4 ms·
I’m torn on this one; as a photographer and videographer I find the right to shoot or film anything I can see from a legal vantage point very near and dear to m
by sneak 4y ago
I’m torn on this one; as a photographer and videographer I find the right to shoot or film anything I can see from a legal
vantage point very near and dear to me.
We should always be legally allowed to film public places. Europe’s legislative approach to this is wrong, I think, but I see the problem. Perhaps we need different societal norms.
- __d 4y agoI'm ok with it being legal to photograph, video, or record audio of public spaces without people. I'm pretty sure I'd prefer that photographing, filming, or audio recording me in an identifiable way was illegal without my explicit consent. I think public officials should be subject to recording while performing their duties. I think celebrities should not, unless they explicitly consent. Security cameras might need some sort of exemption: record, but don't look except under explicit circumstances (like, you've been robbed).
- code_duck 4y agoSo if someone is visiting a town and desires to take a photo of a landmark, they can't take it unless nobody is visible in the photo? How would anyone ever take photos of the Great Wall or the US Capitol or the like?
- sneak 4y ago> I'm pretty sure I'd prefer that photographing, filming, or audio recording me in an identifiable way was illegal without my explicit consent. You’re talking about banning street photography, a rich art form with a long history that is presently regarded as protected artistic expression. Additionally, you can’t really reasonably hold any expectation of privacy when you are in a public place where anyone can see you. If I can legally see you with my eyes, I should be able to legally photograph you. That’s my right.
- __d 4y agoI used to find the argument that "if I can see you, I can photograph you" a lot more compelling. But now that a photograph is not a piece of paper, but rather both an image and its metadata, and trivially able to be, for instance, reverse image searched, leading to yet more metadata, etc, etc, I'm far less inclined to support it. I'm coming to a view that there's a lot of difference between being seen (like, with eyes) and being photographed. It's certainly a shame that photography as an artform might be collateral damage here, but it doesn't change the situation that a photograph of me, in public, is now a gateway to a lot more than just an image.
- DennisP 4y agoIf you want to walk by on the sidewalk and snap a couple pictures of my house, or even take a little video, I agree that's totally fine. But a surveillance camera that's there 24/7, uploading everything to Amazon's cloud, doesn't seem like the same sort of thing to me. In theory at least that can mean Amazon knows when I arrive and leave, all the time.
- sneak 4y agoSeveral large corporations as well as the US federal government law enforcement agencies know when you arrive and leave, all the time. A bunch of small/private companies do too, because your client IP on the background app refreshes from your phone changes from residential isp to mobile phone isp. Amazon is the least of the worries on that front.
- DennisP 4y agoAnd I'm not a fan of that, either. But my point is that the rights of street photographers have nothing to do with constant automated surveillance. (And my original point was that this is not just about people who choose to be surveilled themselves.)