7 ms·
Nighttime charging of EVs may overburden the grid
- pjkundert 4y agoAnd, the attachment of many EVs to the Grid after enabling their innate V2G (Vehicle to Grid) ability will revolutionize them: https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-unlocks-vehicle-to-grid-abilities-bi-directional-charging-explained/ https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-unlocks-vehicle-to-grid-abil...
- coding123 4y agoDid anyone imagine that by 2030 California would have most of its power storage in cars? So all the people on here that want to get rid of cars should chuck their air conditioners and heaters right now.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoI don't know about that. Consider after a natural disaster, like Florida right now, or Texas last year. If every vehicle is low on energy (say, by trying to flee), and they are all trying at once to charge, that may overwhelm the grid. V2G only works assuming mass numbers of people aren't driving all at once, or trying to recharge their vehicles all at once. The fail condition needs to be: What happens if 80% of EV owners are trying to charge their EVs to 80%, all at once?
- mcguire 4y agoV2G (among many other things) is an optimization. Past the point where you stop actually wasting inputs, optimization is the enemy of resiliency. It trades lower costs for an inability to handle extreme fluctuations.
- pjkundert 4y agoIf a civilization has already decided that adequate base-load supply is optional (which we apparently have…) — then at least making that inadequate Grid more resilient by adding more battery-to-grid capacity is an improvement. I personally this that’s stupid, but old slobs like me have been out-voted by young bucks who evidently don’t mind freezing in the dark.
- nathanaldensr 4y ago> civilization You mean authoritarian technocrats.
- kieranmaine 4y agoV2G is where customers can really unlock the value of their vehicle. A trial in the UK allowed some customers to earn £725/year (https://www.kaluza.com/case-studies/case-study-kaluza-enabled-vehicle-to-grid-v2g-charging/ https://www.kaluza.com/case-studies/case-study-kaluza-enable...) through selling energy back to the grid - whilst this was the maximum amount V2G ultimately provided greater savings for all the customers involved.
- paulsutter 4y agoWe were thinking to add PV to the roof of the office for daytime charging of employee cars. The cheapest power, and the right time to use it
- pgt 4y agoThat's one way to get 'em back in the office! :)
- giantg2 4y agoExcept if they were really serious they would have just eliminated the need to spend that energy driving into the office by allowing WFH.
- r00fus 4y agoThis may be anecdotal but of my friends and coworkers who own an EV, it's a real draw to reduce your utility bill at home by charging at least 1-2 days in the office.
- philipkglass 4y agoThe more detailed Nature article that this report is based on is open access (no paywall) and readable here: "Charging infrastructure access and operation to reduce the grid impacts of deep electric vehicle adoption" https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-022-01105-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-022-01105-7 The suggestion to use more daytime charging is specific to California, since California's future energy trajectory is weighted toward more solar. A state like Texas which has more renewable energy output at night, from wind [1], wouldn't necessarily need more daytime charging. If California ends up installing more offshore wind than currently projected, that could also change the optimal charging strategy. [1] https://www.vaultelectricity.com/what-is-the-impact-of-wind-energy-on-texas-electricity-rates/ https://www.vaultelectricity.com/what-is-the-impact-of-wind-...
- Gibbon1 4y agoThing to consider with current electric car range and median driving habits most people won't have to charge their car everyday either. If I had a Chevy Bolt I'd only need to charge it once a week at my rate of driving. An arrangement where Tuesday is my day to use the charger at work would be 'fine'
- shaky-carrousel 4y agoWe have the means to balance grid usage by telling specific families at which time they should charge their vehicles.
- coding123 4y agoI'd say that plugging in a car should mean - charge it enough to get me to a hospital. Beyond that wait for the optimum charge time. However there should also be a screen that overrides this if you are going on a trip or something.
- kybernetyk 4y agoYup, let the tech overlords plan your life for you for the greater good. Fuck that fishing trip - your energy company decided you’re not important enough to have a charged car.
