? The byline of "anti-fascist" makes it seem like something more than just systemd-free. Anti-what? It still comes with X-server... or is systemd fascism now?
- battkajs 4y agoAlong with the OS installation you get a collection of information and texts written by socialist thinkers, and other resources.
- UncleSlacky 4y agoIt's anti-capitalist, and it's been around since before systemd was a thing.
- prmoustache 4y agoI think this is also a play of word with antique to emphasis it runs on old computers as well, a kind of contraction of what would be antique linux and it is not related with being anti X-server. The distribution predate systemd so unrelated.
- unknownaccount 4y agoSomeone should create the first Linux distro that doesn’t push any political agenda and strictly prioritizes code quality over agenda enforcement.
- vortegne 4y agoIf you're vocally against an anti-fascist agenda, then that agenda is doing what it's supposed to: luring fascists out of hiding. Nothing is apolitical.
- Asdrubalini 4y agoI only want to forget about politics at least when I’m using an operating system.
- Fnoord 4y agoPolitical apathy is the one way street to an authoritarian society. Just have a look at Russia what political apathy has brought the Russians.
- Asdrubalini 4y agoI’m just talking about when I’m using my distro of choice, not in general. Politics by definition is divisive and always thinking about it is destructive, I want to relax and stop thinking about stuff at least when I’m minding my own business using Linux and sharing stuff without caring about what other people’s opinions are.
- Fnoord 4y agoYou want a distribution more akin to status quo. Great, these are widely available. But to think that Arch Linux and Debian GNU/Linux and Fedora are all apolitical is nonsense; rather, their politics are not bothering you. The only thing I got against all of this is the paradox of choice. Why so many different Linux distributions? Same in a large US grocery store. 20 brands of mayonaise, why? How can I tell the differences?
- lakomen 4y agoWhy are there so many clueless idiots on HN? I'm reminded of the web pre 2k and post 2k. This thread is post 2k, full of half truths and trolling.