5 ms·
Marketing can only go so far. Are more people finally starting to take their heads out of the cloud? Not only do cloud providers need to pay their own costs, th
by userbinator 4y ago
Marketing can only go so far. Are more people finally starting to take their heads out of the cloud? Not only do cloud providers need to pay their own costs, they also need to make a profit on top of that; thus, if one thinks critically, the only time renting can be cheaper than owning is if it's short-term.
- adrianN 4y agoRenting can be cheaper than owning if the person you rent from can leverage economies of scale that you can't dream to achieve.
- flakeoil 4y agoRenting is typically cheaper if you use the thing rarely. If you use it regularly it is typically cheaper to buy.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoNo. Forget the economies of scale, because they don't help you, as a buyer. What helps you is leverage. The economies of scale only get passed to the consumer if another provider is willing to pass the savings on, which only happens in commodity markets (like oil, wheat, etc.). Low-end server rentals are a competitive market. "Big 3" cloud is not: they use differentiated products and egress fees to lock you in to their oligopoly. They don't have to pass on their economies of scale to you. They don't pass on their economies of scale to you. They charge you slightly less than your cost to leave them, and that's it.
- lupire 4y agoDo you also grow your own food to avoid the overhead of paying farmer and grocer?
- seydor 4y agoPeople do cook instead of eating out . Analogies are not problem-solvers, and it's a false dichotomy because owning is not the only alternative to the cloud
- solardev 4y agoMost home cooks and restaurants don't grown or transport their own food. Even at a farm to table type place there's often different people doing the different work. What's wrong with letting the specialists handle logistics so you can focus on business logic instead of basic piping?
- georgyo 4y agoI think growing food is the wrong analogy, and cooking is better. Growing food is more like designing and manufacturing servers. Cooking is more like taking these goods and putting them to use. There are plenty of places that host their own servers, including people that have these servers in their home or office. But far fewer produce these machines. You could also say that cooking food is dumb. What's wrong with having professionals chefs do it? But that also doesn't take into account the added costs which makes it unfeasible for most.
- mcspiff 4y agoThe major cloud providers are designing their own servers, so we’re back at “growing your own food”.
- mahkeiro 4y agoThey are not doing it because it provides an advantage to their customer but because it allow them to differentiate (and lock people).
- georgyo 4y agoMcDonald's owns their own farms. They are big enough that controlling their supply chain is very important. Facebook does not use cloud providers and designs their own servers. The very large compute uses and cloud providers have incentives to grow their own food. Doing so can save them a few percent at scale. That savings is both not passed on to you and even if it was is not significant at small to medium scales.
- 4y ago
- hotpotamus 4y agoAs far as I know, none of my farmers and grocers are building penis rockets and flying them to space, so they might be working with a bit lower margins than AWS.
- dntrkv 4y agoYou do realize there are billionares in the food / agriculture business too, right?
- forgetfreeman 4y agoSounds like the criticism is broadly applicable then.
- hotpotamus 4y agoCertainly, but none as rich as Bezos and so their metaphorical phalluses take less impressive forms. I'm sure he'll be happy to give them a ride at least.
- kavalg 4y agoyes, and not for the cost savings, but for the quality that I can't get at any commercial farmer
- xani__ 4y ago
- solardev 4y agoTheir costs plus their profits is still cheaper than hiring your own people to rebuild what they've already done, except taking much longer and usually ending up with worse service. Unless you're an infrastructure or network logistics company, it's a waste of resources to build your own. Cloud services are so commoditized already it's unlikely to be any sort of meaningful differentiator for your company. Especially if your field isn't even tech proper.
- jsiepkes 4y agoThat's a way too broad statement. If that were true Facebook would simply be running on AWS.
- faeriechangling 4y agoI hear this core competency stuff a lot and it’s just not so. I need organizations as small as teams of video editors run their own “datacenters” which may consist of as little as a Jellyfin server. A waste of resources? Is centralization into cloud datacenters or even CDNs all the way to the last mile a more efficient use of resources than plugging a 10gig connection into a NAS? Why haven’t all restaurants been destroyed by Taco Bell when Taco Bell has economies of scale and efficiency most restaurants couldn’t dream of? Plenty of mid sized data centres make sense too. Something I see in common with many of these businesses is either the requirement to store a lot of stateful data or to have data locality and to not be concerned with things like being able to serve international customers or being a plodding business which will predict at a steady predictable rate. Some people run businesses that run headfirst into cloud companies entire pricing strategy because their business doesn’t work like a VC funded tech startup. The “but somebody can figure all this stuff out for you” cuts both ways. Why can’t a skilled company make it easier to staff and operate an on premise data centre? Running a datacenter only gets less labour intensive for what you get every year. You know that you can hire people for pretty much any aspect of building or maintaining a datacenter that you can imagine? The datacenter is commodified so why is it special that the cloud is? I just feel this analysis is a spurious oversimplification and what you’re far more likely to see is a sort of Pareto distribution of datacenters and the cloud is never going to swallow the whole market.
- sedivy94 4y agoI was under the impression that outsourcing leveraged economies of scale and ought to be cheaper, if anything. Cloud-everything becoming commonplace does leave me worried that SaaS will drive out SaaP / self-hosted solutions, if it hasn’t already.
- kumarvvr 4y agoThe cloud is much more than that. The premium you pay for a cloud service is - Ability to scale up and scale down in a matter of minutes. - Reduction in variable capital costs required to meet peak demand. - Ability to test and prototype products or services at scale without significant investments. - Ability to have, on tap, products and services that in a traditional sense, would take a lot of time and manpower (A company can invest in equipment and manpower to spin a few services. But as you add more services, it costs more and more to build and maintain such systems. With cloud services, you can use, test and experiment before finalizing)
- friendzis 4y ago> Reduction in variable capital costs required to meet peak demand. If I understand your point correctly it is the opposite - cloud not only lets you trade capex for opex, but also allows for opex variance. Yes, clouds do let you scale up and down (if the application is designed to do that) easily, however how many businesses do really have high load and geography variability? That is the core point behind cloud vs on-prem: capex vs opex and opex variance.
- sofixa 4y ago> if one thinks critically, the only time renting can be cheaper than owning is if it's short-term. If you skip economies of scale that is. AWS, Azure and GCP allow you to use stuff that has cost billions of man hours and matériel to develop and deploy. How much would it cost you to build a global network? A globally distributed DB? Custom ARM/Tensor chips which come out much cheaper than mainstream alternatives for some workloads? If all you need is to host a few apps in a narrow geographic area, or do compute/graphics intensive stuff on an inflexible scale, it will probably cost less over a long period of time (3-5 years). But it's still much more inflexible, time consuming and hard. You need to hire the right people and they need the time to order, configure and deploy all that infrastructure.
- mschuster91 4y ago> thus, if one thinks critically, the only time renting can be cheaper than owning is if it's short-term. There's no real alternative to cloud-based hosting if your application needs to be reachable from more than one geographical region or has wildly volatile usage patterns.
- styren 4y agoThere are plenty of cloud providers that offer cheap and feature-rich services if you look away from the hyperscalers, disclaimer: I'm part of a team building one. However most users aren't swayed by only price so it's a tough market to break into.