3 ms·
Thanks for posting this - that's been my general theory regarding a big portion of the labor shortage, but I didn't have much info to back this up. If you are
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Thanks for posting this - that's been my general theory regarding a big portion of the labor shortage, but I didn't have much info to back this up.
If you are a mother making near minimum wage (which, these days, is around $15 in most major metros, regardless of what the actual law is), and you need to be on the job site for 8 hours/day, you're barely if even covering the cost of child care plus commuting and other job related costs. And as a tradeoff you get to have the stress of the job plus the joy of having someone else raise your kids. It just doesn't make sense.
Also, importantly, your Earned Income Tax Credit will be reduced if you make more money (not 1-1, but just another reason why working in a low paying job doesn't really make sense if you have children and a spouse/partner that can support your family).
- civilized 4y agoThis story also fits with the first figure in the article, which says that the % drop in labor participation has been biggest for less educated women.
- sokoloff 4y agoMy wife stayed home for several years after we realized that nearly every dollar of post-tax, post-401K cashflow her job brought in went right out to childcare (and she had a well above US median household income, PhD-required job in science). She was happier; kids seemed happy; she's now back in the workforce at a similar role and happy with that transition back as well. (We did lose N years of 401K max contributions, but that seems totally worth it.)
- WalterBright 4y agoThe traditional role of grandparents is to care for the kids while the parents work.
- sokoloff 4y agoTrue. They're 700 miles away in our case, though...
- matthewdgreen 4y agoThis assumes that your optimal employer exists in the same location as your parents. Unfortunately that is not always the case, at least before WFH.
- WalterBright 4y agoI didn't assume anything, just stated a historical fact. It is possible for parents and grandparents to structure their lives around it being convenient for the traditional role. The fact that American society doesn't do this is a bit of a tragedy. I know families that engage the entire extended family, including grandparents, in raising the next generation. (In fact, its an evolutionary thing. It answers the question of why does evolution keep grandparents around and healthy? Generally, when an organism no longer serves a useful purpose towards propagation of the species, it dies.)
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoWell, if we're in the business of stating "historical facts", I think it's more accurate to state that the traditional role of women was to care for the kids while the father worked. That is, I wouldn't give too much credence to these kinds of "historical facts" on "traditional roles".
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoWhy assume generations of people didn't know anything about being human?
- hirvi74 4y ago> (which, these days, is around $15 in most major metros, regardless of what the actual law is) Sorry to go off topic, but I cannot believe my state is still $7.25 an hour. There hasn't been a single increase in minimum wage since 2008.