3 ms·
> Should we presume that it must be an invisible ball of matter that gravitates but we have no other way of detecting except through the same effect we use to i
by lmm 4y ago
> Should we presume that it must be an invisible ball of matter that gravitates but we have no other way of detecting except through the same effect we use to infer its existence, or should we tweak Newton's laws of physics?
"we have no other way of detecting except through the same effect we use to infer its existence" is true of everything in the universe. We believe stars exist because we can see the light coming from them, but light is our only way of detecting them.
There's no single answer to this kind of question, we have to actually do science and make observations. We should ask whether it behaves like a ball of matter (e.g. does it have a point location in space? Does it orbit the way a ball of batter does?) or like a modified law of gravity (can we reproduce the same conditions)?
The likes of the Bullet Cluster makes a very compelling case that cold dark matter is real.
- throwawaymaths 4y ago> "We have no other way of detecting except through the same effect we use to infer its existence" is true of everything in the universe No. For example, staying within astronomy, we detect gravitational waves and if we find an optical event that correlates with the gravitational waves, it is multimodal (we are at n=1), and if you don't solicit events (or if you statistically blind it by adding fake events in your solicitation) it's multimodal independent (currently n=0). Going outside of astro, you'll find very rich multimodal studies "I know what this molecule is because I have an IR, UV, NMR, Mass spec, etc etc etc"
- kotlin2 4y agoLight, in the GP’s example is also traceable back to a source. Observing an effect in a 3rd party isn’t directly attributable to anything without a plausible mechanism of action. Using light to detect stars as defense of dark matter isn’t a very strong argument.
- wumpus 4y agoI'm not sure what you're trying to say -- there are many astronomy multimodal studies.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoWe agree.