- tootie 4y agoSimple answer is just "congestion pricing". You want fast charging at peak hours, pay double. If not, set some price optimization. And set it to prioritize the first 30% of charge to never be stranded but always wait for cheaper power to fill to the top. If you've got a fishing trip, plan ahead or pay extra. That's just free markets.
- giantg2 4y agoIs there currently distinction between electric for charging vs traditional uses at the residential level?
- tootie 4y agoThe grid has no idea what you're doing with your power nor does it send different modes of electricity to different appliances. It would be the responsibility of the home or the vehicle being charged to modulate the amount of current (or type of current) they're pulling.
- wcoenen 4y ago"time of use" tariffs will be important to keep things balanced. People who want to minimize their power bill should have the option to pick the "time of use" pricing and shift some of their consumption off-peak. Others can choose to pay more for the convenience of not having to worry about all that stuff. How much more, that can be determined by market forces.
- nightski 4y agoSo basically screw over your average mid to low income person that has less flexibility. This is not how we convince people to be sustainable.
- lupire 4y agoWhat are you talking about? "Low to mid income" people also sleep at some time during the night or day.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LarryDarrell 4y agoHigher electricity prices at night will hit the poor who will be driving older EVs with degraded batteries. They'll have to charge all night so that they can make your McMuffin at 7am. They will also have to drive from further away because we also can't get a handle on housing prices in this country. Higher earners live closer to work. In addition to being able to afford the higher nighttime rates, their workplace may also offer charging as a perk. So you see, those with money form their opinions about electricity pricing schemes involving the invisible hand that has already been so kind to them.
- wcoenen 4y agoWould a person with low income prefer A) having an option to lower the electricity bill or B) pay more because there is no such option, and more expensive power needs to be sourced from peaking power plants? There are already day-ahead electricity markets with prices that vary throughout the day. You _already_ pay a premium over those variable prices, for the convenience of a fixed rate. All I'm saying is that it would be good if consumers had the _option_ of eliminating some of that premium, in exchange for demand shifting.
- megaman821 4y agoThe solution to this is going to be have customers enroll in smart charging. Keep your car connected to the smart charger when not in use and during times of excess power charge the car for a few cents per kw.
- kybernetyk 4y agoThen everyone‘s charger decides „now is the time“ and the grid gets overloaded
- philkuz 4y agoor coordinate them so that doesn’t happen?
- kybernetyk 4y agoYeah. Adding complexity to a system is always the best solution.
- quonn 4y agoSorry, it's not even hard. Coordination isn't even necessary. You just locally randomly choose a timeslot and there will be a uniform distribution.
- pseudosavant 4y agoI'm trying not to be smug, but are you under the assumption that the delivery of physical forms of energy is simple? Distributing, on average, ~1.5B liters of gasoline, with different qualities/chemistries/regions/etc, every day in the US has immense amounts of complexity. Now do that for coal, natural gas, heating oil, etc. Managing time of day for charging isn't a more complicated problem than any of those.
- shagie 4y agoThis gets into the utility frequency... that information is already out there, on the grid. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility_frequency#Frequency_and_load https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility_frequency#Frequency_an... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_demand_(electric_power) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_demand_(electric_power... The way that power companies "communicate" about load is by slightly changing the frequency. If the frequency is 60.5, then there's an abundance of energy on the grid and some less profitable generators can cut back or storage systems can charge. If the frequency is 59.5 then there's a lack of available power on the grid and other generators should go on line and unnecessary load should stop doing its thing (and if it has the ability, it could discharge instead).
- kybernetyk 4y agoEVs as we know them are a dead end. It’s one of those wonderful solutions that look really good until you take a deeper look.
- quonn 4y ago> EVs as we know them are a dead end. It’s one of those wonderful solutions that look really good until you take a deeper look. Shouldn't you try to at least give a reason why you think so?
