7 ms·
China allegedly dumps bad chips on Russia
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoFor the record, anyone working in the HW sector will tell you, Chinese suppliers will often try to scam you by delivering you parts that are faulty or lower spec than originally agreed and see if you notice. If you don't notice, then it's fair game and more money for them. They don't consider this swap as doing anything illegal or wrong if you don't notice, so you really need to have solid QA in house to keep your suppliers accountable, as this is a constant struggle. It's sad, but this is how business is done in this racket. Russia is now stuck between a rock and a hard place, with very little choice of suppliers and Chinese businesses know it and are taking this practice to the next level (beggars can't be choosers). I can't find the comment now, but one HN member told a story here on how their POS credit card readers they sent for production to China, were being tampered with by malicious employees on the supplier side who were shaving internal parts of the case assembly to plant skimmers inside that would beam the credit card data. They were going so far as to match the weight of the tampered device to meet the spec by the milligram to avoid weight detection countermeasures. Insane.
- null_object 4y agoI think this is essentially the major theme of this book: https://www.amazon.com/Poorly-Made-China-Insiders-Production-ebook/dp/B004G5Z2A8/ https://www.amazon.com/Poorly-Made-China-Insiders-Production...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gumby 4y agoThis is really a short, useful book for anyone getting stuff remotely manufactured in China. Some examples of what went wrong from someone who lived there (so things shouldn't have gone wrong). A good example of a problem: supplier underbids to get the business; first and second shipment are fine, then the third has an unauthorized change because now the factory wants to cut their costs to make a profit. In the author's case IIRC it was shampoo: he ordered a set in different scents (lilac, almond, coconut perhaps?). Suddenly all he got was almond because I suppose the factory got a better deal if they bought more. Also remember that Apple gets the quality they do by having a lot of their own personnel on site to stay on top of everything that is going on. You can't afford that.
- captainmuon 4y agoYou get what you pay for, especially in China. Many vendors are completely upfront with this, and you have to pay extra for "good" good parts. Just like you can pay for a test certificate, but you have to pay extra if you want them to actually test your stuff - I would have expected it to be the other way around to be honest.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoEven paying extra for the good "good" part is no guarantee of honesty and quality. Unless you're a juggernaut like Apple, after a while they'll start shoving in sub-par components in the shipments to test your QA and see if they can squeeze more money out of you. It's just how they do business.
- dncornholio 4y agoIf all China manufactures are like you described, nobody would do business in China again. I'm sure there are plenty of honest Chinese suppliers.
- exmadscientist 4y agoThere are plenty! The trouble is finding them. Once you do, hold on to them – they can be very valuable. A good place to start is making sure you're paying a fair price for whatever it is you're buying. Anything too cheap is definitely trouble. (And, of course, this condition is necessary, not sufficient.)
- POPOSYS 4y agoWhy are you sure? Do you have any facts / numbers / experiences? Do you have a good QA for incoming components? If yes, you will see a pattern.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoThe problem is the market filters them out.. because the dishonest ones are more successful and the law does not care about foreign customers.
- vintermann 4y agoThis isn't just a China and chips thing, it's a general supplier thing. My mom ran a small cafe once, and complained that the wholesaler would regularly try to foist out of date coffee on them. It's something I keep arguing: there's a price associated with policing, keeping, people honest. If there is intense competition, the pressure to cheat is also intense, and what you gain from competition may well be eaten up by the cost of policing. So competition isn't a panacea, it has rapidly diminishing returns. (My mom's wholesaler, though, were pretty much a monopoly, who did this sort of thing just because they could. A different failure case!)
- krona 4y agoI think you're describing the guilt vs shame cultural differences. This cultural difference between Russia and China isn't as big as it is to north european/US culture.
- daneel_w 4y agoThey are now simply treating Russia with the same lack of dignity they have treated private customers in Europe and USA with for over a decade. A substantial amount of what's sold to western customers on e.g. AliExpress, BangGood, GearBest etc. are product lots that didn't pass QA. They are dumping e-waste on us, and we pay for it. A fantastic trade trick.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>They are dumping e-waste on us, and we pay for it. A fantastic trade trick. To be fair, western corporations were the ones who made the big move of offshoring all goods manufacturing to China in the first place and turn them into e-waste in a constant race to the bottom of lower and lower costs and higher and higher margins along with insane executive pay for their genius move. Hardly China's fault. Hate the game, not the player, and this game was made by the west, and China has just gotten really good at playing it. The best way to fight this is to bring back manufacturing (it's already cheaper to build certain stuff in some EU countries than in China) along with products that last longer and are more easily repaired. Western consumers would just have to stomach higher cost of goods, and western corporations would have to stomach lower margins, but it's definitely doable if desired, but it won't happen.
- oytis 4y agoLowering costs and increasing margins is the game of the business everywhere, east or west. It is largely the policies of Chinese government that made manufacturing in China especially lucrative, even considering the bad business culture.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>Lowering costs and increasing margins is the game of the business everywhere Sure, but there is no free lunch. You're getting cheaper stuff but for that you're sacrificing your local industry and the environment by offshoring the environmental damage to places with less environmental protection laws. There is no free lunch. The right way to lower cost is by pursuing automation, not by offshoring the environmental damage and using sweatshop workers in areas with human rights violations.
