3 ms·
This is pretty much an argument against democracy, isn't it? The idea that https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Yanukovych https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_
by pjc50 4y ago
This is pretty much an argument against democracy, isn't it? The idea that https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Yanukovych https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Yanukovych should have been left in power against the wishes of the Ukranian people because he was a convenient puppet leader for Russia.
> The odds of Putin deciding to do a Hitler
This has already happened with the level of war crimes in the occupied territories of Ukraine.
- roenxi 4y ago
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Democracy is better than all the other forms of government, but democracy in Ukraine it isn't worth getting everyone killed for and ratcheting up nuclear tensions. The Ukranians - whose opinion seems most relevant in this decision - seem to disagree. https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/10/18/ukraine-victory-poll-gallup/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/10/18/ukraine-vict... Giving in to nuclear blackmail when Russia takes a chunk of someone else's country encourages the taking of more chunks in the future. The 2022 invasion of Ukraine was motivated by the West's inaction when Russia took part of Georgia, Moldova, the Donbas, and Crimea in fairly rapid succession.
- roenxi 4y agoThe Ukrainians don't really have the power to have a say in this situation. Sucks to be them, but he people claiming to be acting in their interests are making them suffer even more. And... Washington Post, Washington, D.C metro area: "We asked the Ukrainians and they are 70% on board with our strategy of turning their country into a war-torn hellscape. US government, we're^^W^W^W you're great!" I literally do not believe the WP on this topic. The US media's record on matters of war is sketchy at the best of times. We don't even know what the actual question posed in the poll was, because we do not speak the local language.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> The Ukrainians don't really have the power to have a say in this situation. So: The US, EU, NATO, and Ukraine itself shouldn't have a say. Your comments in this thread seem to indicate only Putin gets a say. He gets to annex chunks of several countries, while simultaneously forbidding European countries from making alliances amongst themselves.
- roenxi 4y agoThe US shouldn't have any say over where the borders in Europe are drawn. NATZO shouldn't have any particular say on where non-NATO countries borders are, and NATO shouldn't be picking up random European countries either. Ideally Putin would also not be launching invasions. But the response to any one actor doing something horrible is not to start walking up the escalatory spiral towards wiping out all life in the Northern hemisphere and a lot of lives in the Southern one. Escalating isn't going to make anyone better off. It shouldn't be happening, I'd quite like to see what 2025 brings. If the EU wants to mobilise troops and stir up war they can, it'd follow a lot of stupid EU policies. It is going to make them worse off too, but at least maybe the nuclear war might stay in Europe? I'd certainly be on board with them preparing for war, but just don't do the foolish thing of fighting on the Russian border. Go have a proxy war in the middle east. Fortify Poland. Let there be some buffer states. There is always the like-Iraq option. Let a country invade, write an angry UN letter, wait for the costs to force the occupiers out. It worked the first time the Soviets tried to control the Ukraine and with the Ukrainians using diplomacy and far less firepower.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Let there be some buffer states. The buffer states have clamored to join NATO because of Russian aggression elsewhere. Ukraine provides an object lesson about what happens if you don't, one Finland and Sweden are now taking to heart. The supposed problems you describe are self-inflicted by Russia. > But the response to any one actor doing something horrible is not to start walking up the escalatory spiral towards wiping out all life in the Northern hemisphere and a lot of lives in the Southern one. Nor can it be "give them what they want". > It worked the first time the Soviets tried to control the Ukraine... If you don't count the millions dead in the Holodomor, sure.
- 5560675260 4y ago> If the options are democracy and being invaded by Russia vs diplomacy and some other form of government? Sure, jettison democracy. Other form? Like becoming a vassal state for a failing petro-autocracy a la Belarus? Why would you ever do this if you can stand your ground and fight? Being invaded isn't as bad as conceding and experiencing ethnic cleansings. > backed by a really, really angry population. Once someone like Putin or Hitler captures power it doesn't matter if population is angry or lukewarm. Resources will be mobilised, propaganda will be ramped up. What matters is functioning economy and industry as they are what provides means to wage war. And hopefully this war will put an end to Russia's ability to wage war for a very long time.
- pjc50 4y ago> Sure, jettison democracy. And there you go. Overt fascism. This is the trouble with HN.