- ButchC 4y agoWhy bother asking these types anymore? It's just going to the same debunked propaganda over and over.
- ButchC 4y agoThat is a silly statement, as absurd as saying electricity itself is a dead end. The fact of the matter is EVs and electrified vehicles in general are the best answer we've got for the future of consumer mobility. Nothing else really competes long term.
- giantg2 4y ago"As we know them" vs "future" You can both be right here. There are many current challenges that prevent people from choosing an EV or against rapid majority adoption. We also have to consider that alternative methods of taxation (how to pay for roads) and the eventual reduction in tax incentives are problems that still need to be solved. I'm also looking forward to the EVs that come out 1-2 decades from now with batteries that should have 4x+ density and/or half the cost. The biggest downer for me is all the damn tech that comes with them currently. If cost can come down, then I hope I can get one with less tech. Or that conversion kit will be common.
- quonn 4y ago> We also have to consider that alternative methods of taxation (how to pay for roads) and the eventual reduction in tax incentives are problems that still need to be solved. Are roads really payed from gas taxes? Everywhere? I perhaps naively assumed all the taxes go into a big bucket which is used to pay for all kinds of things, including roads. Somehow even relatively poor countries manage to have good roads. We will save elsewhere. Most of the taxes go into the social bucket in most countries (retirement, social security, health, education) anyway.
- ethagknight 4y agoI am so tired of misinformation like this. I know they use the "may" get-out-of-jail-free card in the title, but no, nighttime EV charging will not overburden the grid by 2035, as the article purports, because "the grid" (?) will look dramatically different in 13 years. Plus, networked software solutions are already baked into EVs for time of day charging; as such, its a solved problem unworthy of a headline. The additional load will require new investment, but thats core to the business of providing power. If they can't adapt over a decade with software solutions helping them along, EVs aren't the problem... The actual report from NREL (1) linked to the article is far more informative and interesting and eludes that clickbait headline, but still makes ham-fisted assumptions that make the whole report a little goofy. To list a few: - "Absent systemic changes in customer behavior" (you mean no changes except mass customer purchasing of EVs? what's the point of assuming nothing changes) - Slide 18 shows, for high EV adoption with no charging logic, effectively, "everyone definitely plugs in their EVs at 9pm because thats when TOU kicks in", while also showing "Almost nobody charges at work during the day". Most people will plug in whenever they get home. With WFH, that is basically any random time of the day. Also, they acknowledge people respond to TOU, but dont acknowledge that TOU can change? - "At-work charging makes up a small portion of total EV charging, so the system benefits are likely to be small" (are they really assuming no changes here over a decade? I would love to charge at work but my office building has no services. These will become commonplace over time. Is this really their EDIT: this is fun! here's the actual model from the NREL report! This launches a virtual machine, which might take a minute to boot up. Once the model has opened, click on ‘Cell > Run All’ to initialize the script’ https://hub.gke2.mybinder.org/user/skoeb-co-ev-model-rkichrt0/notebooks/CO%20EV%20Model.ipynb https://hub.gke2.mybinder.org/user/skoeb-co-ev-model-rkichrt... (1) https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy19osti/73303.pdf https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy19osti/73303.pdf
- twblalock 4y ago> "the grid" (?) will look dramatically different in 13 years. I don't think so. It takes forever for anything to get built in this country. I have zero confidence the grid will improve fast enough to make mass EV adoption practical in many parts of the US. During the intervening period we will see higher energy bills, rolling blackouts, and rationing. I mean, if our governments and utility companies were good at building this sort of thing, then why are the power grids in such a poor state today?
- xnx 4y agoCounterpoint: EV's might save the grid https://www.forbes.com/sites/bradtempleton/2022/09/12/evs-wont-overload-the-power-grid-in-fact-evs-and-ice-are-its-salvation/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/bradtempleton/2022/09/12/evs-wo...
- kornhole 4y agoMaybe we need fewer cars rather than newer cars.