5 ms·
Hopefully this will encourage other Fandom sites to do the same. It's absolutely mind-boggling that the current Fandom pages auto-load a Twitch stream by defaul
by smoldesu 4y ago
Hopefully this will encourage other Fandom sites to do the same. It's absolutely mind-boggling that the current Fandom pages auto-load a Twitch stream by default, and replace the background with pointless high-res assets. Mix in the weird social media aspects and shitty business model... it's not a good working relationship.
If these Wiki sites want to redeem themselves, they should lean into the "clickhole" effect that Wikipedia tends to foster. A link-map (like Obsidian or Logseq) would be an actually useful UI addition. Maybe a sidebar would also be nice for navigating grouped articles.
- bobnamob 4y agoThe Path of Exile and Oldschool RuneScape wikis have gone through this same transition recently. I think this is a broader movement as a reaction to fandom’s business practices
- vintermann 4y agoIt's been going on for maybe a decade. I remember the old Tekkit minecraft modpack got somewhat around it by declaring that the Wikia wiki would henceforth be for the classic version of the modpack, and not for newer versions. People have been warning for years what a roach motel wikia/fandom is. But they zealously censor that discontent from wikia/fandom itself, so community after community has to learn it for themselves.
- i67vw3 4y agoThere is a fandom frontend https://breezewiki.com/ https://breezewiki.com/ just for this ad-spam. It is included in the Libredirect extension by default https://codeberg.org/LibRedirect/libredirect https://codeberg.org/LibRedirect/libredirect
- jmillikin 4y agoSeveral years ago the Touhou wiki left Fandom/Wikia for their own hosting. The Wikia admins responded by seizing control of the old wiki, removing any redirects or references to the new location, and banning the old admins. The community largely followed to the new domain, leaving the Wikia version in a sort of dormant state filled with spam and weird "original fan-creation" pages. https://www.reddit.com/r/touhou/comments/44prw7/what_went_wrong_with_the_touhou_wiki_relocation/ https://www.reddit.com/r/touhou/comments/44prw7/what_went_wr... https://en.touhouwiki.net/wiki/Talk:Touhou_Wiki/Archive_3#Wait..._So_this_is_a_War.3F https://en.touhouwiki.net/wiki/Talk:Touhou_Wiki/Archive_3#Wa...
- vintermann 4y agoYes, this has been a complaint against Wikia/Fandom from the start. The accusation was that Jimmy Wales favoured the deletionist faction on Wikipedia in order to push as much content as he could get away with over to Wikia, where he could monetize it. Once a wiki had been created there, it would be very hard for a different wiki to compete, since Wikipedia lent a huge part of its SEO juice to them. Wikia/Fandom regularly takes over wikis that try to migrate off the site and scrub the attempt. The biggest recently was the Terraria wiki. The fandom wiki still outranks the official in Google.
- Suzuran 4y agoIt took a couple years for the current Touhou Wiki to gain traction over its former Wikia site. I want to say this coincided with Google changing PageRank to give less weight to large numbers of links from sites in the same second-level domain.
- Suzuran 4y agoI was temporary host after the move. We had IPs from Wikia's office network vandalizing pages afterward. They literally paid people to vandalize us because we dared detract from Lord Jimbo's holy ad revenue.