4 ms·
I spent some time in 02016 digging through different sorts of academic lineages. It turns out, for example, that you can also trace Leibniz back to Copernicus:
by kragen 4y ago
I spent some time in 02016 digging through different sorts of academic lineages. It turns out, for example, that you can also trace Leibniz back to Copernicus: https://dercuano.github.io/notes/academic-lineage.html https://dercuano.github.io/notes/academic-lineage.html
Thrun's page seems to have an error about Leibniz: "Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz 1966, 1967, 1976"
It would be nice to be able to trace figures like al-Tusi back to Plato and Imhotep, to know if there really was an unbroken line of personal mentorship the way there is in the Buddhist lineages, or if at some point the oral line was severed. Perhaps during the Roman rampages through Greece, the line of transmission of philosophy only survived in Alexandria, or less plausibly, somewhere in India, only to resurface in Arabia while Europe was sunken into its Dark Ages. Or perhaps it had to be recovered from the few manuscripts the Christians hadn't yet recycled into hymnals, like the Archimedes Palimpsest.
We know that somewhere between Eudoxus and Galileo the idea of freely postulated axiom systems was lost, and it was not really fully rediscovered until the 19th century.
- tim_hutton 4y ago> "02016" Thank you for preparing for the Y10K problem.
- humanistbot 4y agoIt's a Long Now thing.
- tomrod 4y agoKurzgesagt suggests we soon have a merry 12023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CWu29PRCUvQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CWu29PRCUvQ
- naniwaduni 4y agoHow does it help to create a Y100k problem by using fixed-width numerals with five digits, instead of using variable-width numerals like we normally do for years?
- texaslonghorn5 4y agoexactly, it seems like a faulty solution to a problem that doesn't exist -- at present, we would say 900 and 1, not 0900 and 0001.
- garbagetime 4y agoI believe the point is to try to get people to engage in long-term thinking.
- languageserver 4y agono where on the site does it tell us that a lineage actually is. Does it mean that the mathematicians knew eachoter? that they adviced? cited?
- ghufran_syed 4y agousually it means that the “parent” was a phd supervisor for the “child” researcher who studied for a PhD under that supervisor
- bgriirtuh 4y agoCan you provide a reference for the claim that the concept of a freely postulated axiom system was implicit in Eudoxus? I'm very curious! I assume the 19th century rediscovery you refer to was Boole, Hamilton et al and their work in logic and the beginnings of abstract algebra.
- telotortium 4y agoI feel that the possibility of tracing academic lineage back to antiquity in the West is very dim, for the same reason that tracing descent from antiquity[0] in Europe has proven impossible - too few records survived. Even in the Catholic Church, the longest unbroken chain (i.e., for which records survive) of apostolic succession (i.e., which bishop consecrated each bishop) goes only back to the 1400s with Guillaume d'Estouteville, even though France in the 1400s was long after the Dark Ages and many records survive from the High Middle Ages onward. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Descent_from_antiquity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Descent_from_antiquity [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guillaume_d%27Estouteville https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guillaume_d%27Estouteville
- kragen 4y agoA thing I was thinking was that, though almost surely the line was broken in the West, it might not have been broken altogether. We know, for example, that the Pauliṣa Siddhānta in India contains Hellenistic astronomy; and we know that as far back as Classical Athens, Greek philosophers reported visiting India and studying with "gymnosophists", an ascetic tradition (called Digambara in Sanskrit) which either survives there today or has been coincidentally reinvented in the same subcontinent at least a thousand years ago. Surely it is conceivable that, during the period when Rome was laying waste to the Hellenistic world, some philosophers might have fled to India and trained their successors there? But it does seem very unlikely that we could trace it, given how little written material survives from that period in India.
- throwoutway 4y agoI’ve always wondered what things we’ve lost from library fires, hall burnings, church burnings etc. perhaps this is one such example
- lmpdev 4y agoIt boggles the mind The likelihood of a text surviving tends towards zero given enough time Before antiquity we often only have quoted fragments to look at The early episodes of the History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps is a pretty good introduction to how little we know about pre-socratic thinkers especially Surviving corpora can often be only hundreds of characters long