3 ms·
The distribution of stress-energy is a single parameter per point in space. That is, I don't think saying "it's only a single parameter" and "it's different in
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
The distribution of stress-energy is a single parameter per point in space. That is, I don't think saying "it's only a single parameter" and "it's different in different galaxies" are compatible.
- pdonis 4y agoIf you want to say it's a "parameter distribution" or something like that, that's fine. It doesn't change the fact that this thingie, whatever you want to call it, is already present in our existing theory of gravity, GR, and is already adjustable in that theory. So we're not adding anything new to the theory if we adjust this thingie to take into account observed motions for which we can't see the gravity source that causes the motion.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoDo you understand the concept of overfitting?
- pdonis 4y agoSee the response by DiogenesKynikos. The "fitting" is not being done the way you appear to think it is.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoI don't think you understand the concept of explanatory power. Because dark matter cannot be observed we must manually tune the dark matter distribution for each galaxy. This creates new parameters that don't exist in the theory that are necessary to properly explain phenomena. Whether or not they exist in the theory is irrelevant to the fact that they are necessary.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DiogenesKynikos 4y agoLambda CDM assumes that the initial density distribution is a Gaussian random field with a spectral index close to 1. There is only one free parameter setting the distribution of matter: the deviation of the spectral index from 1. The detailed distribution of matter that we view in the present-day universe is a consequence of gravity (and other known physical laws) acting on that initial, random (but following a very simple statistical distribution) density distribution.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoThis is not true. There is not enough explanatory power in LCDM to explain the distributions of dark matter we apply to each specific galaxy, therefore there must be a proliferation of parameters.
- DiogenesKynikos 4y agoI recommend you read about Gaussian random fields in cosmology. Cosmology treats the initial conditions as random, but with a distribution that is describable by only a few parameters. You're confusing the exact realization of the random field with model parameters.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoReplying late, because I was on vacation, but just in case anyone reads this: There is a sense in which what you are saying is true. And yet, when people say "The dark matter distribution in the Bullet Cluster is <some non-trivial distribution>, they are not deriving that from the "few parameters" that describe the cosmological distribution. They're deriving it from what they see of the local situation in the Bullet Cluster. And then they say "dark matter explains what we see in the Bullet Cluster". That's what people are referring to when they say "a tunable parameter at each point in space". Without that, you have something that explains cosmology, but not the Bullet Cluster. With that, you have something that explains both cosmology and the Bullet Cluster (and a number of other odd things out there), but you no longer have "only a few parameters".