- roenxi 4y ago
- tommica 4y agoStupid for who?
- roenxi 4y agoUS leadership. They've got the most influence here on what Russia does, outside of what Russia itself.
- DrBazza 4y agoChina doesn't want alliances, it wants 'tribute', indebted countries, and vassal states. Russia is fooling itself if it thinks it has a strategic alliance with China. I would not be surprised if the Russian parts of Manchuria are taken back by China within the next 30-50 years.
- klpot 4y agoSo what? The BRICS countries are a thing, even if they do not trust each other. Biden already repels Saudi Arabia, too: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/10/18/saudi-congress-democrats-midterms-oil-biden/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/10/18/saudi-congre... "Over the weekend, South African President Cyril Ramaphosa, on a visit to Riyadh, said that MBS had expressed interest in joining the BRICS nations, an economic bloc of major emerging economies including Russia." That may be a false pre-election leak, but the current U.S. policy of repelling every country on the planet and treating Europe as vassals will backfire eventually.
- ogogmad 4y ago> That may be a false pre-election leak, but the current U.S. policy of repelling every country on the planet and treating Europe as vassals will backfire eventually. I live in a European country. While I love to shit on the US as much as anybody else, I'm wondering what you mean by European countries being US vassals. This sounds like Kremlin bullshit. Also, I get frustrated when people make vague, unsubstantiated claims like that.
- trasz 4y agoOf course they do. To China, Russia is a cheap mafia-owned gas station. It can no longer provide any real business opportunities thanks to sanctions; see how the Russian part of Belt and Road got shut down and everything moved south to Kazakhstan. Long term, Russia used to be a strategic problem to China, as its huge, aggressive direct neighbor. This problem has now been solved, but helping Russia develop would risk it becoming a threat again in a generation or two.
- prox 4y agoIt seems China is doing the math that Russia itself hasn’t done. Or it did but it was shelved but it’s leadership just plugged their ears,
- taf2 4y agoLet’s just say it was “special math “ and move on
- tenpies 4y agoYou're missing that the worst thing that could happen to China is a Russian collapse. China wants Ukraine to end like Afghanistan: an embarrassing and gradual defeat of the US/West - leaving behind billions in cutting edge military hardware - after a decade of being financially and militarily drained, while having nothing to show for it. Russia is the Taliban that can make that possible, and while you don't necessarily want them to be too powerful, you definitely don't want them to just collapse. Not to mention the US will get even more ideas if they "win" in Ukraine. From the Chinese perspective (and the perspective of much of the world), Russia is currently the anchor on US imperialist aspirations. The real big loss for China, is Germany, who has chosen to obliterate its purchasing power as part of this war. That's the loss of a huge trading partner and quite unfortunate.
- simonh 4y agoIn reality Ukraine has become Afghanistan for Russia. Embarrassing military defeat? Check. Leaving behind billions in hardware? Check. Financially and militarily drained? Check. All things that have already happened to Russia. Conversely other than expendable munitions hardly any of the Western capital equipment in Ukraine like M777, Caesar, MLRS, HIMARS and air defence vehicles seem to have been lost. Even if they were, the only reason those things existed is to fight Russia anyway, job done. None of them are particularly relevant to a conflict with China. That's why when the Marine Corps pivoted to focusing on the Pacific theatre they ditched all their tanks.
- NicoJuicy 4y agoI know a electronics company in Europe and the US owners of a big customer requested production in China. The choice was between having a commission ( and starting it there) or lose the customer. After everything was running, all components broke within a year. The Chinese company secretely replaced an important electronic piece with a cheaper one. They now have all the customers business back. But probably within 3 years there's going to be a new board, who will try something similar ( again).
- asianamerican 4y ago
- larryliu 4y agoUS military also once bought fake chips from China: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/blog/2008/oct/06/security.china https://www.theguardian.com/technology/blog/2008/oct/06/secu... There are good reputation vendors in China, but if purchasers type in the chip model in Alibaba and simply buy the cheapest, it's likely to be bad. Russian purchasers should know this, but maybe they don't care or they got kickbacks.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago*unknowingly
- sct202 4y agoThe more trustworthy Chinese companies are also refusing to do business with Russia so that they don't get sanctioned and lose business with the rest of the world. That leaves Russia with the worst of the worst.
- larryliu 4y agoRussian agents set up shell companies that hide their Russian nexus. IC vendors don't really background check cash buyers. Many ICs are sold in open markets like this: https://n.sinaimg.cn/sinakd10114/107/w1024h683/20220819/c5a8-0659fc838c5398a8f2705d82c8570ecf.png https://n.sinaimg.cn/sinakd10114/107/w1024h683/20220819/c5a8... Cash and carry, no fux given. You cannot sanction an open market like you cannot sanction open source software.
- nieve 4y agoBut similarly you can't be sure what you're buying in a market like that.
- IYasha 4y agoBut that's still lower failure rate than from Aliexpress!
- veritascap 4y agoOr they can’t make chips with decent yields.